Fashion for modernization
The analytical material “Moral basis of modernization”, which has produced a considerable splash in recent days, is not only distinguished by amazing legal nihilism, but also by an extremely strange form. It seems that this document is written on the knee, and modernization in it is included only as a tribute to fashion.
The Russian authorities recently have been talking a lot about legal nihilism as a big problem facing society. But at the same time, the intellectual institution called “National Institute for the Development of Modern Ideology” is close to “United Russia” is literally approved by the following: “Ideology needs ideology for modernization and development of Russia. In the Constitution of the Russian Federation it is written that no ideology can be recognized as state ideology. The objective need for state ideology is due to the fact that ... ” Then you can not continue. In fact, this is the fact that the institute proposes to violate the basic law of the country (there are no proposals for amending it in the text). At the same time, it seems that no one pays serious attention to this. The fact is that the 1993 Constitution is perceived in Russian elites as a liberal declaration that has lost its relevance in Putin's Russia.
Against this background, the appeal to Orthodox values, which also aged liberal public, seems completely innocent (the authors of the material do not intend to restore the state church). Moreover, upon closer examination, it turns out that the list of these values, from the point of view of the authors of the material, is very narrow. There is no hint of a decalogue or a naked sermon. The place of ten commandments is occupied by a certain “ethics of Orthodoxy” with three principles: patriotism, collegiality, service to the common good. As for the first and third principles, they go back to ancient times - Pontius Pilate would rather agree with them than Jesus Christ. The ancient Romans really did not know the co -finding, but what it is is still the subject of a dispute of philosophers. In modern Russia, this concept has become a “deputy” of a well -known, but pretty discredited collectivism in Soviet times. Only with the latter is usually associated with forced campaigns in the vegetable base and boring political information, while the first recalls lost Russia, in which there were “candy brans” and the indispensable ringing of bells.
Further in the document refers to the moral crisis of society, hasty copying of Western forms of life and an “aggressive invasion of the values of a market economy” and, as an urgent alternative, the need to mobilize the patriotic potential of citizens. It seems that such a text was prepared for another purpose - for example, to justify the need to isolate Russia from the corrupted foreign influence. However, while the work was conducted, it became inadvertible not to mention in such texts about modernization - since Medvedev insists on its necessity. In this sense, the United Russia was not lucky, which managed to proclaim conservatism with its ideology. As a result, it was necessary to include in the last year the thesis program on the combination of conservatism and modernization adopted last year, and in the presentation of “United Russia” this hybrid resembles the result of crossing the terrible with a hedgehog than the political course of Reagan and Thatcher. However, in comparison with the material of the Dableborn Institute, the official party document looks much more respectable.
It is difficult to argue with the “moral basis of modernization”. You can discuss serious analytical texts - such as Incor's reports or articles by Vladislav Inozemtsev. You can agree with them or not, but it cannot be denied that in each case we are talking about a professional analytical product. You can argue about what modernization should be - authoritarian or democratic - and how much one or another scenario corresponds to modern Russian conditions. To discuss who we need - “Russian Erhard”, “Russian Dan Xiaopin”, “Russian Li Kuan Yu” - of course, adjusted for a real Russian situation. Pay attention to systemic corruption (almost Nigerian type) as one of the main risks of modernization. Insist on the need for "new industrialization", etc. But to argue about the admissibility of the violation of the constitution and the collegiality for modernization is outside the rational.
But in the publication of the "moral foundations ..." there is one big plus. This material demonstrates the inexhaustibility of the adaptation of Russian “writing people” to the last instructions of the authorities. Once I had to communicate with a person, for several years consistently former liberal, a social democrat and a conservative, depending on ideological fashion. It seems that modernization turns into a cliche, which is threatened by a sad prospect of becoming a wiped not over time, but almost immediately.
Author - First Vice President of the Center for Political Technology
Photo by RIA Novosti