Russia’s warship that wasn’t, the ‘Granny Anya’ saga, the meaning of mobilization, and a love affair with Soviet symbols
Thursday, May 5, 2022
For ongoing coverage of the invasion of Ukraine and its consequences back in Russia, follow Meduza’s live updates. Please note that the authorities are now blocking our website in Russia, and we’re turning to you, our global audience, for financial support.
In today’s newsletter:
Latest news
How mobilization works in Russia
The war’s impact on Ukraine’s elderly
Once a hostage, now an invader: one man’s path from Beslan to Ukraine
Russian propaganda’s obsession with Soviet symbols
Special delivery from Ukraine: Buryatia’s boys in body bags
Major recent events in Russia and Ukraine
🛢️ Orbán says no ban: Hungary has accused Brussels of threatening EU unity with its plans to impose an embargo on Russian oil imports, reports The Financial Times. Hungary Prime Minister Viktor Orbán says Budapest will not support any proposals that would undermine the nation’s energy security. “If the commission insists on the adoption of its proposal, it will have to bear full responsibility for a historical failure in the course of European integration,” he warned.
⚓ Gone missing in nobody’s waters: Dmitry Shkrebets (whose son “went missing” aboard the Moskva guided missile cruiser when it sank on April 14, 2022) revealed on social media that Russian military prosecutors claimed in a letter that the warship never entered Ukraine’s territorial waters and wasn’t part of Russia’s “special operation.” His son is still unaccounted for. “What kind of scum do you have to be to send us something like this?” Shkrebets wrote on Vkontakte. Meanwhile, the Pentagon says it provided targeting assistance that helped Ukrainian forces locate and strike the Moskva. Two senior American officials told The New York Times that Ukraine already had obtained the Moskva’s targeting data on its own, and that Washington provided only confirmation.
✡️ Putin says sorry: During a phone conversation between Putin and Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett on Thursday, the Russian president apologized for remarks made by Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov, who recently dismissed Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s Jewish heritage by claiming that “Hitler also had Jewish blood.”
👵 Granny Anya’s saga: Ukraine’s Center for Strategic Communications released footage on Thursday purportedly showing Anna Ivanova, the elderly woman who became a pro-invasion icon in Russia after she greeted a group of Ukrainian soldiers with a Soviet flag. According to the new video, Ivanova and her husband are now sheltering at a hospital in Kharkiv after Russian artillery strikes damaged their home. In heavily edited comments, she says she greeted the soldiers with a Soviet flag because she thought they were Russian, and she hoped to stop them from “trashing” her village. In the original video that made her famous in Russia, however, a visibly confused “Granny Anya” watches a Ukrainian soldier trample her Soviet flag before explaining that her parents died defending it.
👮 Investigating the factchecker: Just a few days after the Social Research Expert Institute (a pro-Kremlin think tank) released a report titled “How They’re Killing the Free Press: Factcheckers as an Instrument of Western Counterpropaganda and Censorship,” police opened an investigation into Ilya Ber, a fact-checker demonized in the report for his work debunking a Kremlin-media misreading of an article published in The Guardian about Russian troops killing civilians in Bucha.
🔎 Chechnya’s peculiar part in Ukraine: A new investigative report by iStories about Chechnya’s involvement in the Ukraine war argues that Ramzan Kadyrov has been reluctant to risk his men in combat but eager to claim credit for battlefield feats. Kadyrov is apparently relying on State Duma deputy Adam Delimkhanov to resolve rivalries and tensions among his top military commanders. The report by iStories also alleges simmering tensions between Chechen units in Ukraine and soldiers fielded by the Donbas separatists and main Russian military.
🔎 Bucha’s breadcrumbs: In a special report for Reuters, journalist Mari Saito pieces together eyewitness testimony, discarded documents, and social media posts to tie Russian soldiers and Moscow’s chain of command to the bloody occupation of Bucha. Saito and her colleagues spent three weeks in the Kyiv suburb interviewing more than 90 residents, reviewing photographic and video evidence these locals shared, and examining documents left behind by the Russian soldiers.
The Kremlin denies it vociferously, but Western analysts and state officials warn that Vladimir Putin could declare Russia’s full military mobilization as soon as May 9, when the country celebrates the USSR’s victory in World War II. Ben Wallace, the UK’s secretary of state for defense, says such an announcement wouldn’t surprise him, adding that Putin could claim that Russia is now at war “with Nazis all over the world,” necessitating mass conscription. Meduza asked Pavel Chikov, the head of the human rights group Agora, who would be affected by a full mobilization and whether it would still be possible to avoid being drafted in Russia’s armed forces.
Yasuyoshi Chiba / AFP / Scanpix / LETA A 92-year-old woman sheltering in a bunker inside a factory waits for the Ukrainian Red Cross to evacuate her. Sievierodonetsk, eastern Ukraine. April 22, 2022.
According to the Ukrainian Prosecutor General’s Office, at least 221 children have been killed and 408 have been injured during Russia’s all-out war against Ukraine. These statistics are updated regularly, but data on how Russia’s war affects elderly people in Ukraine don’t feature in the authorities’ daily reports. Meduza has compiled photographs that tell the stories of Ukraine’s elderly — including those who are still awaiting evacuation, and those who are unable or unwilling to leave their homes, despite the threat of bombing and shelling. This photo report also includes the text of a letter from Viktoria — a reader from the Luhansk region who wrote to Meduza about her grandparents.
On September 1, 2004, terrorists took 1,128 people hostage inside a school in the North Ossetian town of Beslan, including children, parents, and teachers. 333 people were killed and 783 were injured, making the siege one of the largest terrorist attacks in Russian history. Hostage No. 281 on the list compiled by Beslan teachers after the siege was then-15-year-old Alexey Viktorovich Ptakh. In 2022, his name appeared on a different list: the list of soldiers in the 34th Brigade from Vladikavkaz, which, according to the Ukrainian Defense Ministry, is participating in Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Meduza special correspondent Svetlana Reiter spoke with Alexey Ptakh’s mother, Tatyana, about how her son ended up in the war.
Evgeny Silantyev / TASS A banner with the image of the “grandmother with the Soviet flag.” Shebekino, Belgorod region.
Russia’s war propaganda has begun co-opting Soviet symbols with increasing frequency. Monuments to the “grandmother with the Soviet flag,” for example, have popped up across the country. And both Kremlin officials and propaganda narratives continue to frame Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine as an extension of the Great Patriotic War (the Soviet theater of World War II). Meduza special correspondent Andrey Pertsev looked into the Kremlin’s “Soviet” agitprop and learned how it’s connected to Moscow’s drive to annex new territories.
As Russia’s military casualties in Ukraine continue to mount, Buryatia has emerged as the country’s second-hardest hit region in terms of losses. The only place losing more men is Dagestan. Nevertheless, the speeches at the near daily funerals in Ulan-Ude and other Buryatian cities still resound with support for Russia’s war against “Nazis” and gratitude for the fallen soldiers not being “left behind” but shipped home for burial. At the end of April, the local magazine People of the Baikal published a report about how Buryatia is burying their dead soldiers, and what their loved ones and the regional authorities think about these losses.