At the regular hearing in the Leninsky Court of Kirov on July 2 in the case of Alexei Navalny and Pyotr Ofitserov, accused of theft by embezzlement of wood from the Kirovles enterprise, Judge Sergei Blinov again made it clear that he did not need to listen to defense witnesses. On June 16, he refused to call all of the defense's witnesses. Now the defense has demanded his recusal on this basis. But Blinov did not deflect himself as expected and stated that the lawyers had not presented any evidence that the defense witnesses could provide the court with any valuable information. So much for the competition between the parties.
Nevertheless, the witnesses who came specially to the hearing were heard by the court. Among them was former Deputy Prime Minister of the Kirov region Maria Gaidar. Answering Navalny’s questions, she stated that the governor’s adviser (Navalny held such a position in the Kirov region) had no right to influence regional enterprises (and this is what Navalny is accused of: he allegedly forced the then head of Kirovles, Vyacheslav Opalev, to sell timber at a reduced price Vyatka Forestry Company, which belonged to Ofitserov). She also said that she had never heard of Ofitserov paying anything to Navalny, and that Governor Nikita Belykh and his deputy Sergei Shcherchkov laughed for a long time at the results of the Kirovles audit study.
At the request of the defense, Irina Merkusheva, an employee of the Vyatka Forestry Company, who was responsible for the documentation, was also questioned. According to her, even when she came to the company for an internship, the forestry enterprises could not even answer how much goods they had shipped. She also said that the price at which forest products were purchased from Kirovles was set by the said company.
The third witness, whose appearance was ensured by the defense, was Ofitserov’s brother Dmitry, now the owner of the Vyatka Forestry Company, and during the events described in court, he was engaged in sales there. He said that he never saw Navalny either in the company’s office or in the apartment he and his brother rented. Dmitry Ofitserov also stated that VLK never bought products from Kirovles at a reduced price.
Next, Elena Ovsyannikova, who worked at VLK as an accountant, was interrogated. She said that no money transfers were made to Navalny or other people completely unrelated to VLK. She also never saw Navalny in the offices of her company.
The judge again refused to question other defense witnesses, those whom the lawyers themselves were unable to bring to court.