About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Newsletter
About RIMA
For researchers
Collection
Kronika Project
About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Date
08/13/2009
Author
РОМАН ХАХАЛИН
Source
Ezhednevnyi Zhurnal
Preserved copy
Internet Archive
Translated material

AvtoVAZ: Chavo?

In the economy

AvtoVAZ: Chavo?

August 13, 2009 Roman Khakhalin

Chavo - in the sense of FAQ. And the FAQ - not in the sense of "FAC", but in the sense of "many questions have accumulated." A lot of questions have accumulated about our auto giant in Togliatti.

In connection with the rally in front of the Palace of Culture and Technology (DKIT) of the automobile capital, which was on August 6, many assumptions have already been expressed. So why not express one more? I will do this.

But first - a small retrospitation of opinions and judgments about the rally itself. On August 6, the rally gathered ... how much? I can’t consider the number of participants in 800 people an independent source of the police chief of public security of the Samara region, who determined the number of participants. Relatively independent sources call the figure from 2000 to 3000 people. Let us dwell on the minimum - about 2000 people came to a rally dedicated to the distress of AvtoVAZ.

What pain did those of these two thousand bring with them who really worked/worked at the car factory? (In addition to them, representatives of the Communist Party and the LDPR wished to participate in the rally, which is not surprising: now in Togliatti the election campaign has begun in the place of the deputy of the Samara Provincial Duma - Anatoly Stepanov killed at the end of 2008)

The requirements of the AvtoVAZ team actually came down to the following: a) the nationalization of the enterprise; b) transparency of financial and economic activity; c) the right to participate in independent trade unions in solving personnel and production issues (if anyone does not know, now the chairman of the official trade union organization of the VAZ, Nikolai Karagin, is included in the board of directors of the enterprise. The remuneration for such an honorary activity is not disclosed, but stubborn rumors go that it is calculated at least tens of thousands of dollars a month. Will such a trade union leader want to think that the salary of workers' workers will want to think that the salary of workers hangs around the mark of 8000-10,000 thousand rubles?); d) the abolition of order No. 310 (an order on the introduction from September 1, after a month of complete downtime, a 20-hour working week. That is, on the reduction of already small salaries of ordinary employees); e) investigation of the Accounts Chamber of spending at the enterprise; f) the dismissal of the current management of the enterprise.

We will analyze all these points a little below separately, and now a little about how the interested parties reacted to the rally (at the same time, none of them personally appeared at the rally). Vladislav Kapustin, Minister of Industry, Energy and Technologies of the Samara Region: “Obviously I want to tell you: the difficulties are big in the country, not to me to tell you. But no one wants to pay attention to one thing - for the entire period of the crisis, at a time when tens of thousands of people were dismissed on many leading car factories, not a single person was fired at AvtoVAZ for the entire period and there was no order to reduce the order. I am surprised by leisure speculations that are constantly exaggerated in our press. I want to say that the leadership of AvtoVAZ, including the management team that has been criticized today, from my point of view, has done everything and solved the most important task during this period - maintaining jobs. We all must really understand that the money for AvtoVAZ will not come from nowhere, except from the cars sold. The state provided unprecedented and timely assistance to AvtoVAZ, which allowed to stabilize the work of the enterprise. ”

Nikolai Karagin, chairman of the ASM union (official profanity of the enterprise):

“Our trade union organization also sometimes holds rallies and such kinds of public events, but now we consider other forms of work more effective - a constructive dialogue is needed within the framework of the negotiation process and with the leaders of the plant and with authorities. We have a permanent conciliation commission, within the framework of which we discuss all difficult issues, and there is no refusal of the leadership of the plant to discuss certain problems, we are in dialogue and with the mayor of Togliatti and the Governor of the Samara region. We believe that this form gives a greater result than holding some kind of rally. ”

Sergey Chemezov, head of the state corporation Rostekhnology , which now belongs to the VAZ, according to Echo of Moscow, appreciated the rally as a provocation.

The objectivity and impartiality of all the judgments I have given, of course, is not subject to doubt (in the official media). Amen.

We will move on to the consideration of the requirements of the protesters by points, as promised.

Nationalization of the enterprise. One hundred and more, or more, the thousandth team of AvtoVAZ is still in dreams about those times when the state was the owner of everything and everything in a space of 22 million square meters. km. The effectiveness of the enterprise itself in those conditions was not discussed. There was no competition. Now - different. VAZ employees do not want to remember themselves three years ago, when they rejoiced that “strong statesmen” came to the factory management in the person of personal friends and friends of personal friends of the then “leader of the nation”. In fact, the Rosoboronexport team (now Rostekhnology) for three years demonstrated all the effectiveness of state -oriented management in modern Russian conditions. To demand nationalization after this is at least strange. It is not Newton’s bin that the nationalized enterprise will be headed by the next talented managers who are carefully selected over the years of “getting up from the knees” by reverse selection. So what is the difference between the current statesmen and statesmen of the future in the event of nationalization? I'm afraid that the unity union or the participants of the rally have an answer to this question. And given the active assistance of the Communist Party, I generally include the idea that this requirement of the rally resolution is imposed by the Communists (by the way, also exclusively in the old memory of the USSR).

The transparency of financial and economic activity. A completely fair requirement, but if you recall where a person spends his days, which was the last time that proposed at the state level this very transparency, it becomes clear that this point of resolution suffers from some idealism. Although, of course, it would be very interesting to find out what amounts the remuneration for hard work is now being measured for the highest management of the plant and who is one of this management itself. (According to some reports , the costs of maintaining the administration in recent years, with the advent of the "new team", have increased three times.)

The right to participate in independent trade unions in the election of management. The independent union “Unity” for the past two years AvtoVAZ was fed promises on this topic repeatedly. But WHO is still there, and so far there is no reason to believe that something will change. They were not going to consult with independent trade unions.

The abolition of order No. 310. The order can be canceled, but this will not solve any problems of the plant. The overstator will remain, new products with the current price policy will continue to settle in warehouses. If the state allocates money to compensate for all these costs, such an infusion will help (provided that it will not resolve along the road) for a short while. And after three or four months, the plant will return to the same problems.

Investigation and analysis of the expenditure of funds of the enterprise. The right idea that seems doubtful in the light of information received in the spring of this year: then the counting chamber and the General Prosecutor's Office tried to check AvtoVAZ and even hinted that they found a lot of interesting things. Yes, only after April, when all these statements were made, about the continuation of inspections and their results - not a word. There are probably people who know some kind of “rooster word” to cool the ardor of Sergei Stepashin and Yuri Chaika. So it is unlikely that this requirement of the protesters is at least somewhat feasible.

The dismissal of the current leadership. The idea, again, is quite sound: if the manager showed his failure, he is fired. But current managers are so close to the highest leadership of the country that to dismiss them means recognizing their failure in the selection of personnel.

As a result of this, to the highest degree of subjective (emphasize!) The analysis of the situation in the dry residue only one conclusion. Without a complete change in the management paradigm, without abandoning the principle of replacing real anti -crisis actions with a loud PR, the enterprise in the near future does not expect anything good. If the status quo is maintained, even if you imagine that the plant will once again receive a certain loan from the state on favorable terms, in a few months the situation will still slide down the same collapse. At the same time, judging by the statements of officials, they either have not yet realized the seriousness of the situation, or simply, from a bureaucratic habit, continue to pretend that their situation is under control.

Samara

Photos of RIA Novosti