Today there is a lot of talk about alternative fuels. The need to use the inexhaustible energy of the Sun and the prospects for artificial photosynthetic systems are discussed. Many people place their hopes on ITER, an international project to create a thermonuclear reactor. However, if you come down to earth, it is here that you can find the possible key to creating a renewable, environmentally friendly and safe source of energy. Biological fuel technologies, of course, do not promise to “feed” humanity with several kilograms of plasma (as is planned in a thermonuclear reactor). They will require a lot of labor and tonnage of production, but the benefits - not only in saving fossil fuels, but also in combating greenhouse gas emissions from industrial facilities - are already obvious.
Gasoline from food?
All types of biological raw materials are divided into two types. First generation raw materials are agricultural products with a high content of starch, low molecular weight sugars (cereals, sugar plants) or fats (oil crops). The former are easily hydrolyzed to simple carbohydrates, while the latter are also hydrolyzed and then reduced. Second-generation raw materials are non-edible plant products, for example, stems of edible cereals, perennial herbs, and algae.
Among the biofuel industries operating today, first-generation raw materials are more common: sugar cane, sugar beets or sweet sorghum, which contain a lot of sucrose. It is easily extracted from plant material for subsequent fermentation into alcohols. Sugar cane is now the most common raw material, economically and environmentally justified. It is not difficult to produce, but it can only be grown in certain climatic zones; it is sensitive to weather conditions and soils. This limits the possibility of its large-scale use.
Corn, grains and cassava can be processed by enzymatic hydrolysis into a solution of sugars that are fermented into fuel. To produce biodiesel fuel, you can also use vegetable oils - both primary (palm, soybean, rapeseed or sunflower) and waste (animal fat or cooking oil). The second way is preferable, since it involves effective recycling of waste. However, for a number of reasons (the high cost of cultivation and processing), fuel from traditional types of vegetable oils is considered in the long term only as an additional source of bioenergy.
The most promising are the more widespread second-generation raw materials, in particular lignocellulose. This is the name given to inedible plant material consisting mainly of cellulose, hemicellulose and lignin. It is he who is considered the future of the biofuel industry, its tomorrow. However, today we are not very fond of this raw material: lignocellulose is much more difficult to process into fuel than food products. This process is highly energy-intensive and must be significantly optimized before introduction into industry. Lignocellulose benefits in another way - the availability of raw materials. In particular, there is the possibility of recycling currently unused waste. This includes waste from the wood processing industry (shavings, etc.), and agricultural waste (straw, corn stalks), and paper and paper waste, as well as “energy” crops - switchgrass, reed or fast-growing “weedy” poplars.
Microalgae are considered another highly promising source of biomass. These are single-celled plants, capable, like all others, of photosynthesis, during which carbon dioxide is absorbed, oxygen is released and organic substances are synthesized. Algae are the fastest growing plants on Earth: within one day their mass can increase significantly. In addition, they have another unique feature - they contain up to 80% oil, which is so important for the production of biofuels. The advantages of algae as a biological raw material are obvious: they provide extremely high “yields”, the cultivation of which does not require the use of useful agricultural land. Along the way, algae cultivation can solve environmental problems of recycling carbon dioxide emissions from industrial enterprises. Today, algae are one of the most promising sources of biomass for fuel production.
| CULTURE | Specific oil content (l/ha*year) | Specific energy content (MWh/ha) |
| Soy | 446 | 4 |
| Sunflower | 952 | 9 |
| Rapeseed/canola | 1 190 | 11 |
| Castor seeds | 1413 | 13 |
| Stanza | 1892 | 18 |
| Coconuts | 2 689 | 25 |
| Palm oil | 5 950 | 55 |
| Chinese tallow tree | 6 527 | 61 |
| Algae with content a triacylglyceride of 15%) | 11204 | 104 |
| Algae (50g/sq. m*day with a triacylglyceride content of 50%) | 100000 | 931 |
Depending on the type of fuel, the methods for processing it vary. The most common ones are fermentation, gasification and transesterification. New synthetic methods for processing biomass are also being developed. As a result, it is possible to obtain not only fuel, but also other technically important substances and materials.
Fermentation of sugars is the most obvious process, simply put, fermentation. To carry it out, however, it is necessary to carry out serious preparation of the raw materials - both the first and second generation, so that the sugars pass from them into an aqueous solution. Starch and other polysaccharides require primary enzymatic hydrolysis, but sugar plants can be fermented directly to produce bioalcohols.
The fermentation process of lignocellulose is much more complex. First, the mixture must be separated: cellulose and hemicellulose are suitable for fermentation, but lignin is not. Energy is obtained from lignin only by combustion.
Cellulose and hemicellulose are processed into fuel in two stages - enzymatic hydrolysis followed by fermentation, while the fermentation process differs from that described above. Sugar and starch are composed of hexoses, carbohydrates containing six carbon atoms, such carbohydrates are easily fermented by yeast. But to ferment the products of hemicellulose hydrolysis, it is necessary to ferment pentoses - carbohydrates with five carbon atoms. This requires only special microorganisms. One of the technological challenges facing developers of biofuel production technologies is the creation of more efficient and resistant to unfavorable environmental conditions (fermentation temperature, concentration of alcohols and other toxic substances in the fermentation mixture) bacteria that could process any carbohydrates.
Transesterification is a standard procedure for oil processing. Fats, which are esters of fatty acids and the trihydric alcohol glycerol, are exposed to methanol. In the presence of catalysts (mainly alkaline), fatty acid methyl esters and glycerol are formed in the reaction mixture. These esters can already be used in diesel engines. Why are fats bad in the first place, since they are the same esters? The fact is that glycerol esters have excessively high viscosity and low volatility, and transesterification can significantly improve the physicochemical properties of the future fuel. Now diesel based on fatty acid methyl esters is the most common biodiesel fuel.
Gasification (i.e. transformation into a gaseous state) is a harsh method of processing biomass, during which, when exposed to high temperature, all covalent carbon-carbon bonds in natural molecules are broken. The result is a mixture of CO (carbon monoxide) and H2 (hydrogen), known as synthesis gas. Saturated and unsaturated hydrocarbons are obtained from synthesis gas on metal catalysts, which are used as synthetic fuels or lubricating oils (Fischer-Tropsch process). Water is released as a by-product.
Alcohol in a car tank
What substances can be obtained from biomass, and what substances are required for the operation of engines? Let us recall that conventional modern fuels obtained from oil are a mixture of liquid hydrocarbons. Why is their combustion so efficient? When it breaks strong covalent bonds carbon-carbon and carbon-hydrogen, this ensures the release of energy. Natural compounds contain oxygen in addition to carbon and hydrogen, which reduces their energy capacity. Highly efficient enzymatic processing of carbohydrate plant biomass (which is a natural, highly efficient catalytic process) produces alcohols rather than hydrocarbons. At the first stage of the development of biofuel technologies, attempts were made to complete the fuel base using alcohols. However, it turned out that in modern engines alcohols can only be used as an additive, and not as the main fraction of fuel. In the future, the use of alcohols is ineffective for most countries, not only because of the need for government subsidies for modifying engines and infrastructure, but also because of the insufficient calorific value of alcohols.
Oils are a completely different matter. Although transesterification produces esters rather than hydrocarbons, the number of carbon atoms in the fatty acid chain is so large (about 20 depending on the type of acid) that such esters burn efficiently in the same way as hydrocarbons. The first “oil” diesel fuels were created based on the oil of the fastest growing oilseed crop - rapeseed. However, its low yield and limited distribution do not allow us to hope for a significant expansion of this sector.
In this regard, many experts pay attention to the prospects of creating biodiesel based on microalgae oil. The “sown area” of such a crop is almost unlimited - growth occurs in water incubators, and only CO2 and sunlight are used as raw materials. The productivity of algae is several orders of magnitude higher than that of agricultural plants, and the ability to use vegetable fats as opposed to carbohydrates, and the ability to use vegetable fats as opposed to carbohydrates, makes it possible to obtain biofuel from non-food renewable raw materials, which is practically no different from traditional fossil fuels. In this case, expensive modification of the existing fleet of vehicles with internal combustion engines will not be necessary, and this, by definition, is a huge gain for the “algae” technology.
Technology of the present and future
Countries that are partially or completely dependent on imported energy resources are making great efforts to develop biofuel technologies. According to the current energy industry strategy, the United States plans to produce up to 36 billion gallons (162 billion liters) of biofuels by 2022, obtaining fuel from corn and lignocellulose. Over the next 30 years, Brazil plans to satisfy up to 25% of its fuel market needs with bioalcohols. They are planned to be extracted from sugar cane. The EU plans to supply up to 10% of cars with biofuel from rapeseed and lignocellulose (as an additive to existing motor fuels). China plans to replace up to 20% of fuel imports with biofuels, and India has the same plans. All countries provide government subsidies that will make biofuels cheaper for consumers. At the same time, “punitive” measures are planned for motorists who use only traditional gasoline: a special fine will be imposed on such vehicles.
What scientific challenges remain to be solved on the way to large-scale implementation of technologies for producing fuels from renewable biological raw materials? First, increasing the efficiency of initial biomass production requires the work of geneticists and breeders. It is desirable that the plants used are resistant to drought and cold, and increase biomass at the fastest possible pace. Chemists should develop separate processes for processing hexoses and pentoses, given that they may be present together in a mixture. For more complete processing of biomass using enzymatic hydrolysis and fermentation, it is necessary to select the most “aggressive” enzymes that will decompose even the strongest fibers. Related to this is the issue of selecting microorganisms that will participate in the fermentation process. The efficiency and completeness of fermentation depend on them. A separate task is the isolation of the target product from the fermentation mixture, which is often not its main component. When the concentration of alcohols in the mixture is above 1-5 wt. %, fermentation productivity drops significantly, while the total content of target fermentation products is small and usually does not exceed 20 - 50 g/l.
In this context, great hopes are placed on membrane separation methods, which can significantly reduce energy costs when isolating a minor component of a mixture by increasing the selectivity of separation on a membrane selective for target components.
At the stage of mass introduction of biofuels, industrial specialists will have to develop the logistics of the process from agricultural production of biomass to delivery of fuel to the consumer. It is obvious that in the early stages of biofuel use it is impossible to do without government subsidies, but the future benefits, and, most importantly, the prospects for preserving natural resources and improving the ecology of problem regions, are undoubtedly worth it.
Biofuels in Russia
In Russia, developments devoted to the introduction of biofuels, unfortunately, lie only in the interests of scientists. Considering that our country is rich in oil and gas and the economy is critically dependent on the hydrocarbon export market, the use of renewable energy sources is not taken seriously by either the state or private energy corporations. However, it was not for nothing that Dmitry Mendeleev said that burning oil is the same as heating a furnace with banknotes. Burnt hydrocarbons could be successfully replaced with biofuels, and the “freed” raw materials could be used in the production of advanced oil processing products (polymers, fertilizers, fibers). By the way, the export value of such products would be immeasurably higher than the price of raw hydrocarbons on which our budget now earns.
Academician Ilya Moiseev in the article “The Evolution of Energy. Time of Algae" claims that it is biofuel based on algae that can revive alternative energy in Russia, despite the obvious lag behind the West: "Due to the specific morphology and chemical composition of algae, new technologies are quite simple in hardware design and represent a number of well-known and proven technologies other branches of the chemical and petrochemical industry methods. Does our country have a concept of supporting new energy-saving technologies emerging in the world? For now, the question remains open” [1].
Alexandra Borisova,
"Gazeta.Ru"
1. Ilya Moiseev, Vadim Tarasov, Lev Trusov. “The evolution of energy. Seaweed time." The Chemical Journal, December 2009, 24-29.