
In recent weeks, the media, public and political figures, cultural and scientific figures, and the opposition have been quite actively discussing the abolition of jury trials for those accused under articles of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation under investigation by the FSB and the expansion of the grounds for prosecution under Articles 275, 276 and 283 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (high treason, espionage, disclosure of state secrets). On the other hand, the authors of the changes pursue their line with manic persistence, not paying attention to any objections and arguments.
The head of the Duma Security Committee, Vladimir Vasiliev, admitted that the “reform” of the article on high treason is associated with the difficulty of proving this very high treason. This means that after the adoption of the amendments, it will become much easier for investigators to present their conjectures and assumptions to the court instead of legally significant evidence, which was done, of course, before, but, as they say, in person. And judges dependent on the authorities will, without further ado, make the decisions that the authorities need. One of the experts in the Sutyagin case, for example, presented his “evidence” this way: “Based on the available materials, it can be assumed that the specified organization is...”. On the basis of such alleged “evidence” Sutyagin received his 15 years of strict regime. Without any assumptions. Really.
Sentences based on assumptions in cases investigated by the FSB have virtually become the norm. The time has come to formalize this into law.
Note that the key concepts in the changes proposed by the government are the words: foreigners, foreign organizations, international organizations, etc. The idea was hatched for a long time. The “theoretical” basis for the current changes was presented back in April 2000 by the then newly elected president V. Putin. And although Putin’s “ideas” were published several times by various publications, they never received the necessary assessment. We just didn't pay much attention to it. But in vain. Today, the authorities have moved from Putin’s words to action - the restoration of the methods of the NKVD. It seems that we should carefully think about the words of the newly elected (at that time) president. Let us repeat them, perhaps, so that the proposed innovations become more understandable, as well as the persistence with which the security officers implement them.
Speaking in the State Duma on April 19, 2000, Vladimir Putin said: “Dear Gennady Nikolaevich, dear deputies! Before I report to you on the substance of today’s issue, I would like to very briefly respond to comments that, I believe, should not be ignored. First of all, I join Yevgeny Maksimovich Primakov regarding the remarks addressed to members of the government, including the Minister of Foreign Affairs. If the Minister of Foreign Affairs is seen to be maintaining contacts with representatives of foreign states outside the scope of his official duties, then he, just like any other members of the government, deputies of the State Duma, leaders of factions, just like all other citizens of the Russian Federation Federation, will be subjected to certain procedures in accordance with the criminal law (emphasis added - E.Ch.). And I must say that the latest events that are being carried out in the Federal Security Service tell us that this is quite possible.”
Speaking about the criminal law, Putin was clearly in a hurry and wishful thinking. Of course, there was no law on criminal liability for communication with foreigners then, but I really wanted to put him in prison. So I had to pull out articles about high treason and disclosure of state secrets. Intimidation of society began. The latest events meant the prosecution of Alexander Nikitin, Grigory Pasko and a group of famous Russian scientists for high treason. In this speech, Putin simply let it slip and there he confirmed that the FSB is persecuting citizens simply for collaborating with foreigners, and not at all for the mythical treason or disclosure of state secrets. Only now, it seems, the time has come to implement the KGB idea. Today everyone who is interested in their future knows how it is implemented. Now interaction with foreigners and foreign organizations is built into criminal legislation (Criminal Code of the Russian Federation) and has become a criminal act. And communication itself is given the status of high treason.
There is one more circumstance related to the list of information constituting a state secret. The latest list was announced by Presidential Decree No. 90 on February 11, 2006. So, in this list there is Article 98, which classifies “Information revealing... methods of conducting investigations in criminal cases of crimes against the foundations of the constitutional system, state security , peace or the security of mankind...”. This means that, contrary to the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation, which regulates the conduct of the investigation, some special, but hidden from society, “methods” of conducting the investigation have been invented. Most likely, these are the methods (as torture is shyly called) that are still used today to obtain the necessary testimony (remember the story of Pumane?). It’s just that before this Decree they did not have a regulatory basis. Now combine the abolition of jury trials, changes to Articles 275, 276 and 283 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation with “special methods” of conducting investigations under such articles. Did you guess it? Recognition will be ensured. And no jury for you!
Will anyone now dare to say that the current heads of the special services are bad students of comrades Stalin, Yezhov and Beria? No way. Back on January 10, 1939 (Yuri Stetsovsky. “History of Soviet Repressions”, 1997, vol. 1, p. 159) one of the documents of the Central Committee said: “The Central Committee of the All-Union Communist Party of Bolsheviks (Bolsheviks) believes that the method of physical influence should be used and henceforth, as an exception, in relation to obvious and undisarmed enemies of the people, as a completely correct and appropriate method.”
There is just a little bit left and the regulatory framework - the remake of the 30s will be ready for use. History should remember well the authors of the idea and the creators of the legislative framework for such a remake. It would be naive to assume that all the fuss and haste associated with these amendments is simply a legislative itch of our wonderful deputies.