Politics or Socialist?
The question of the priority of political or economic rights for the modern Russian opposition, raised in the article by Mikhail Delyagin , causes bewilderment for several significant reasons.To begin with, the platform for combining various political forces differs from the election slogans, the development of which represents a separate task. It can be about positions that are consensus for all participants in the unifying process and are unambiguous. Otherwise, the unification project at the very beginning will become stagnant in fruitless disputes about the interpretation of individual theses - and, as is the case with oppositionists who have no chances for quick victory, with emotions and clapping doors.
Imagine for a moment that the opposition, without really uniting, will put forward social slogans. It turns out right there that one of it advocates monetizing the benefits in principle, but against the methods of its implementation, used in 2004. The other part is fundamentally against monetization and at the same time for the preservation (and, perhaps, expansion) of the Soviet system of benefits. The third will immediately offer the option of modifying the preferential system. The fourth, looking at this discussion, will simply leave quietly. The same applies to health care and education. Should they be completely free? Or 90%? Or at 70? And so on. All these issues can be agreed within the framework of the general project, but only if it already exists, and is not in the formation stage.
In modern Russia, with all the importance of socio-economic topics, there are no questions from this sphere that could be formulated in one or two words. At the beginning of the twentieth century in European countries, such a topic was an eight-hour working day-now many Russians are ready to work 10-12 hours in order to make a career (leaders) or make ends meet (outsiders). In Bolivia, the first half of the 50s was a powerful public request for the nationalization of tin mines-in Russia, the demand for nationalization of a large industry is able to split not only the opposition, but also the society as a whole. You can give many other examples that do not change the essence of the matter.
At the same time, political topics are much more consensus. Democracy (without additional verbal definitions), freedom of speech, assemblies, demonstrations, printing, conscience, independent judicial system, normal competitive elections - these provisions can be acceptable for a wide range of sane political forces that differ among themselves in many other aspects of their party programs.
In addition, democratic principles will allow to separate those political forces with which the liberal cannot enter into any coalition agreements without danger to lose its own identity and, in the end, be political bankrupt. Mikhail Delyagin speaks of the 1993 coalition, which was of a motley character - it included the Communists, Nationalists, as well as part of the radical democrats who could not “integrate” into the regime of Boris Yeltsin. How it all ended is well known - the former democrats ended up in the immoral union with the GG. Makashov and Barkashov. Moreover, the union turned out to be not only immoral, but also extremely unsuccessful for those who defended the White House twice (in the 91st and 93rd). After some time, Makashov was chosen to the Duma, where he continued his career as a politician and anti -Semite, and retired democrats turned out to be no one.
Now that "honest liberals simply underestimate the significance for the population of the goals that these liberals themselves have long achieved in personal quality." This thesis-and then partially-is relevant for the 90s, the time of “storm and onslaught” for the liberal political movement, when many important topics that really exciting the population really remained behind him. Partly-because the “Yabloko” already put forward a well-thought-out social program that could not “reach” to voters, for many reasons that were not directly related to the program provisions (from the general bipolarization of the political process in the 90s to the prevailing image of Yavlinsky as a theorist that was not able to solve practical problems). However, now the situation looks different. For some time, the ATP did not carefully appeal to the pensioners, which, apparently, became one of the main reasons for his conflict with the Kremlin (the right unexpectedly began to take part of the electorate of United Russia). The Republican Party Vladimir Ryzhkov in its program announced the unacceptability of the approach to it, according to which "first you need to raise the economy, and only then invest in the social sphere."
The problem is that the most striking social initiatives become electorally meaningless if the party cannot not only participate in the elections, but generally exist. The registrars counted 38 thousand members to the same republicans, after which the party was liquidated, despite the fact that its leaders convincingly proved that there were more than 50 thousand in its lists, which was enough for the existence of RPR. And a large -scale campaign, deployed against the ATP, broke all the electoral plans of party leaders, including those based on the “socialization” of software installations. Thus, Alexander Ryklin is completely right, speaking of the relationship of political and social demands (despite the fact that it is impossible to agree with the style of his answer to Delyagin - it can only reduce the number of supporters of the future opposition project).
It seems that in modern Russia a serious opposition may be in demand - if not now, then in the medium term. The role of liberal bureaucracy in the modernization of the country, as in the previous periods of Russian history, remains significant. In this matter, I cannot agree with the radical critics of the authorities - I intend to state my position in the next article in the “HED”. But without real party competition, it is impossible to create a stable political system that can function in normal mode. Only the opposition project receives a chance for implementation if it is not initially shocked by software disagreements.
Author-Vice President of the Center for Political Technology