
The next volume of memoirs of Field Marshal Count Dmitry Alekseevich Milyutin has every chance of becoming the loudest among the five already published and two planned for publication. Considering the current interest in the Caucasian theme and the love of publicists for drawing parallels between the Caucasian War, which Russia waged in the 19th century, and the current Chechen campaign, one can be sure that the book published by Rosspan is a book of memoirs of the chief of the General Staff of the Caucasian Army, and even titled by the author "In the Caucasus" will not go unnoticed.
Milyutin began working on his vast memoirs in the Crimean Simeiz, where he retired after retiring in 1881. Before describing the Caucasian events of 1856-1860, to which this volume is dedicated, the former Minister of War of Alexander II reached 1889, when he was already over 70. However, Count Milyutin lived for almost a hundred years, so he had no time to write memoirs there was still enough of it.
In Simeiz, Milyutin had a huge archive with various documents and numerous letters at his fingertips. He actively used all these materials when writing his memoirs, which, as the editor of the volume L. Zakharova reasonably notes, greatly increases their value. But this same circumstance rather scares away the non-specialist from Milyutin’s memories. Both the previously published books and the Caucasian volume, for all their unconditional historical significance, are not very exciting reading: for this they are too detailed, overloaded with details, dates, names. It is difficult to expect anything else from a colossal seven-volume work spanning several decades.
The main character of the "Caucasian" volume is Milyutin's immediate superior during these years, the commander-in-chief of the Caucasian army and governor of the Caucasus, Prince Alexander Ivanovich Baryatinsky. Milyutin talks not only about the military operations themselves, but also about the complex relationship between the governor and the St. Petersburg bureaucracy, which, with its desire to save costs, fairly irritated the prince. I think that phrases like “not for the first time he (Prince Baryatinsky - M.E. ) had to be convinced of how little Caucasian affairs were understood in St. Petersburg” will soon be replicated and savored by journalists writing about the Caucasus.
The culmination of the events described in the volume is the capture of the village of Gunib and the capture of Shamil in August 1859. A year after this triumph of Russian weapons, Milyutin was transferred to St. Petersburg, where he became a comrade of the Minister of War. A completely different story begins - and the next volume of memoirs, oddly enough, was published five years ago.
And in another 134 years a new Caucasian war will begin. How it began and what preceded it is described in the book by Krasnoyarsk journalist and former investigator Evgeny Strigin with the optimistic title “The KGB was, is and will be. From the Ministry of Security of the Russian Federation to the Federal Grid Company of the Russian Federation (1994-1995).” This is the second volume in a series about the fate of Russian intelligence services in the post-perestroika period, published jointly by the Eksmo and Algorithm publishing houses - the first examined the situation in 1991-1993.
In fact, Strigin’s book goes quite far beyond the scope of the topic indicated in the title, representing almost a short course in Russian history for the indicated two years. As a result, the volume is quite bloated, but it is nevertheless interesting to read in its own way. It’s interesting to remember what was happening in the country in those years, to compare your reaction to events at that time with their current understanding.
The author's text, as one would expect, consists mainly of monotonous rhetoric in the spirit of “Soviet Russia”, but, fortunately, there is not too much of it in the book. Strigin's work is frankly compilative, and a significant part of it is occupied by excerpts from newspapers and memoirs - the author's most popular are the memoirs of Alexander Korzhakov, Oleg Poptsov, and Alexander Mikhailov. Strigin, naturally, does not report anything new, but his book, like any similar collection, cannot be denied some usefulness: after all, who read all the newspapers from Segodnya to Zavtra in the mid-90s? And here is a solitaire game of quotes, choose what you want. The author himself, however, prefers “Our Contemporary”, but honestly offers the reader all the goods available.
Strigin's attempts to maintain objectivity make a very touching impression - he probably heard somewhere that the authors of scientific studies behave exactly like this, and is trying his best to comply. Sometimes he forgets about it, but after a while he always comes to his senses.
For example, we are talking about the Soros Foundation and the accusations against it. “Truly, if you don’t want to be scolded, don’t do anything ,” the author laments about this and destroys in detail the article from “Our Contemporary”. But he immediately adds: “And yet the opposition, exaggerating the importance of the fund, said interesting things ,” and continues to quote “Soviet Russia” and the same “Our Contemporary” without any reservations. A page later, Strigin again comes to his senses: “Let’s not draw a conclusion from one statement ,” but immediately introduces a concessionary construction: “Although I somehow don’t believe in genuine charity, that is, disinterested and from one’s own pocket . ” And he adds shyly: “At least in large sizes . ”
The next page is occupied by another quote from “Our Contemporary” - something about Sergei Chuprinin and Natalya Ivanova’s support for “anti-Russian literature” using Soros funds - and it is followed by the author’s summary: “The author of the book has no other evidence confirming these suspicions of in relation to this fund. But if not he, then someone else was still, to one degree or another, engaged in and (or) will be engaged in intelligence and subversive activities. This is a matter of principle, not a specific fund . "
After these words, naturally, the chapter about the Masons begins. It would seem that this rewarding topic could be explored properly, but Strigin shows noble restraint here too. The chapter is structured very simply: a short introduction, a three-page quote from “Our Contemporary” and a comment from an impartial author: “The above reflects one of the versions. But no one has substantively refuted this version. In any case, the author of the book has not read such a refutation. But it belongs to a specific person to any organization does not mean that he acts in the interests of this organization . "
It is clear in the interests of which “organization” the physicists who created the Soviet atomic bomb acted. However, the author of the book “Stalin’s White Archipelago” published by the Young Guard, one of the most famous scientific journalists in the country, Vladimir Gubarev, is least concerned about the moral aspects of this story. The work of a group of nuclear physicists evokes his sincere admiration, and he simply does not ask the question about the political side of the USSR atomic project. Well, considering nuclear physics as art for art's sake is probably a position as good as any other.
Moreover, Gubarev wrote a truly fascinating book. It seems that for the first time in my life I regretted my bad grade in physics. I believe that for those who understand at least something in the exact sciences and are able to distinguish a cyclotron from an isotope, “Stalin’s White Archipelago” should be even more interesting.
The book has the subtitle “A documentary narrative about the creation of a nuclear bomb, based on declassified materials from the USSR Atomic Project.” There are indeed a lot of documents in it, but no less important is that the author, who has been involved in the history of Soviet science all his life, was personally acquainted with almost all participants in this project.Therefore, the book contains a lot of interviews and first-hand information.
Already in the 40s, many people both in the USSR and abroad guessed about the approximate size of the Gulag Archipelago. But neither Western intelligence nor the citizens of the Soviet Union knew for the time being that in parallel with the Gulag, the empire of the special services created another one, the White Archipelago - dozens of closed cities, research institutes and design bureaus, whose residents were engaged in the invention and then production of atomic and hydrogen weapons. The two archipelagos existed simultaneously, they were led by the same people, and nuclear facilities were built by the hands of Gulag residents. At the end of their sentence, the builders of the White Archipelago were not released, but were taken to special “separate places”, where they remained for the rest of their lives. However, the scientists themselves were slaves of closed cities and were completely dependent on curators from the authorities. At least, this was the case before the onset of the Khrushchev era.
Contrary to popular belief, Soviet nuclear weapons were not always directed only at external enemies. There is at least one known attempt to use it for internal political blackmail. We are talking about Beria's intention to seize power in the country after Stalin's death. The President of the USSR Academy of Sciences, Aleksandrov, recalled that a few days before Beria’s arrest, generals from the relevant department rushed to him and the other developers of the project and demanded that a prototype of the newly created thermonuclear bomb be immediately handed over to them for delivery to Moscow. For technical reasons, it turned out to be impossible to carry out this order immediately - and a few days later the all-powerful minister was arrested, and his envoys quickly retreated.
Gubarev is convinced that one of the most important reasons for the collapse of the Soviet Union was the Brezhnev leadership’s passion for quantitative indicators in the nuclear sphere and the traditional Soviet gigantomania: “100 “Stalin” bombs and 50,000 “Brezhnev” bombs.” What kind of economy can withstand this?! Ours could not. .. By the way, in my opinion, 100 atomic bombs are quite enough to guarantee the security of our country. Both in the past and today . " In connection with this conclusion, the author’s attention is drawn to the figure of one of the heroes of his book - corresponding member, three times Hero of Socialist Labor Kirill Shchelkin. Shchelkin withdrew from the atomic project back in the 60s: formally for health reasons, actually because of disagreement with the course towards creating super-powerful charges - he believed that small ones were enough.
After so many serious men, terribly busy pacifying the highlanders, shuffling the special services and creating an atomic bomb, two charming girls are simply bound to appear on these virtual pages - a miniature brunette (wow!) and a large blonde (meh). The first one is called Trudy, the second one is Rachel. In general, it turned out that Trudy Baker and Rachel Jones' hit "What would you like, sir? Tea, coffee or me?" there is a continuation, and more than one. The first of three sequels to the famous book about the adventures of two flight attendants was recently published by At Cetera under the title "Rachel and Trudy Fly Around the World."
This story begins, naturally, with the airline’s management exposing the girls as the authors of that very libel that disgraces the high rank of stewardess, which, we note, sold three million copies. It is not possible to fire them - the vigilant union is on guard - but now Trudy and Rachel are being harassed by all and sundry. As a result, the girls are transferred to international lines and write the next book. One chapter per country.
As befits entertaining reading, the essay by Miss Baker and Miss Jones exploits national stereotypes with might and main. Unlucky philanderers live in Paris, porn films are made in Scandinavia, and in Berlin they jump over the wall in the direction from east to west. For the Russian reader, I recommend the chapter about Moscow, where the girls spend Christmas in either ’68 or ’69. In Russia, Rachel was greeted by a handsome Cossack at customs, frosts below forty, a lot of vodka tinted with pomegranate juice, and a sad poet without Moscow registration. Fortunately, she did not come across anything of what was discussed above: neither wild mountaineers, nor the ubiquitous KGB officers, nor even the most seedy bomb.