
On January 28, another discussion was held on the new stage of the Alexandrinsky Theater as part of the Open Library project. Historians Julia Kantor and Yuri Pivovarov participated. Nikolay Solodovnikov was discussed. During the discussion, historians expressed a lot of extraordinary thoughts, which featured the author of these notes to share impressions of it.
The unique tradition of supervasia
Yu. Pivovarov noted that in no Christian country there was and there was no tradition of absolute sole power, as in Russia. The words of Paul I are characteristic: "In Russia, only that one means, while I talk to him." In other Christian countries, including the Orthodox, the ruling elites have always found ways to limit the power of the monarch, for example, due to the independence of the church and its hierarchs. Our power is always personified, everyone knows who is the main in the country and who cannot disobey. Such a tradition of supervasia (today - the super -presidential republic) came to us not from Byzantium, but from the Horde, whose khans gave the Russian princes the labels for autocratic reign.
The draft Constitution, developed by Speransky for Alexander II, provided for the separation of the powers over which the king was the right to cancel any decisions, execute or mercy. The first Russian Constitution of 1906, which Nicholas II agreed, was written according to the patterns of the Speransky Constitution. But the 1993 Constitution reproduces the same Speransky system. And today everything fundamentally important in Russia depends on the sole decision of the president.
The difference between European civilization and the Russian one, Pivovarov noted that the European is anthropocentric, for it the main thing is a person, his life, rights, freedom, self -realization. Our Russian civilization is power -centric, everything is imprisoned in it, on the privileges with which it bless the loyal to it. In the European states, there is a monopoly on violence against the law that had undergone, but the Convention on the Rights of Citizens and Bodies also works there. And this convention is respected! And in Russia - the violence of those in power, not limited by any convention. Designed in the Constitution, it does not work.
Pivovarov added that with such a system it is important not only who is the ruler in his views and deeds, but also what heir he will leave behind. To grow a successor sharing your views is a super -task. Yeltsin lost her. And yet, to the presenter’s question, as he evaluates Yeltsin, Pivovarov described him as a great man. Indeed, largely thanks to his courage and firmness and, of course, the support of part of the Muscovites, the Russians themselves achieved the liberation from the CPSU tyranny, from an extremely ineffective administrative-command system in an economy that doomes people into poverty. Compare: the Germans themselves could not free themselves from tyranny of the Nazis, they were liberated by the Americans. Added: Yeltsin did not execute the conspirators twice - at all atypical for Russian rulers
Julia Kantor called the 1990s a short era of transition to possible freedom. The economic decline caused by the transition to the market and the demilitarization of enterprises painfully hit many. But there was freedom of speech in the press and on television, freedom of rallies and meetings, freedom of participation in the elections of newly created parties, freedom of citizens to offer and defend their opinion. But it turned out that we still have to be able to defend freedom. We did not manage to.
I note that the current substantive culture of Russians (the culture of the “Leader-Step”) rises its roots to instincts, to genetically fixed programs. In the struggle for hunting grounds, those herds of primitive people won whose members were cramped around the leader in any difficult situation. The development of culture allowed many peoples to get away from the primitive rules of life, to create a real separation of powers and ensure the rule of law, but this was beyond strength for the Russians.
On the role of historians in modern society
In Russia today there is practically no public policy, that is, disputes in parliament and on state television channels on the country's development routes. The words of the former speaker of the State Duma "Parliament is not a place for discussions!" Exactly reflect the position of power and most of the society. And in this situation, historians are engaged in politics. Moreover, both the people and the authorities have no vision of the future. If the Bolsheviks fogged their heads with fairy tales about a bright future - communism, today many want to make the future of the past. Hence the privileges of the Church, and the monument to Tiran to Ivan the Terrible.
When the historian serves power, he turns into a servant. The historian Sergei Piontkovsky, mobilized by the Bolsheviks to work on writing the desired story, has an entry in the diary: “I can’t adapt in any way ...” No matter how hard he tried, all the same, the Bolsheviks shot him.
It has become more difficult for historians today. Julia Kantor noted that access to archives is gradually closing. And not because a special law was adopted or an order has been issued, fear of the authorities is working: no matter what happened ... A kind of self -censorship is acting, similar to the one that many authors and officials are sick today. Some, even of their own free will, climb into the service of power, demonstrate the stunned solidarity with her. Julia Kantor gave an example: the rector of Moscow State University Sadovnichi voluntarily sent a letter to the governor of the Oryol region for the opening of the monument to the bloody Ivan the Terrible.
Others are to blame for everything
Participants in the discussion noted that over the 70 years of the Bolshevik tyranny, the type of man, convinced that we ourselves are not to blame for all our troubles, but other peoples, other countries. The Soviet Empire rejected the idea of its own original sin. The fact that our income is largely inferior to European, Obama is to blame, and not us and not our power.
Pivovarov noted that among young people an extremely dangerous nostalgia for the USSR is manifested. The current students in spirit are more and more - Komsomol members. Or we can say - the guardsmen in the service of those in power. Most want to work in the civil service in the calculation of corruption income or in Gazprom, where salaries and premium bonuses. Many people justify Stalin: yes, he molested millions of compatriots, but he won the war!
The primitive representation of the courtyard hooligans dominates: "We are respected because they are afraid." Therefore, they are ready to live starving, without medicine and ambulance, but spend budget funds on a military -industrial complex and the army.
The law that was drawn up
Julia Kantor noted that the saying “The Law that Dad” is fair today. Therefore, Russians do not delve into the norms of laws, which they understand: the law can be any, problems can be solved through connections or bribe. And the main thing will be not the law in the court’s decision, but the instructions of the authorities. In Russia, the authorities do not like laws and legality. Many adopted laws contain articles that give the official the opportunity to make a decision at their discretion or for a rollback. In the USSR, laws were distinguished by maximum vague, in reality the rules were formulated by by -laws, and some of them were not available to the population. By the way, in the USSR there was no law on the CPSU. So formally the CPSU was an illegal organization.
When the current government needs to create something anti-constitutional, it uses not by laws, but of all kinds of decrees or simply acts “according to the call”. Example: the presidential administration, a body not provided for by the Constitution of the Russian Federation, but with exceptional powers. This is a dead end in the development of our statehood.
However, Pivovarov noted that in some cases, the norms of even the current superpretant constitution allow us to ensure compliance with the law. The Constitutional Court canceled the presidential decrees three times. Not so long ago, paper was sent from the government to universities about the need to introduce the position of vice -rector according to ideology. This caused indignation, as the constitution prohibits official ideology. The initiative has stalled so far. So arbitrariness is limited by the norms of even this constitution.
Nevertheless, the revision of the current Constitution in favor of the parliamentary republic and ensuring the independence of the court should become the slogan of the intelligentsia, which advocates the European path of development of Russia. So far, such a constitution has not been adopted and will not take measures to overcome the imaginary culture of Russians, until the indifference to the fate of the country will dominate - “we are not to blame for anything and do not want to intervene in anything” - Russia will stomp in the spot or sink into the swamp of poverty of poorly developed countries.
Going out after the discussion, I thought: what are the goals, interests, desires of the current sole ruler of Russia? Raising the living standards of the population? No, the money goes into service. The victory of communist utopia around the world? No, he is a pragmatist, prefers money, like his associates. Restoration of the Russian Empire? Unrealistic. But I thought that Hitler in the basement of the Reich Chancellery, if he had a nuclear suitcase in his hands, would rather press a button. Superwater in Russia, which has 44% of nuclear weapons, poses a threat to humanity. As a view, we can end due to the mood of one superpower. People, doesn't it bother you?