
It so happened that yesterday I had the opportunity to attend two “religious” events: the presentation of the collection “The Limits of Secularism”, published
Information and Analytical Center "SOVA", and the conference “Religion and the Church in the Information Society”, which was organized by
RIO-Center (Center for the Development of the Information Society). Both events turned out to be very significant.
The SOVA Center works in several directions at once: it monitors the religious situation within the framework of the project “Religion in a Secular Society”, monitors illegal nationalist actions, and is now starting a new project “Democracy under Siege”. The collection of articles compiled by the director of the center, Alexander Verkhovsky, became a kind of afterword to the conference “Freedom of conscience and secularism of the state: problems and solutions” held in November 2004. Structured as a public debate where opposing points of view on the religious and social problems existing in Russia collided, the conference bore little resemblance to a scientific meeting. Roughly speaking, the debate was between two camps - liberals and conservatives. And it showed that it is fraught with a terrible simplification of reality.

In the collection, Alexander Verkhovsky said at the presentation, he tried to get away from the journalistic format and all kinds of partisanship and present the widest range of views (many conference participants were among the authors). And in general it was a success. Experts (Sergei Ivanenko, Yuri Tabak, Elizabeth Sewell), human rights activists (Alexander Daniel, Vsevolod Lukhovitsky), priests (Vsevolod Chaplin, Vladimir Vigilyansky), journalists (Olga Kvirkvelia, Mikhail Tulsky) expressed their opinions. And the topics covered were very diverse: from religious education in school and the peculiarities of Russian legislation to criteria for extremism and comparative characteristics of secular states. Of course, it was not possible to cover all the “thorny issues,” but a picture of how the public involved in religious problems lives is emerging.
At the autumn conference, the heat was such that a meaningful conversation continually turned into a showdown and veered into some particulars. The collection, which brought together under one cover the opinions of people with sometimes diametrically opposed views, made dialogue possible even between irreconcilable opponents. Of course, this is not yet a real public dialogue. A broad discussion requires the involvement of all public groups - so far the conversation is being conducted mainly by specialists, and even they have not fully agreed on the terms. But these are already approaches to the discussion, since almost for the first time, representatives of different “get-togethers” (including liberal human rights and church groups), which previously stewed exclusively in their own juices, met on the same negotiating field.
The conference organized by the RIO Center also had all the signs of dialogue. Although here everyone was talking about “their own”. The organizers, Minister of Information Technologies and Communications Leonid Reiman and Director of the Institute of General History of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Academician Alexander Chubaryan, spoke about the capabilities of the Internet, which are still poorly used by religious organizations. The distinguished guest, President of the Pontifical Council for Media, Archbishop John Patrick Foley, spoke about the experience of the Catholic Church in this area. Representative of the Moscow Muftiate, Sheikh Farid Asadullin, speaks about the Islamophobia-provoking manner of some media in remembering Muslims only when explosions are heard. Professor of St. Tikhon's Orthodox Humanitarian University, Deacon Andrey Kuraev, says that the Church is present in the media in a caricatured form. President of the Institute of Religion and Politics Alexander Ignatenko talks about the growth in the number of Islamic sites that researchers characterize as extremist, and about the task facing everyone who cares about peace not to let themselves be deceived. The head of the Church and Scientific Center “Orthodox Encyclopedia” Sergei Kravets says that the Russian media have turned into a means of entertainment, not information. Director of the research center “Religion in Modern Society” Mikhail Mchedlov talks about the need for an educational mission among young people, because, according to the center, the most intolerant part of society is young people 16-18 years old. The executive editor of the newspaper “Tserkovny Vestnik”, Sergei Chapnin, says that the Internet offers a completely new, and very dangerous, image system that forms a clip consciousness in a person.
Although the RIO-Center has existed since the beginning of 2003 and organizes seminars periodically, at least twice a month, it addressed the topic of religion and its existence in the information field for the first time. Perhaps because religious topics are gradually gaining a place in secular media, and on the Internet its share is even greater. But perhaps also because the desire of the authorities to rely on traditional values in their ideological quests is becoming more and more clear, and the head of the center, Leonid Reiman, is, after all, a minister. And the conference was held with the support of the presidential administration and the Federal Assembly. It is all the more gratifying that in addition to secular specialists, it was attended by representatives not only of the so-called main faiths, but also specially invited Catholics (though not their own, but Roman ones), and Protestants, and even a Hare Krishna, who, however, did not speak. But the spirit of officialdom was still felt. For example, after the speech of Archbishop Foley, the fourth of fifteen, about a third of the hall was blown away by the wind.
Everyone spoke in one way or another about the role of religion in the moral development of virtual space. How to deal with irrepressible consumerism, with heroes who never let go of a bottle of beer, with porn sites, after all? There were proposals to oblige the state to support the developers of restrictive programs and to intensify law enforcement in this area. Interestingly, the roles are reversed this time. Usually the initiators of prohibition projects, all kinds of morality committees and other things, are churchmen and Orthodox activists. And then the repressive fervor gripped mainly the officials. The representative of the Patriarchate, Archpriest Vsevolod Chaplin, on the contrary, expressed confidence that restrictions will not achieve anything. “It’s not that the laws are bad,” he said, “the problem is that people don’t have positive values. And together we must develop a positive ideal that people will follow, for which they will be interested in living and working.”
If the conference was not intended for show, then perhaps the conversation will continue on this platform. This wish was expressed by many speakers, and Academician Chubaryan promised that there would be work “at different levels and in different formats.” One way or another, it is obvious that society is increasingly involved in the discussion, moving away from a straightforward, head-on solution to religious problems. And that's good.