
There was a wave of comments, as light as a quiet surf, about the dizzying success of the Party of LIFE in Samara. A wave of responses to the unification of three parties around the same Party of LIFE rolled over her, with a slight foam. Everything is clear, the orchestra plays harmoniously, obediently obeying the waves of the director's baton. The main topic of commentary is the electoral chances of the new party. Journalists and commentators can be understood. Still, it’s a new story. For the first time after a long break, the word “electoral chances” regained some semblance of meaning, well, at least some kind of revival, at least something vaguely reminiscent of signs of competition.
I don't care about the electoral chances of the new party. As are the chances of United Russia. Firstly, there is no sporting interest in either. Secondly, both organizations that we call parties are not such, and their life will be very short-lived. In political science there is a precise name for such organizations - clientele. A clientele is a group of people united around (for, next to, in the name, etc.) of a leader (patron), inspired by the resources he has (power, money, etc.), hoping that something will fall to them from these resources in exchange for the support they provide to the patron. There is nothing else that unites them - neither serious goals, nor ideology, nor a common history and a common future - nothing that glues into a single political body those who form a normal party. Does this remind you of anything? Of course, this is United Russia.
The fact is that the clientele, unlike the party, is alive as long as its patron has alienable resources and needs support. Otherwise it disappears. This is exactly what happened with the clientele called “Our Home is Russia.” The same thing will happen with United Russia and the new “party” (I can’t remember its proud name).
However, now we will have two teams supporting Putin, two packs of pie-hungry “politicians” (and there is still a third clientele looming - liberal, what joy!).
What is the trick here, as they say nowadays?
The classics of political science, summarizing historical experience, suggest: one patron can have only one clientele. This is not a problem of decency (like the ban on polygamy). It's just life. Two clienteles begin to compete for a single patron resource; fight for it; prove to the patron that each of them is more worthy than the other; discredit each other. As a result, instead of supporting the patron, they spend their energy on intraspecific struggle, which, as a rule, is more merciless than interspecific struggle. But this is “one time”. And “two” is that all this is too expensive for the patron: more money needs to be sacrificed, and these fighters are of no use.
Then the first question that an outside observer may have: why does our patron need this (whoever he is - Putin personally, or one of the Kremlin towers around him)? The second question: since this is happening and since what is happening violates the laws of political nature, then how can it end?
I'll try to answer these questions.
The idea of a second clientele controlled by the Kremlin (well, let it be a party, if that’s more pleasing to the Kremlin puppeteers) has arisen repeatedly over the past four to five years. And every time the leadership of United Russia fell at the president’s feet: “Sovereign! Why are you your second beloved wife?! Don't we love you? Are we not the ones who glorify? After this, new projects were quickly curtailed. And now there has been a breakthrough.
Why? Let me express a version that is confirmed by a number of indirect evidence.
Imagine this clientele - “United Russia”. It doesn't matter if she knows what it's called scientifically. But they definitely understand deep down in their souls, jumping up at night from their own screams and covered in cold sweat, that they are not a party. That they exist while Putin is in office. If he leaves, they face the threat of collapse. Will the successor patron need them? Or maybe he will build his own clientele on the way to the throne? “What will happen to us?!” - they think with horror. And a seditious thought arises: “The only salvation is to move our successor, the future patron, with whom we will be tied with strong ropes in advance.”
Does United Russia have the resources to solve such a problem? Yes, I have. They were presented to this clientele by the Kremlin itself. It was he who drove the political and administrative elites of the regions into his pet party: with a stick, blackmail, handouts, but he drove them. Now almost all governors, most mayors of large cities, their deputies, most regional deputies have all joined the clientele. But the results of federal elections depend to a very large extent on the actions of regional authorities. It’s not for nothing that the Kremlin lined up governors under its vertical line this way. But already during the parliamentary elections, Putin will become a “lame duck” (as Americans call the president leaving after his second term). And there will be no clarity with the successor. The Kremlin will find itself in a situation where its influence will sharply decline. And this is where the regions will have the opportunity to take revenge, to recoup in full for all the humiliations and robberies that the federal government was eager for.
Now you understand: the symbiosis of “United Russia” arises quite naturally, with the force of inevitability. The first need, using regional administrative resources, to push through their successor, the new patron of the old clientele. The latter can, by engaging in bargaining in the alliance, return what was taken away by Putin.
We have seen traces of the conflict between the “new alliance” and the Kremlin. Two examples. The first is the constant adventures of the Party of LIFE in the regions: the regional elites do not need a new clientele competing for their resources, they have already entered into a conspiracy with the old one. Another conflict arose around the ideological pearl - “sovereign democracy,” which Putin branded and which United Russia put on its shield.
As a result, the Kremlin became concerned about the increased strength and independence of United Russia, and therefore found it useful to create a counterweight. Thus, the principle of political monopoly in the party sphere was recognized as dangerous and is now being replaced by a system of checks and balances.
Now let's look at the consequences. Let's start with what has already been discussed. A fierce intraspecific struggle between two (and in the future three) clienteles is inevitable. The parties will use various administrative and information resources. They will probably start throwing dirt on each other and bringing prosecutorial investigations on each other. The first way this could end is the destruction of the system of checks and balances and a return to the previous political monopoly. All alternative projects to “The Other Russia” will be stopped. However, losses are inevitable along this path. Voters who see at least some alternative in the Party of LIFE will not return to the bosom of the monopolist. On the contrary, there will be an additional outflow of votes from him. Losses are inevitable.
But another scenario is more interesting, in which at least two clienteles remain. This will lead to managerial schizophrenia almost everywhere. Authorities and captive media, accustomed to following simple commands and serving one political party, will find themselves in an extremely unusual situation. Try to put yourself in the shoes of the Kremlin instructors. How to set a task for controlled structures? As a percentage of the distribution of some resource (say, airtime) between competing clienteles? Who will set the percentage? President? Nonsense. Who will take the risk? Try to put yourself in the shoes of the chairman of the Central Election Commission, the governor, the head of the TV channel. What should they do?
Let's assume that everyone acts in the simplest way: here are equal resources for you, and then figure it out for yourself. But what is access to equal resources in the context of criminal use of administrative resources? These are constant complaints against each other. What is there to predict when this is already happening. We already see how United Russia accuses the Party of LIFE of its own sins. Funny?
Both clienteles can independently come to a decision that may seem incredible. They will find it useful to restore fair competition, moreover, they will take real steps towards this. This has already happened. The Second Duma was engaged in real improvement of election legislation and expanded the possibilities of public control. Of course, not out of inclination towards democracy and not out of respect for voters. It’s just that everyone thought that fair rules of the game were beneficial to him and not beneficial to his parasitic rivals. The same thing can happen with our rival clienteles.
Now imagine how two clienteles compete on air. For example, who better to praise the president. Another routine plot is who will criticize the Putin government more harshly. It doesn’t take much imagination to imagine this abyss of insanity, similar to a loud, irritated conversation between a person and himself.
The obvious consequences in such a scenario are the outflow of votes from both parties and the emergence of the opportunity for third and fourth forces to get involved in the fight, with a complete worsening of insanity.
I shared my fantasies with you not to convince you that this is exactly how everything will be. The main conclusion is this: by going against the laws of political nature, the Kremlin is creating an uncontrollable, unpredictable and unstable situation in the political sphere. And this, I would add, will be another contribution to the overall dangerous instability being whipped up by the regime.