The State Duma adopted in the second reading a bill on the protection of the feelings of believers with amendments reducing the maximum penalty for relevant crimes from five years in prison to three, Interfax-Religion reports. 304 deputies voted for the adoption of the bill, 4 were against, and one abstained.
During the first reading, it was proposed to introduce a separate article 243.1 into the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (insulting religious beliefs and feelings of citizens or desecration of objects and objects of religious veneration, places intended for performing religious rites and ceremonies).
In the second reading, it was decided not to introduce a separate article into the Criminal Code, but to expand the existing one - Art. 148 (obstruction of the exercise of the right to freedom of conscience and religion).
This article introduces provisions on sanctions for “public actions expressing clear disrespect for society and committed with the aim of insulting the religious feelings of believers.” It is proposed to punish this with a fine of up to 300 thousand rubles or the salary of the convicted person for a period of up to two years, compulsory labor for up to 240 hours, forced labor for up to one year, or imprisonment for up to one year.
Thus, the amendment adopted in the second reading softens the punishment, since in the original version of the bill the maximum term of imprisonment for insulting the feelings of believers was three years.
Also in the second reading it was provided that if these acts were committed in places specially designed for worship, other religious rites and ceremonies, they are punishable by a fine of up to 500 thousand rubles or the salary of the convicted person for a period of up to three years, or by compulsory labor for a term of up to 480 hours, or forced labor for a term of up to three years, or imprisonment for the same period with or without restriction of freedom for a term of up to one year. Initially, it was proposed to set the maximum punishment for these acts to five years.
An amendment to the norm of the bill amending the Code of the Russian Federation on Administrative Offenses was also adopted. For “deliberate public desecration of religious or liturgical literature, objects of religious veneration, signs or emblems of ideological symbols and paraphernalia, or their damage or destruction,” it is proposed to punish citizens with a fine of 30 thousand to 50 thousand rubles or compulsory labor for up to 120 hours, and for officials - a fine of 100 thousand to 200 thousand rubles.
This amendment expands the range of sanctions. It also includes “desecration of objects of religious veneration,” which in the version of the bill at the first reading stage was classified not as an administrative offense, but as a criminal offense, and the maximum penalty for it reached five years in prison.
In addition, an amendment was adopted to tighten criminal liability for illegally obstructing the activities of religious organizations or the performance of religious rites and ceremonies, provided for in Article 148. In particular, it was proposed to increase the maximum fine provided for these acts from 80 thousand to 300 thousand rubles.
In addition, if these acts were committed with the use of official position or with the use of violence, it is proposed to punish this with a fine of up to 200 thousand rubles or the salary of the convicted person for a period of up to one year, or compulsory labor for a period of up to 480 hours, or correctional labor for a term of up to two years, or forced labor for a term of up to one year, or imprisonment for the same term.
At the same time, the State Duma rejected the amendment of the deputy from the Communist Party of the Russian Federation Oleg Smolin, who proposed excluding provisions relating to religious beliefs and feelings from the law. “The concept of “insult to feelings” cannot be legally defined. Radical believers can always consider that they are offended by another faith itself or by disbelief as such,” Smolin said when discussing the bill. In his opinion, the bill violates the rights of “non-religious people.” “Why are religious feelings protected separately, while non-religious feelings are not protected?” - he asks a question.
At the same time, the text of the bill presented for the second reading did not take into account either the demands of the public, in particular, the Human Rights Council under the President of the Russian Federation, or the recommendations of the Legal Department of the State Duma.
Someexperts believe that the new composition of Art. 148, designed for the second reading, is not amenable to any reasonable proof. As a result, the law opens up new opportunities for arbitrary enforcement, and at the same time for the expansion of religious concepts into our secular legal system.