
The Old Russian icon was again opened quite late by the standards of Russian culture: Evgenia Trubetskoy's program work “Settlement in Colors” was released in 1916, and the works of Florensky were created after the revolution. But the discovery of deep symbolism of the icon contrasts more, how widely the symbolism of the icon was used in the propaganda of the Bolsheviks.
The Russian historian and thinker Georgy Fedotov noted that the relatively careful attitude of the Bolsheviks towards cultural heritage contradicted their slogans, but followed the decadence culture they learned. Attention to the little things, signs, stylistics as building life was not characteristic of Russian democratic thought, revolutionaries of the 19th century, proud of their rudeness; But it became part of the fashionable culture of the beginning of the century, against which the Bolsheviks were formed.
In addition, the conservatism of the personal tastes of Lenin, his household sentimentality, shaken his political radicalism, also led his followers to search for those samples of the old culture that seemed humanistic. Soviet criticism equally successfully spoke of the humanism of ancient Russian icon painting, Beethoven or Chekhov, referring to either a pathetic creation of human images, portraiting as humanism, or the absence of strict plot structures (although classical Italian humanism, on the contrary, demanded the strictest reproduction of ancient plot samples in philosophy and historiography).
For example, in music, Romantic Beethoven with his violations of the plot sequence was much more acceptable for Soviet culture than a bang with its compositional harmony; And the music of the 20th century, in which the law of the whole completely subordinates the emotional motives, turned out to be, with random exceptions, impermissible. The Soviet school argued that literature and art are important in that they allow you to contemplate the images of heroes, finding a living moral ideal in them. Only the development of structuralism (Lotman) and hermeneutics (Averintsev) in the USSR recalled that in addition to contemplation of images, there is also the work of the plot; And that in classical culture it was the plot, myth was a social dimension of literature.
The Soviet poster used a number of obvious signs of the icon, such as a direct look, a flat prospect, bright colors: the image seems to be approaching the viewer and directly attacking it. But more importantly another: symbolically complex icons were used to create compositions, and not the simplest images. The image of a happy motherhood, according to the sample of the Mother of God with the baby, refers to the post -expert time and speaks of a deep fracture in culture, when the complex symbolism is incomprehensible, but the simplicity of images makes us recall the other sense of the icon - the contemplation of the intelligent world.
Paradoxically, it was the materialists and technocrats of the 1960s that were the first in the official USSR to talk about invisible, impassable, incomprehensible: invisible tears of widows, incomprehensible power of reason, the experience of the household situation as the contemplation of its invisible grounds-all this marked the poetry of Yevtushenko, Voznesensky and Akhmadulina. But before that, instead of contemplation of the invisible, Soviet art required the direct entry of the contemplator into history, renunciation of contemplation. Stalinist art was allegorical, and the sixties art became typological.
Typology - the methodology of parallels between the historical events of the Old Testament and the miraculous events of the New Testament rising to the Gospelist and Origen. Only the Old Testament turned out to be a revolutionary past, and the New Testament was a navigating communism. The events of the past, such as a moral choice in favor of the revolution, the struggle with the remnants of the past, the democratization of culture, turned out to be the prototypes of what is happening in the present: for the sixties Lenin - with us, the remnants have already died, and culture triumphed as the fullness of revolutionary meanings that already create salvation. The difficult path of the revolution in the past and the triumph of Leninist ideas in the present; The romance of the Civil War in the past and the smile of Gagarin in the present is the coordinates of a new experience.
But such a typology was dissolved in the images of heroes. When Andrei Voznesensky wrote: “Andrei Rublev was Lenin,” it meant that in the icons you can find the characters that are represented by Lenin: draw a line from the softened features of the ancient Russian icon painting to Lenin's smile. It is important to note here that such works as “Poem without a hero” by Anna Akhmatova and “Doctor Zhivago” by Boris Pasternak were unacceptable for Soviet culture: she could not understand how to do without heroes or say that character is not the most important thing in a person.
At the same time, symbolically saturated icons were still understood at the dawn of Soviet power as a way to depict character with the help of symbols. These icons themselves could ascend to the Byzantine patterns, such as “Descent to Hell”, but could come from Western mysticism, like “Sofia the Wisdom of God” or “Incapital Eye”. These images, in fact, deployed some of the liturgical names of God or the Mother of God, but at the same time they, like liturgical texts, should have turned dogmatic knowledge into part of internal experience.
For example, if the Mother of God was called an indestructible wall, then in medieval culture this meant not only the dogmatic knowledge of the Mother of God as a defender of people from disasters, but also the need for the firm foundations of faith. Such a duality of meaning goes back to the ancient anthem, in which praises to the hero, proclaiming his divinity, are also an opportunity to accept the Divine will of the hero, his actions in relation to you, committed by him as a hero. But only in the Soviet poster does this acceptance of someone else's will be understood as the adoption of someone else's character.
For example, the poster “May 1, 1920” reproduces the composition “Descent to Hell”, but not the gates of Hell are violated, but the symbols of the old world, the resurrected righteous are replaced by the crowd of workers, and as the Messiah is the union of workers, soldiers and peasants. But it is remarkable that although the composition of the icon is reproduced in sufficient detail, all things receive attributes in time: the past is the royal coat of arms, the present is a hammer. The contemplation of this poster means the contemplation of attributes, properties of character, in other words, even in a poster with its conventions, the individualization of images is more important than the plot.
Another Soviet poster dedicated to the spread of literacy depicts a worker-enlightener in the form of an archangel of Michael. All the symbolism of the icon is preserved: a fiery winged horse, the ability to sit on a horse without rods, the gospel turned into a primer, a censer, turned into a torch, view of the earth from space and even clouds of the divine presence in the corners. That is, the poster depicts the spread of literacy as the spread of angelic news. But again, historical time appears: the worker can be understood as a teacher who teaches a letter, and as a successful student, triumphant after mastering the letter. As in classical antiquity, praise claims the fullness of the form of the subject, his happiness, good and to others, but only this fullness comes down to personal professional history.
It should be noted that in Russian culture, which did not influence Soviet propaganda with its allegories, there was a similar process of turning the classical “praise” into an expressionist grotesque, chanting into a caricature image of character. The most famous example is the absurdists of the Oberiu group. But I will give another example that commentators did not pay attention to. In 1887, the forerunner and patron saint of Russian Symbolists Konstantin Sluchevsky tried to create Ecfrasis “Crucifixions” (“Exhibition of the Cross”) Rubens:
The picture is valuable in parts visible :
Christ , with a blackened wound of goodbye ,
Barely visible in a cloud of smoking ;
The most clear of all shone from the canvas
The side of the horse with the horseman mustache ,
Label over the elder bearded
And a full -part wife ...
In these lines all the rules of classical ancient ecfrasis are observed ( other Greek . Έκφρασις from έκφράζω- I express , express): an indication of the value and brilliance of the work, its incomprehensibility as a whole, caused by barely noticeable elements, to the dynamics of clear characters that seem alive and moving. But classic ecfrasis demanded precious materials or their imitation, idealizing curiosity and mild mythological eroticism, which is impossible in serious easel painting of the new time depicting the dramatic clash of characters.
The solemn image is revealed by caricature, which is very important later for the formation of expressionism in Russia: Mikhail Kuzmin in the poetic manifesto “The End of the Second Tom” (1922) depicted a dream in which the black -bearded Assyrian was crucified, identified with the robber, inscriptions and other requisitions of Ecfrasisis of Sumyevsky already They don’t even flash, but as if falling off the sky - the logic of dreams turns the logic of Ecfrasis, which lifes to heaven, into the slurry of impressions.
The Soviet government tried to introduce intelligence into this slurry, subordinating the impressions of the direct logic of the collapse of the old world and the formation of a new world. But only the ways of official art and paths of great art began to diverge, and the further, the more fat.
Alexander Markov,
doct. Filol. sciences, deputy. Dean of the Faculty of History of Art of the RSU,
Vedas. scientific. sore. Moscow State University