Corruption in Canada
From the editorial office. The level of corruption in any country is closely connected with the relations dominant in society, with the orders adopted in it, with the nature of the regime of power. Where, in conditions of political competition, the ruling party is forced to achieve the growth of the living standards of the population, there corruption interferes with objectively to the authorities. They have to really fight her, as they fight her in Canada. But where corruption income serves as glue, fastening the vertical of authoritarian power, there are rare processes over corrupt officials only a decoration that hides the true nature of the authoritarian regime. However, it is already useful for us today to know about the successful experience of combating corruption in democratic countries. The time will come when Russia will turn on the European path of development. And this Canadian experience will be useful to us.
Canada enters the top ten of the least corrupt countries of the world. Corruption offenses are qualified here as the most serious crimes. Both bribe giveers and bribeers are brought to criminal liability on an equal footing.
In Canada there is no single law on the fight against corruption. But the behavior of citizens of any country is determined not so much by formal texts of laws as the culture of the people, its traditions adopted by the management system. It is significant that the State Anti -Corruption Committee of Canada , which includes eight members of the government and nine representatives of the system opposition, is headed by the representative of the opposition. Strange, isn't it? Is this possible in Russia? Could Navalny lead a similar state note with us?
At the initiative of the Anti -Corruption Committee of Canada in 1985 , a value ethical code of a civil servant was approved. Codes were also adopted to resolve the conflict of interests in the House of Commons and in the Senate. These normative acts today determine the rules of conduct that all public servants are obliged to be guided by. To be guided by the prevention of corruption crimes and minimizing the possibility of “conflicts of interests”.
So, civil servants are not recommended to have private interests that may concern the department in which they work. Upon admission to the civil service, they must rebuild their personal affairs in such a way as to exclude the possibility of a “conflict of interests”. They are obliged to abandon all gifts and other material benefits that may affect the decisions they are. In cases where it is impossible to do this for some reason, one should immediately report this to the authorized official of his department.
Councils are not allowed to deviate from their duties to assist private individuals and enterprises in their relations with the state, if as a result of this the latter gain any advantages compared to others. Before the law, everyone is equal!
Public employees are not entitled to extract material benefits from information that has not yet been made public and became known to them as a result of the performance of official duties. They should not allow the use of state property for any other purposes, except for those for which it is officially intended. Without the permission of the leadership, a civil servant does not have the right to offer his assistance to any person or organization if its provision is not included in his official duties.
The Ethics Code contains specific requirements for the daily activities of officials. So, the civil servant for 60 days after appointing to the service is obliged to submit an authorized official report to an official about his property and about all obligations that potentially capture a “conflict of interest”, about all assets of the civil servant - securities, shares in the partnerships and cooperatives, farmers, real estate, loans owned by the subordinate. Under the control, all his foreign income and benefits are also controlled. The code contains requirements for the behavior of civil servants after dismissal from public service. The goal is to minimize possible conflicts of interests in the future employment. After dismissal, employees should not try to extract any advantages using the capabilities they received in the performance of their official duties. During the year after dismissal, the former civil servant does not have the right to settle down in the organizations with which he had previously conducted business on behalf of the department during the year. He does not even have the right to advise for a commercial purpose of any such organization conducting cases with the government institution in which he previously worked. Everyone is subject to control in Canada, regardless of the position held. So, the Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau had to pay a fine of $ 100 for not making information about the income on the income about the sunglasses donated to him.
It is important that all these norms do not remain good wishes, only fixed on paper. Citizens, relying on clear norms of anti -corruption legislation, were able to maintain corruption in Canada at a very low level.
***
Lobbyism in Canada is a legal type of activity. In Canada, there are about 5200 lobbyists. Lobibists who receive remuneration for contacting officials on issues related to decision -making by authorities are required to undergo public registration. It is carried out in electronic form, and information about lobbyists is posted in the public domain.
Lobbyism, as a type of activity, is regulated by the Law on Lobbying . Lobbyism is considered any interaction with an official in order to make a “state decision”. The law classifies all actions on the introduction, adoption of laws or by -laws and decisions, amendments, as well as the adoption or amendment of any act of executive bodies, the creation or change of political programs, the conclusion of state contracts, the receipt of grants or other financial benefits. Any information obtained as a result of such contacts should become public. Lobibists are obliged to publicly report on their actions on the Internet, in particular, to indicate with whom, when and on what issue they met.
The official does not have the right to accept money from lobbyists on any reason. However, the senior public servants themselves (including ministers and ministries) do not have the right to work with lobbyists or in lobbying companies within 5 years after resignation.
For violating the federal registration lobbyist, a fine of up to 50 thousand Canadian dollars and imprisonment of up to 6 months is supposed to be a fine of up to 50 thousand. For the provision of false information or false documents-a fine of up to 200 thousand Canadian dollars and imprisonment of up to 2 years. Until 2005, there was not a single case of holding lobbyists accountable for such an act. Since 2005, fines have nevertheless superimposed, but extremely rarely. It is interesting that the provinces of Canada themselves determine the measures of punishment for violation of their own legislation on lobbying, the range of fines - from 500 to 100 thousand Canadian dollars.
The supervision of federal lobbyists is engaged in a special enforcement officer for lobbying, who is endowed with broad powers to check the activities of lobbyists. In particular, he can prohibit any lobbyist, guilty of any violation, contact the government for up to two years. The surnames of violators are called in reports submitted to the parliament. The authorized person is independent of the executive branch and is appointed for 7 years by both chambers of the Canadian parliament, to which he is obliged to report on his work annually.
* * *
State procurement in Canada is carried out mainly in electronic form through a specialized controlling and executive body - the “Ministry of State Services and State procurement of Canada”. Its share in public procurement exceeds 85%. About 85 thousand tenders passes through it annually. 12.5 thousand people work in the staff of the ministry. Units of the Ministry assess the each tender, analyze the documentation, the validity of the prices and conditions of the contract, prepare recommendations to the participants and control the auction process. The control department at the ministry is also engaged in the prevention of corruption. Its units analyze the practice of each large tender, compliance with the participants and the customer of laws, principles of ethics and other provisions, and consider disagreements during trading.
State officials follow not only the laws governing the Gostorgs, but also the ETICAL Code . It consists of 35 provisions that determine the practice of trading and the behavior of state representatives. For example, such norms as transparency of the transaction are fixed there. This norm in Canadian legislation has a very specific meaning and is carefully observed. Another norm of the Code is to stimulate competition. Such a frequent phenomenon in Russian practice, such as Gostorgs with the only supplier, is rare in Canada only if the contract is capable of fulfilling this particular candidate and provided that the contract does not affect the interests of state security.
Such a method as the separation of the areas of responsibilities is also used. For example, the executive manager controls the expense of the Gostorg funds, monitors the costs of expenses, and the financial director visits payments for payment. This practice helps to avoid corruption and conspiracy of the Contractor with officials responsible for the distribution of funds.
As a rule, the transaction also takes an audit of specialists who study procedural issues, documentation, the process of conducting electronic trading. Then an analysis of the work of officials is carried out in the framework of the law on the protection of civil servants. If there are reasons, then fines are imposed, complaints or warnings are issued.
* * *
An important step in combating corruption in Canada was the adoption of the Law on Government responsibility in 2006, with which the amendments were related to more than sixty other laws. The story of its acceptance is as follows. Canada, as a former colony of Great Britain, inherited the Vestminster management model from the metropolis, in which ministers remain members of the House of Commons and, thus, get the opportunity to control themselves. This violates the principle of separation of powers, the balance between the legislative and executive branches of the authorities, which can lead to bad consequences. This was the same in 2006 by the "advertising and sponsoring scandal", as the press christened him. He led to the change of the ruling party. The Liberal Party, which was in power for 13 years, lost to the Office of the Conservative country.
The background of this scandal is as follows. On October 30, 1995, a referendum on sovereignty was held in the mainly Francophone Province of Quebec. 49.4% of the province of the population spoke out for sovereignty. Thus, supporters of the unity of Canada prevailed only with a very insignificant advantage. The results of the referendum allowed analysts to judge that the national problem in Canada seriously threatens the integrity of the Canadian Federation. During this period, the Liberal Party was in power in the country. Under her leadership, the federal government approved the state program to promote the ideas of national unity in Quebec and clarify the advantages of the integrity of the Federation. A mass propaganda advertising campaign was deployed, which was supposed to fit into cultural, sports and mass entertainment events held in the provinces. Every year, tens of millions of Canadian dollars stood out for the holding of the United Canada. The campaign took place from 1996 to 2004 and would have lasted longer if the facts of numerous violations of the law had not been opened and published in the consumption of state funds for its implementation. Most of the budget funds, and this is about 200 million dollars, was paid for the performance of minor work by advertising companies close to the Liberal Party. At the same time, these companies, receiving state money, provided temporary work to the functioners of the liberal party. These "employees" were paid a considerable reward. This reward, in turn, was already quite legally sacrificed to the needs of the Liberal Party.
As a result of the scandal, the country's parliament adopted a “law on government responsibility”, which provides for a number of reforms aimed at preventing corruption. Thanks to the tough system of responsibility introduced on the basis of this law, transparency of the activities of officials was ensured. On the basis of this law, a submarine act was adopted, namely the leadership for ministers, which is called the “responsible government”. This leadership establishes the requirements for compliance with the non -party principle of public service. Citizens of different political views can be members of the government, but this should not interfere with them conscientiously, honestly and impatiently fulfill their functions.
But it is important that in order to strengthen public control over the work of the government through the deputies elected by the population, it was decided to establish several posts of authorized parliament on conflicts of interests and ethics . Parliamentary authorized Now they control the execution of the Code of Code of Code of Council for civil servants in the same year in the same 2006 of the interests in the event of a conflict of interests. In case of violation of any civil servants, up to the Prime Minister, the rules established by the Code, the authorized person has the right to apply a fine on him.
In Canada, personnel are engaged in personnel work and the distribution of funds in the ministries, but their first deputies. They were obliged to come to the Committee of the Senate and the House of Commons and give a report on their work and measures undertaken in the ministries based on the results of an internal financial audit. In this regard, the functions of the general auditor of Canada were expanded, who was endowed with very broad powers for financial investigations. In addition, one of the guarantees of the separation and balance of the authorities was the consolidation of the rules of the Parliament of Canada in the regulations of the House of Communities of the Parliament, according to which, in contrast to the general auditor, the Committee of the House of Communities on State Accounts is headed by a representative of the opposition party.
An important element of the “responsible government” system is the transparency and reliability of budget planning procedures. The government is obliged to publish monthly financial reports, reports and financial materials. The parliamentary budget officer, established by law, assesses the costs proposed by the government. At the same time, ministries and departments are obliged to provide him with accurate information in a timely manner. As a result, the parliament discusses the results of an independent analysis of the financial and economic situation in the country and may evaluate the work of the government. There is a real separation of powers, the system of retirement and counterweights works.
To improve the procedure of state transactions, the position of an independent supply inspector was introduced, who constantly monitors the justice and transparency of contracts at the government level. He also considers complaints from potential suppliers. If the complaint is justified, then it gives recommendations to the ministry with which a trading transaction was concluded. The inspector submits annual reports on his activities, about the results achieved at the Agency of Public Works and Government Services of Canada, which studies them and transfer it to parliament.
In the system of counteracting corruption, a significant role is played by the mechanism for ensuring real protection of persons reporting the criminally punishable actions of civil servants. Public servants reporting the facts of corruption began to be encouraged by prizes in the amount of up to 1000 Canadian dollars. The law also introduced the position of a special parliamentary authorized person who controls the execution of the “law on the protection of civil servants” who disclosed information about the unlawful actions of the leadership. On the basis of this law, a special court was also created, considering such cases and imposing disciplinary measures of punishment on violators.
“The Acon on the responsibility of the government” was introduced by the Parliamentary Commissioner for the audit of individuals and organizations receiving funds from the state treasury. It has broad powers to conduct an investigation to use state funds. He is endowed with immunity from possible criminal prosecutions and bringing to administrative responsibility, as well as forced to speak as a witness in connection with his official functions.
The criminal law measures for corruption crimes are also strengthened. Так, в «Закон об использовании государственных средств» введены санкции для чиновников в виде содержания под стражей до пяти лет за хищение средств в размере до 5000 канадских долларов и до 14 лет — за хищение средств в размере, превышающем 5000 канадских долларов.
Кроме «Закона об ответственности Правительства» антикоррупционные нормы содержатся в целом ряде законов и других нормативных актов. Например, в «Административных правилах Совета Казначейства» перечислены все правила раскрытия информации, касающейся служебных злоупотреблений, правила предупреждения притеснений и домогательств на работе и разрешения связанных с этим ситуаций, правила заключения государственных закупок и т. д.
* * *
В Канаде работу бюрократии регламентирует и целый ряд других законов. Так « Закон о найме на государственную службу» предусматривает назначение на должность только на основе личных профессиональных качеств, а не по блату и приятельским отношениям с начальником. Контроль за назначением на должность осуществляет Комиссия по вопросам государственной службы , которая подотчетна Парламенту и независима от исполнительной ветви власти . Подчеркнем, что в любой стране важнейшей проблемой формирования эффективных органов исполнительной власти является естественный отрицательный отбор среди госслужащих , когда руководитель подразделения стремится избавиться от сотрудников, которые могут составить ему конкуренцию. Лекарством от такого отрицательного отбора госслужащих и служит прозрачность процедуры замещении государственных должностей, объективность кадровых решений. Именно для этого была создана упомянутая комиссия. Качество принимаемых ею решений и рекомендаций гарантируется порядком ее формирования, независимостью ее членов от органов исполнительной власти, авторитетом ее членов.
« Закон об управлении государственными финансами» определяет обязанности государственных служащих по сбору, управлению и распределению государственных средств, обеспечивает дисциплину на государственной службе и дает возможность использовать дисциплинарные меры воздействия вплоть до увольнения. С другой стороны работает « Закон о защите государственных служащих» , сообщивших о служебных нарушениях. Он определяет для них средства и методы раскрытия информации о возможных служебных нарушениях и одновременно обеспечивает защиту от проявлений мести за сообщение таких сведений. Надзор за исполнением закона осуществляет подотчетный Парламенту Уполномоченный по вопросам добросовестной работы государственного сектора. Он получает информацию о преследованиях, расследует обвинения и сообщает о результатах расследований высшему должностному лицу организации, где все это происходило. Он также может передать дело в «Трибунал по вопросам защиты государственных сотрудников, сообщивших о служебных нарушениях» .
Важную роль играет «Закон о доступе к информации» , дающий право канадским гражданам (в том числе физическим и юридическим лицам, средствам массовой информации, а также членам Парламента) требовать и получать информацию, имеющуюся в распоряжении государственных органов власти. Надзор за исполнением закона осуществляет специальный Уполномоченный по вопросам информации, подотчетный Парламенту.
Работает в Канаде и «Закон о неприкосновенности частной жизни» , который, в частности, предоставляет право канадским гражданам знать, какая информация о них хранится в государственных учреждениях.
* * *
Члены Парламента сохраняют право владеть и распоряжаться ценными бумагами и занимать посты в корпорациях, но это разрешение о6ставлено целым рядом условий. Все депутаты обязаны ежегодно сообщать подробные данные о компаниях, в которых они являются директорами, менеджерами или служащими, а также о корпорациях или фондах, ценными бумагами которых они владеют. Депутат, получивший в обход закона прибыль от выполнения правительственного контракта, в 30-дневный срок обязан вернуть в казну всю сумму , отказаться от дальнейшего участия в контракте и выйти из правления корпорации. В противном случае он немедленно лишается места в парламенте, которое автоматически становится вакантным.
В связи с существованием таких ограничений канадские парламентарии предпочитают не заниматься предпринимательством, лишь некоторые из них сохраняют побочный род занятий – обычно юридическую или медицинскую практику. Часть депутатов владеет небольшими пакетами акций, как правило, в семейных фирмах.
Тем не менее, нельзя сказать, что политическая жизнь в Канаде совсем обходится без коррупционных скандалов. Так, летом 2020 года в центре большого скандала оказались премьер-министр страны Джастин Трюдо и один из ключевых членов его правительства, министр финансов Уильям Морно.
Правительство страны запустило программу помощи студентам вузов, которые во время пандемии стали волонтерами. Ее реализация была поручена благотворительному фонду WE Charity, для чего этой организации предполагалось перечислить из федерального бюджета 912 млн канадских долларов. Оппозиция заявила, что лидер правящей Либеральной партии Джастин Трюдо нарушил положения закона, который запрещает госслужащим участвовать в принятии решений, которые могут быть выгодны их частным интересам. Выяснилось, что был нарушен и другой закон, так как право на управление такими огромными средствами фонд WE Charity получил без проведения какого-либо тендера. Все это привело к началу расследования со стороны Уполномоченного по конфликтам интересов и этике.
Выяснились довольно тесные связи семьи Трюдо с фондом. Мать премьер-министра и его брат с 2016 по 2020 год за выступления на различных мероприятиях фонда получили от его руководства не менее 282 тыс. канадских долларов. Разовый гонорар получила от фонда и его супруга. Тесные связи с фондом нашлись и у семьи министра финансов. Билл Морно на фоне скандала заявил, что вернул WE Charity 41 тыс. канадских долларов, которые организация потратила на перелет членов его семьи в Кению и Эквадор в 2017 году. Также Трюдо и Морно принесли извинения за то, что сразу не отказались от услуг фонда, с которым их семьи имеют тесные связи. Премьер-министр заявил, что фонд WE Charity рекомендовала госструктура, курирующая волонтерскую деятельность, а он не использовал свое влияние при этом выборе. Благодаря скандалу фонд свернул свою деятельность в Канаде.
До этого Трюдо, в свою бытность премьером, еще два раза был заподозрен в конфликтах интересов, тем не менее эти скандалы тогда не привели к его отставке. Но сам факт обнародования информации и проведения расследований показывает, что в Канаде неприкосновенных сегодня нет.
Резюмируя, можно сказать, что законодательство Канады, направленное на противодействие коррупции в государственных органах, достаточно эффективно препятствует возникновению «конфликтов интересов» и обеспечивает надлежащее использование государственных ресурсов. Оно дает гражданам и государственным служащим немалые возможности для противодействия коррупционным сделкам. Актуальность канадского опыта для России очевидна и требует глубокого исследования на предмет возможного использования.
При подготовке статьи использованы материалы с сайтов Ushistory . ru , www . myshared . ru , tass . ru , pora - valit . livejournal . ru , kostunov . livejournal . com , studme . ru , Anticor . hse . ru , B - pointer . ru , studwood . ru , minjust . nso . ru , Pikabu . ru .
Illustration: pixabay.com