The results of the Unified State Exam in biology this year, on the one hand, should please us: many graduates passed Part C, more than last year. In Moscow, experts often had to check two written sheets with the most difficult tasks instead of one. That's a plus. On the other hand, if you look into the nuances, optimism diminishes.
We do not take into account the scandal with the posted completed tasks of parts A and B, this repeats itself year after year. A relatively new phenomenon can be considered a significant number of works (according to surveys of several experts - about 10%), where the tasks of part C coincided word for word with the standard, which is handed out only to experts and only for the duration of the test.
The most interesting thing is that these standards do not exist in schools and cannot exist in principle, i.e. leakage occurs at a higher level. When the experts themselves noticed complete, down to commas, compliance with the standard text given to them, they asked questions to the manager - what to do and who to report about cheating? To which they received a simple answer: this is not in your competence, your business is to check. If everything is answered correctly, give the maximum score, the rest does not concern you.
It is clear that both students, whose future fate depends on it, and teachers are interested in good USE results, because the performance of their students on the USE results is extremely important for their final certification. Therefore, both of them will come up with more and more sophisticated ways to deceive the system. And at the same time, people suffer who are trying to teach honestly and pass just as honestly; they have already lost the race for points in advance.
And these points are so important. For example, in my alma mater - the Military Medical Academy, as in many other universities, there is a specialized subject, the results of the Unified State Exam for which give the right to preferential admission. This year the subject is chemistry. Writing it yourself, as many years of practice has shown, is possible with 75-80 points, provided that the student is specially trained. And the “leaked” standard will make it possible to get 95-100 points, accordingly, it is this applicant who will be admitted, and not the one who taught and really knows something.
However, the results of testing the Unified State Exam Part C in biology provide food for other thoughts. As before, despite all the leaks, communities on social networks and high-tech cheat sheets, graduates produce absolutely amazing gems. Here are some of them:
“The main properties of a living organism include variability and adaptability”
“Viruses differ from bacteria in having a clear program of action”
"DNA is made up of 20 non-essential amino acids"
“Enzymes break down proteins into fats and carbohydrates, releasing energy.”
"The Moving Force of Evolution"
“Immunity is designed to destroy bacteria, fungi and lichens”
"Habitat Halo"
“Variability is written into DNA and passed on from generation to generation.”
“During photosynthesis, plants inhale carbon dioxide and exhale glucose.”
“Photosynthesis is the process of producing nutrients from sunlight.”
"Quantums of light are converted into glucose"
"The membrane separates the cell from the non-cell"
“Cells store energy at night”
"Proteins are enzymes and proteins"
It is noteworthy that most pearls are due to the inability to correctly formulate their thoughts. Moreover, this could be easily found out during a traditional oral exam. For example, “cell” and “non-cell” are wonderful philosophical concepts, and viruses are really programmed for a certain sequence of actions, unlike bacteria, which will have more choice. Just as there are indeed enzymes among proteins (although they are also among proteins, these two concepts cannot be connected by the conjunction “and”), variability is indeed hereditary. But what is written with a black gel pen on the Unified State Examination form cannot be cut out with any ax; it does not take into account what the graduate meant, what he got confused, and where he simply wet himself.
By and large, the Unified State Exam turns into a kind of rite of passage. If you managed to get out and bypass the system - well done, you “understood life”, you are ready for Russian realities, the road to the best universities is open to you, you have an advantage over those who did not go through initiation, but naively tried to play by the rules. If this was precisely the idea behind the Unified State Exam, then it was definitely a success.