About Goebbels and about "Rain"
Two stories are somewhat similar, different. Reflecting complete intellectual chaos in our society. This time in the context of history, victory, blockade, fascism ...
The VGTRK fired in full composition, responsible for social networks. The guys decided to celebrate the 90th anniversary of the death of a bad person V.I. Lenin, collecting the sayings of him of various famous people. But they called this quotation strangely: "Great statements about Lenin." The creative approach came to them when, among others, they quoted such a “great man” as Goebbels.
The quote, by the way, is very interesting. The most black propagandist in history, our leader of the world proletariat was very pretty. Isn't it curious to know this? Doesn't this demonstration strokes add to the portrait of the "grandfather of Lenin"? And I never agree that the ideologists of Nazism cannot be quoted in principle. If you do not quote, how do people even find out that people like Goebbels are the embodiment of evil? You need to know this, you need to quote them.
But context and goal are important. If you admire the Minister of Propaganda and follow his covenants, then it would be nice to isolate you and the most well from society. But educational and cognitive goals are not reprehensible. Probably, they had something similar to VGTRK, but for some reason Goebbels was recorded in the “great”, which in our language has a clear semantic shade. The great means positive. It is unlikely that the one who did this considers Goebbels a positive hero. Probably, he deserves official censure, probably he could be fined at VGTRK, and absolutely, he does not need to work with social networks henceforth. But still this is not a crime. And dismiss the whole department! People who did not have the slightest attitude to this quote, to its posting on the network! What is their fault? This is pure nonsense! Show patrioticity, demonstrate that the memory of the victims of Nazism is honored in a media holding.
It is curious that the quotation of Goebbels namesake, the executioner is even more terrible - Stalin - does not bother anyone. And to celebrate the death of the founder of the world's first state, deliberately fighting with his people - Lenin, is just a good tone.
The story with the liquidation of the whole editorial office due to the bargain on the site coincided with the scandal around the rain and its survey about the blockade. I agree and disagree with my colleague Podrabinek. I agree that to discuss everything related to the blockade, with the monstrous victims in Leningrad, and those whether it was somehow possible to avoid them. Be sure to! We are catastrophically little know about this. As well as catastrophically, we know the true truth about the war. And all sorts of blunt deputies and officials with the rubies are just doing everything so that we continue to live in the world of Soviet myths and stamps - about the war.
But I do not agree with Alexander that the question was asked normal. The question was asked bad. Because he has no answer. "Was it necessary to pass Leningrad in order to save hundreds of thousands of lives?" Such a statement of the question is true if it is about the capture of hostages by terrorists. When we can say that we are able to save life by going to the terrorists to concessions. Here, psychologically, the sign of equality is placed between concepts by no means identical. The surrender of the city did not necessarily attract the salvation of hundreds of thousands of lives. The situation was too complicated to reduce it to such a simple formula.
But colleagues, of course, did not mean someone to offend, did not call to capitulate before Hitler and almost surrendered to the mercy of the Nazis right on June 22-what the rain, among other things, accused. Journalists allowed the inaccuracy of the formulation. And if they had to apologize for something, then it was precisely for the inaccuracy of the wording, without removing the topic itself. Vice versa! Now this topic is in the focus of attention and the discussion needs especially acute!
But a flock of patented patriots rushed to poison the canal, which, apparently, had long wanted to take his own accounts and just waited for a reason. It is wonderful in this story not only that the whole media wants to close for the only mistake for which it also quickly apologizes. And what they want to close for the question! Not even for the point of view - but just for the question asked!
After all, the rain did not claim that the city had to be handed over and generally surrendered to the enemy. The channel just asked, pushed people to his thoughts. But thinking in our country is dangerous. Thinking in Russia is not required. It is much better to implicitly fulfill the orders of the authorities - and it is better even to anticipate his desires. And to dismiss entire editions for the slightest inaccuracy and close television channels. And to live in captivity of some myths - generating others.
In the photo: Joseph Goebbels's book "Michael. German fate in diary sheets" in one of the bookstores of the capital.
Photo by ITAR-TASS/ Mikhail Postuev