Chairman of the Constitutional Court Valery Zorkin, in an interview with Rossiyskaya Gazeta, criticized State Duma deputies who ignore decisions on the unconstitutionality or incorrect interpretation of various norms. Today, the Duma “owes” the Constitutional Court about thirty amendments to legislation. Zorkin complains that “the legislator is in no hurry, and sometimes, unfortunately, the courts do not implement our decisions.”
Thus, several years ago, the Constitutional Court decided to compensate citizens for harm caused as a result of the abuses of a judge under Article 1070 of the Civil Code “Liability for harm caused by illegal actions of the bodies of inquiry, preliminary investigation, prosecutor’s office and court,” but so far, according to chairman, “no reaction from the legislator.” In 2006, the Constitutional Court declared unconstitutional Article 405 of the Criminal Procedure Code, which made it impossible to resume proceedings in the supervisory authority, leading to a worsening of the situation of the convicted person (in exceptional circumstances, if a significant error was discovered that makes the sentence unfair) - it has not yet been corrected.
According to Zorkin, “if parliament has not corrected the law, the courts should accept such cases for proceedings and review them, based on the requirements of the Constitution and taking into account our relevant decisions.”
In the same interview, the chairman of the Constitutional Court expressed dissatisfaction with the increasing number of Russian cases in the Strasbourg court - “despite the fact that our country has all the professional and organizational capabilities to resolve most of them with the help of our domestic justice.” Assuring the interviewer that he does not want to block our citizens’ road to Strasbourg, Zorkin emphasized that it is necessary to “make our own domestic system rational”, “so that the supranational subsidiary court does not replace the national (domestic) authorities of the Russian Federation.” To do this, he said, it is necessary “in accordance with the decision of the Constitutional Court adopted back in February 2007, to reform the system of instances in courts of general jurisdiction by analogy with how it was done in the system of arbitration courts: first of all, it is necessary to create full-fledged appellate and cassation instance”, “to exclude the possibility of repeated review of court decisions by way of supervision, otherwise the stability and fairness of these decisions will be undermined” and to give powers to domestic courts “to resolve cases related to compensation for harm caused to citizens due to non-execution of court decisions, due to for violations of reasonable time limits for consideration of cases, as well as due to abuses committed in legal proceedings when considering a specific case, or due to illegal detention, or violation of the regime for serving a sentence,” since it is precisely for this kind of violations that most complaints are sent to Strasbourg.