
He withstood a short dispute with his humanitarian friend. He is a filmmaker and sometimes thinks based on the high. “Well, it’s impossible,” he says, “to do this as Kasyanov did. I understand everything. And the fact that the persons from his list are not at all journalists. And the fact that they conduct intensive destructive work in the field of the fractions of the masses. But to go with a list to the US State Department and complain is also unacceptable. Why? Because thereby you refute your own slogan of freedom of speech. Freedom of speech should be absolute. ” "Even if the above -mentioned characters are its absolute owners and managers at home?" - I am asking. “Even if this is so,” answers my filmmaker, who has not been allowed to shoot a single film for the past ten years, for nothing that he is a laureate and so on and so on ...
Obviously, this opinion goes back to the famous Voltaire “Your opinion is deeply hostile to me, but I will give my life for your right to express it ...”
God knows where Francois-Marie Arue Volter said this and for what reason, but it should be noted that the famous satirist still never lived in such societies where his opponents would really intend to take his life deeply hostile to his philosophy. On the contrary, he personified the omnipotent public opinion of the enlightened West. Behind him stood an educated class, which ultimately defended him from both cleric and monarch. And he died in his bed, and was then placed in Pantheon.
Another thing is Russia. There was never Voltaire in her. And none of the Russian rulers of the Dumas never insisted on an equal Voltaire statement. Well, besides, I would like to see, Voltaire would agree to give his life, for example, for the right of Comrade Stalin to have an opinion that the class struggle is constantly aggravated and that several million people need to be killed on this occasion? Or for Putin’s right to have an opinion that there are things more important than the well -being of the territory entrusted to him in the election. As a result of which, say, it is quite permissible to burn in a nuclear fire behind the Crimea not only hated pindos, but at the same time all the progressive humanity, including blackness for independence in Africa, the aforementioned defendants from the Kasyanov list and, yes, also the coveted Crimea to the addition.
If we draw analogies, then this is like fighting for the rights of a crazy mizanthropic programmer composing a computer virus that will ruin all computers on Earth. I would like to talk about this option with Voltaire.
And on the other hand to see. If this, as claims, is a denunciation of the State Department, then what? The only about the fact that these characters consider their homeland the best place on Earth and their knife in the heart stay in the hated West, which they consider to be an enemy . In any case, they affirm this on every corner, and we took, and we believed them. We went towards and protected from dangerous contact.
The same, in fact, the problem with the worship of the memory of the fallen, which the famous biker club "Night Wolves" is trying to organize. In theory, we, liberals, at every step should defend the right of civilians to move across the borders. Consequently, the right of motorcyclists packed in the skin, who could well remind us of the SS men (if not for the Orthodox crosses and St. George ribbons), go to the places of military Russian glory in Europe.
But no, something is not right in this. Some kind of falsehood. Firstly, this right is not yet imperative, but still a recommendatory, design, goal-setting. But still, unfortunately, there are boundaries and visas. Secondly, since Russia decided to become the “island of Russia” with nuclear missiles spread out in all directions, a whole ocean of mutual understanding has formed between us and Europe. And the organized visit to Europe by the Biker club, which is particularly highlighted and loved by Putin and who, one must think, he has long stuffed it with his agent, if he did not make the roof of a famous office, to put it mildly, very similar to provocation.
Although why "like"? There is a provocation! For what should the columns of the leather Crimeanaries mean passage through Europe? For those who fell seventy years ago, fighters - nothing. For veterans, in my opinion, too. But having nothing to do with victory over the Nazis, bikers are a sea of pleasure. If they miss, then, please, here is the picture: we make everything we want with Europe. As our ancestors took Berlin, so we, descendants, will also take him. And all kinds of Polish border guards are not a decree for us. But there is a significant difference. The ancestors took the fascist Berlin, saving the world from fascism, and we would take a disgustingly democratic Berlin, "saving" him from "European values."
And if they do not miss, then it will be good. You can roll cylinders for Europe for violating human rights and biker. Moving them with unambiguous threats. In the newspaper Free Press, such a magnificent sincere in his circle, like Anna Safran, expresses these aspirations: “We must click Europe (and, above all, Poland) in response to remember 1945.” “... Moreover, many people in the West begin to doubt the“ European values ”, switching to imperial. That is, on our values, Russian. ”
Perhaps the Anna Sharfran will be upset, but so far no one, fortunately, has also canceled European sovereignty. If leather imperial people (I would like to know where they sewed such cool jackets and what means acquired their motorcycles, on which the spaces ware during working hours) want to click Europe on the nose, and Europe, for example, does not want to click on her nose, she has the full right not to allow this. As a result of which a diplomatic incident arises, and the Russian Ministry of the Russian Federation has to run out of a fool and pretend that she does not understand something and “still expects comprehensive explanations in connection with unreasonable and evoking actions” of a European country, which, as we see, is protected from imperial claims.
Of course, in a volter, it seems to be necessary to give a life for the right of the current political commissars to freely cripple the consciousness of Russians. Or for the right of "night wolves" to depict the clicking of European democracies on the nose. But I would like to part with my life somehow more conceptual ...
Photo: Russia. Eagle. April 28, 2015, the leader of the Night Wolves, Alexander Surgeon, Zaldostanov during a motorized run with a relay, “Fire of Memory-Unity Fire” along the route Moscow-Tula-Orenel. Artem Geodakyan/TASS