
This plot is underestimated. The opposition media unsubscribed languidly, and they can be understood. Is it not banal that the system rolled up another innocent guy to the camp? More recently, in the memory of the not yet left generation, the system rolled up in the camps of innocent millions. But, thank God, today - not yesterday and the regime is now not so hard, but soft, hybrid, as Madame Schulman would say. However, if you are surprised, so, rather, the selectivity of pressure, that only Dadin rolled up. Moreover, this required some indistinct explanations and excuses from several influential instances, as well as a whole process in the Constitutional Court of Russia. Exactly, Schulman would have considered it with great progress.
The Loyalist press also wrote sluggishly. Obviously, she did not smile to waste the shells of loyalism to the justification of a clearly dubious procedure, prominent even to the naked ... prosecutors. On the other hand, the guy was injured-liberal without certain classes, from the fifth column, so there is a road there.
Meanwhile, the incident turned out to be interesting, like a layer pie.
One level: verification of the Dadin case by the Russian Constitution. She just had just passed with the universal funnyness of observers. The observers mixed everything: a bubnier dressed in a mantle of boring people, and the nervousness of the guards on the street, and the unexpected arguments of the noble lawyer of the country Barschevsky, who suddenly remembered his grandfather with the rules of flogging.
“Before you tear,” the grandfather of the future Kremlin lawyer taught, “we must spank several times.” Barschevsky remembered this maxim from childhood and voiced today at a meeting of the Constitutional Court. Obviously, Barschevsky now believes that leaving the legitimization of flogging. The more cute refrigerations, the more serious flogging is more normative, so to speak ...
The second level: how all this happened. It is meant that the Hall in the Constitutional Court was not scored by civil activists, the concerned position of human rights in Russia, but mostly indifferent students of legal entities who were promised for the masses of tests. What personally, for example, was vividly reminded of the Stalinist processes, which, according to the stories, the listeners came to the court rooms in construction, we were in construction, and the defendants were allegedly carried away to white hoodies without gaps for the eyes. No, in our case the applicant, of course, no one carried away anywhere. His simply brought a meeting, as an extra element in a real discussion. Yes, and the students left not in construction, but Gald and exchanging impressions. However, the sediment still remained.
And finally, the third level and the main layer: this is the verification of the Russian constitution, since Ildar’s complaint was not only tested here on the correspondence of the verdict of the district court of the Constitution of all our huge country. But the most important law of our entire huge country was tested on the subject, can it stop the damage to Russian legislation, if someone is needed and profitable?
Looking ahead, we note that this test the Russian constitution, apparently, did not pass. It turned out that anyone can spoil it and as you like, and constitutional judges have neither constitutional bailiffs nor constitutional policemen in order to send them to understand the violators. Yes, and admit, they do not have enough passionarity to send someone somewhere, because those who spoil, they pay our judges salaries and give them flashing lights.
However, another bonus level has recently appeared.
From a somewhat unexpected and paradoxical side - from Syria. The fact is that in the divided Syria we are trying to do something like the “Soviet occupation zone”, since it was not for nothing that it was bombed so much? And the “Gadeyr” Syrians in this connection proposed “Soviet” the version of the Constitution, made by specialists from the administration of the Russian president. According to this option, the people of Syria in the Russian zone of occupation should receive all legal rights and freedoms. And illegal - Yok! - Do not get. It is strange that the official representatives of the Syrian people did not delight with the Russian version, considering it probably too democratic. Savages, they did not understand their happiness. After all, that the Soviet Constitution, that the current Russians completely do not limit the initiative of the "elected representatives of the people", they can completely calmly repair any infringement, referring to the national characteristics of the rule of law. Which, in fact, teaches us the case of Dadina.
Let us return, however, to the essence of the initial question.
He, of course, is not in the problem of constitutionality of Article 212.1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, which was introduced in July 2014. And not how it happened that a young man who did not kill anyone, did not kill anyone and did not even break the window, and did not at all cause any suffering and inconvenience, he left for the places remote, as if he had killed or stabbed someone. And not even in whether the “repetition” of certain minor offenses can itself (which, I must say, were not and recorded with frauds) to become a separate significant offense, logically divorced from the initial insignificant offenses recorded with taces. After all, the Duma and a significant part of the prosecutor’s corps is just what they think. But also in what is the source of law in Russia and in general?
One way or another, in this subject there are two versions that are fighting throughout the history of Russia as a kite with a blue.
First: that the source of law is the laws that adopt random psychopaths in the kind of parliament. In our lifetime, as you know, they forbade the adoption of orphans, hungry, on the contrary, ordered to put pressure on foreign frozen geese with bulldozers and came close to arrest for storing high -quality cheese in the refrigerator. And no constitution in this delirium prevented them.
The second: that some higher principles of law are dominated by local laws, and the laws created bypassing these principles are illegitimate.
And although in Russian jurisprudence, mainly the black crows of a sovereign attitude to law and ethics prevail, individual liberal lawyers continue to keep the pigeons in the mind, for which they bow to them. Otherwise, you can’t explain the appearance of such arguments as references to the impossibility of attracting again for the same offense (“And if under the new law signed by the President?”, “And if according to the new law signed by the president,” it is possible ”) and appeal to some foreign practices and codes of“ civilized countries ”, which will not take root on Russian soil.
Until for some time, this position also seemed strong, but recently in the “civilized camps”, some kind of non-notostable ethics of damage began to occur, why it became clear that the Western culture may not have created any higher law. Of course, this discovery does not add optimism to us - neither in this process, nor in general.
Photo: Igor Akimov \ Interpress / TASS