
Appeared in "Hedgehog"
noteViktor Shenderovich, in which he compared the Iranian Ayatollah, who came up with a proposal to recount some of the ballots, with Vladimir Churov. The comparison is, to put it mildly, incorrect. If you look for an analogue of the Ayatollah in Russia, then this is Vladimir Putin, and the “guardians of sovereign democracy” are the “chekists”, who are a kind of “order of the sword-bearers”, whose strength lies in its informal power over the country.
What happens in Iran will have very far-reaching consequences and, in some ways, may serve as a model for what could happen in Russia. And there was a serious breakdown in the Iranian political system. The Ayatollah recognized Ahmadinejad's victory, supplementing the secular ritual (elections) with a religious one (references to the will of Allah). However, this did not stop the opposition. This created a threat to the legitimacy of not only the power of Ahmadinejad, but also the power of the Ayatollah and the Guardian Council. And this is already a powerful blow to the entire political and ideological system of Iran. The religious support of secular power did not work. This does not mean that the Age of Enlightenment will begin in Iran. However, the place of religion in the political system and in the life of society, its interpretation can become the subject of fierce disputes and a split in society.
In Russia, the religious support of secular power is the great-power ideology, which includes Orthodoxy, the Soviet experience, and autocratic traditions. This explosive mix does not stand up to any criticism from a rational point of view. But as an object of belief that evokes strong emotions among the population, it fully fulfills its function. This “religion” is guarded by the “Order of the Sword Bearers”, led by Putin. Putin and the “chekists” are feared and respected at the same time, since they managed to very effectively promote and use at their service the myth of the KGB as an all-powerful organization possessing enormous power hidden from ordinary people. This myth was purposefully created in the USSR to intimidate the population and is very useful today. As for the president, he plays the role of “official” power in this system. But in this mythological system, “explicit” power is, by definition, less than “secret” power. Therefore, Medvedev is not taken seriously.
In Iran, a similar structure began to collapse under the pressure of the deteriorating social situation and the fear of the active part of the population at the prospect of complete isolation of the country. In Russia, an active isolationist policy began to be pursued after the August War, and the part of society that does not want to live in “Fortress Russia” is only just realizing the consequences of the ideological turn that took place in Russia at the instigation of the “guards.” But the spiral of crisis is unwinding very quickly. The power of the “guards” is becoming more and more burdensome. Therefore, it is possible that in the foreseeable future the legitimacy of the Russian “ayatollah” for the active part of society will be lost. And then the process of reformatting the current political system will begin, which will proceed very rapidly and unpredictably according to the old Russian tradition.
Photo by RIA Novosti