Novaya Gazeta has already described how St. Petersburg is trying to hold a referendum on the status of St. Isaac's Cathedral (about keeping it, the Church of the Savior on Spilled Blood and the Peter and Paul Cathedral as part of state museums), and how the city authorities are trying to prevent this in every possible way.
According to the law, the documents of the initiative group on holding a referendum are first checked by the City Electoral Commission, and if there are no errors in them, they go to the Legislative Assembly. The city parliament within 20 days is obliged to check the referendum question for compliance with the law (whether it is among those directly prohibited, and whether the consequences of one or another answer to this question are unambiguous).
The documents of the "Isaac's" referendum were received by the Legislative Assembly on April 4. And until April 25, Parliament had to say yes or no. And he didn't say either. The Legislative Committee of the Legislative Assembly prepared a draft resolution of the city parliament on recognizing the referendum issue as “inappropriate”, but the issue was stubbornly not included in the agenda of the meeting. Moreover, when the opposition nevertheless forced him to be included in the draft agenda, the United Russia members, who have an overwhelming majority in the Assembly, excluded him from the agenda twice in a row.
Seeing that the ZAKS in every possible way “wraps up” the issue of a referendum, its initiators appealed to the Oktyabrsky District Court with a complaint about the inaction of the parliament: it did not fulfill its direct duty within the time period established by law.
It would seem that everything is very clear, should the court ascertain this inaction and oblige the ZAKS to consider the issue?
However, the court dismissed the case, stating that the demands of the initiators “suggest interference by the court in the rule-making activities of the representative body” and violate (!) the principle of separation of powers.
Note that not only the initiators of the referendum (including the author) protested against the termination of the case, but also the defendants - representatives of the ZAKS. And even the prosecutor. But this did not prevent the court from making a decision to dismiss the case.
The position of the court forced not only oppositionists, but also quite loyal lawyers to shrug their shoulders: what does the separation of powers have to do with it?
This principle means the independence of different branches of power in making decisions and the distribution of their competence - but does not mean at all that the "third", the judiciary, cannot ascertain the illegal inaction of the "first", legislative (as, we note, the "second", executive) . And who else can complain about parliament? The ZAKS does not and cannot have a higher body that could cancel his decision - in Russia (and in the world) there is no “vertical” of legislative bodies. Only judgment remains.
The thesis about allegedly unacceptable “intervention” does not withstand any criticism at all: yes, of course, “interference” in the work of a government body does take place - but this is what the court is intended for. If the legal rights of citizens are violated, the court intervenes, taking measures to stop lawlessness. At the same time, we did not demand from the court to oblige the ZAKS to make a specific decision - to approve or not approve the referendum issue, we demanded to oblige the ZAKS to make one of two possible decisions, but to accept it, and not to do nothing - which simply stopped the process.
Naturally, an appeal was filed against the ruling of the Oktyabrsky Court, outlining the objections listed above, and everything was repeated in the city court.
Our complaint - demanding to cancel this ruling and oblige the Oktyabrsky Court to consider the case on the merits - was supported by both the representative of the Legislative Assembly and the prosecutor. Nevertheless, after some consultation, the judges upheld the ruling of the Oktyabrsky Court. After the announcement of the decision, I asked: how to protect the violated rights? Where to complain about the ZAKS, if the court refuses to even consider the complaint? “Nowhere,” they answered me.
Of course, we will file a cassation appeal and, if necessary, we will go to the Supreme Court and the ECtHR.
This, however, is not the whole story. On June 28, two months later than it was required by law, the Legislative Assembly nevertheless considered the issue of the "Isaac's" referendum, and refused to hold it.
We appealed against the decision of the Legislative Assembly on recognizing the referendum question as inconsistent with the law, as illegal, in the same Oktyabrsky court. And they received an almost identical definition of dismissing the case. With the same words about "intervention" and "separation of powers".
The absurdity of this definition is most clearly illustrated by the fact that seven years ago, in 2010, the same Oktyabrsky court accepted for consideration practically the same case in form: then we appealed against the refusal of the ZAKS to hold a referendum against the notorious Okhta Center.
Since then, the norms of legislation governing the holding of referendums and appealing against the actions or inaction of the authorities have not changed much.
But then the court considered the case on the merits without any problems, although it denied our demands, and now it has even refused to consider it.
Having taken a position that can be called simply: “no” and there is no trial.
The question of why a court is needed if it is impossible to cancel the illegal decisions of the authorities, and in what other way these decisions can be challenged, seems to be quite reasonable in such a situation.