Yesterday ended the World Newspaper Congress, which was held in Russia for the first time. About how the situation with freedom of speech was discussed at it, a free report by our observer.
About 1,700 editors, journalists and other representatives of the journalistic corporation from more than 100 countries around the world from 8 to 9 in the morning drove up to the Kremlin Palace of Congresses to go through the control of the Federal Security Service.
The congress itself was supposed to open at 10, but it started half an hour late. Leonid Makaron, head of the Guild of Periodical Press Publishers, was scheduled to speak at 10, then Vladimir Putin, and then Gavin O'Reilly, president of the World Association of Newspapers (WAN). Then the Golden Pen of Freedom Award for 2006 was to be presented - it was supposed to be received from the hands of the President of the World Editors Forum George Brock by the Iranian journalist Akbar Ganji, who spent 6 years in prison for criticizing the authorities and did not change his views. And, finally, the premiere of the musical opus “Newspaper Overture. News block in the year of Mozart” by Russian composer Vladimir Martynov, who wrote it specifically for the congress.
But everything went awry - the President of Russia was very late. Spivakov, who performed the planned numbers, was once again forced to "improvise" by performing unplanned numbers. They offered him to make a speech - and then he did not let us down. Then the Iranian was awarded.
The “concert” of WAN CEO Timothy Balding could not continue indefinitely, but at 12.05 the hall breathed a sigh of relief: the president finally appeared. At that moment, as the hall sat down after greeting him by standing up, several times it was distinctly heard: "Putin is the executioner of freedom." As it turned out, these were members of the NBP who managed to scatter leaflets explaining this thesis and were evacuated from the hall by the FSO officers.
And then WAN President Gavin O'Reilly stepped up to the podium. But after all, it was not for this that they waited so long for Putin in order to deprive him of his word? It turned out that they were waiting for the president to personally listen to criticism addressed to him, and only then give him the opportunity to respond.
Throughout the report, O'Reilly addressed the president directly. He explained that an organization that defends freedom of speech around the world cannot but criticize the situation in Russia. He said that around the world, Russia and the presidential administration are criticized for its control over the media. He pointed out that the conclusions of the report are the result of many meetings with journalists, editors and publishers in Russia. He referred to the obvious corruption problems in the media industry, where there is a "order" and the influence of politicians and businessmen on the activities of editorial offices. He recalled that both the president personally and the government spoke more than once about freedom of speech as an indispensable condition for democracy. “This causes a lot of skepticism both inside and outside the country,” he said, because no one can say that the Russian media have become financially independent, influential and independent. In this regard, he asked rhetorical questions:
- Why is the state still accused of creating an atmosphere of self-censorship in the media?
- How can one argue with the fact that there is an objective journalistic analysis on the national TV of Russia, which is controlled both directly and indirectly by the state?
— How can one not see that the oligarchic control over the press has simply been replaced by state control?
And is it acceptable that state control over the national media leads to the fact that the regional media are under the influence of mayors, governors and business groups?
He acknowledged that we should not forget that even the great Russian poet Pushkin fell victim to censorship more than once, recalled Pasternak and Solzhenitsyn. “Mr. President,” he again addressed Putin personally, “you may ask what is the need for a strong, free, critical and truly independent press. Why does the international community again and again put freedom of speech in Russia at the forefront? The answer is simple. It is this press that is the basis of economic, social and political prosperity.” O'Reilly did not limit his opinion, referring to the president of the World Bank, who said: "You cannot talk about economic development if there is no freedom of the press."
He also said that WAN was under pressure from criticism that the congress is taking place in Russia: it is here that there are problems with freedom of the press. And one of WAN's counterarguments in these disputes was the thesis that here one can criticize the president personally. "For the record" he expressed gratitude to the president for the warm welcome and also found words of gratitude for the organizers.
Vladimir Putin's main counterargument is that the state cannot control 53,000 periodicals, "even if the state had such a desire." The President, however, did not mention the situation with TV and did not say how many of these thousands of media are social and political. After all, probably, the state does not need to control glamorous, scanword and other entertainment publications, which are the majority in Russia? And it is unlikely that the governors are not able to control a couple of political newspapers in their regions, if the president, of course, considers the governors to be representatives of the state.
On the governors, by the way, it was discussed the day before. Before the opening of the congress, on Sunday, WAN's annual "round tables" were held, one of which was called: "The media in the post-Soviet space: from dictatorship to democracy?". And it was there that the head of the Altapress publishing house, Yuri Purgin, asked the audience a question: how many portraits of the governor can be placed in Altaiskaya Pravda, published in A2 format on four pages. Hall, laughing, assumed: three? four? Purgin answered: "Six."
Laughter sounded at that “round table” more than once. By the way, in addition to Purgin, two other journalists were invited to report on the state of freedom of speech in Russia - the general director of Izvestia, Pyotr Godlevsky, and a member of the Public Chamber, a journalist for the Rossiya state channel, Nikolai Svanidze.
Loud laughter rang out when Pyotr Godlevsky argued that his newspaper did not belong to Gazprom (Izvestia, he said, belongs to Gazprom-Media, where Gazprom is not even the main shareholder). In addition, the editorial office does not require any subsidies from Gazprom, Godlevsky developed his idea, but due to the lack of profit, Gazprom-Media helps the newspaper.
Godlevsky won applause and when, answering a question about the reasons for the appearance of the United Russia functionary Ilya Kiselev in his newspaper, he expressed the opinion that every person has the right to choose the place of work that he likes.
But Mr. Svanidze was extremely serious. For example, he sadly stated that “the specific Russian society is tired of alternative information” and, in general, “the presence of alternative positions tires a person to some extent.” That is probably why representatives of the federal non-state media did not participate in the round table. Russian specificity, you know.
Editorial
On June 7, at the World Press Congress, Mikhail Gorbachev spoke to an audience of editors and publishers of the world's leading media, announcing that he and his friend Alexander Lebedev, deputy Alexander Lebedev, in their personal capacity, are part of the shareholders of Novaya Gazeta.
Mikhail Gorbachev stressed that this would not affect the publication's policy in any way. And the necessary investments are being made to provide Novaya Gazeta with additional opportunities for development: increasing the frequency, increasing circulation and, accordingly, the emergence of a new audience.
The controlling block of shares remains in the ownership of the newspaper staff.
As for the congress itself, it turned out to be excellently organized. The level of discussion and speeches, especially about the relationship between newspapers and the Internet, was extremely high. We plan to print the most interesting fragments.