
Why did the director of the FSB Bortnikov issue an order in which half of the points concerns Roscosmos and Rogozin personally. Why the "Soldiers' mothers" ceased their activities. What can we talk about now in Russia now
On this day, 51 years ago, on October 8, 1970, Alexander Solzhenitsyn was declared a Laureate of the Nobel Prize in Literature. It was a weighty slap in the Soviet Union and personally Leonid Ilyich.
In response in the Soviet media, Travlya Solzhenitsyn was deployed, which was declared a “literary vine” and “slanderer”. A special unit was created in the KGB, which was exclusively operating Solzhenitsyn’s development: the 9th department of the 5th department. Along with the collective letters of workers and collective farmers who “did not read, but condemn”, Din’s open letter was published, in which the American singer explained to the “dear colleague in Solzhenitsyn’s art”, that “the Soviet Union always goes ahead of the twentieth century”, and “blacks are hung” in the United States ...
Today, the Nobel Committee will announce the Nobel laureate of the world. Among 329 candidates, experts called those whose chances are higher. This:
“Reporters without borders”, committee of protection of journalists, Svetlana Tikhanovskaya, Executive Secretary of the UN Frame Convention on Climate Climate Patrician Espinosis, Israeli human rights organization “BECELE” and Palestinian Center for Human Rights, Defender of Uyghur's Rights Ilham Tokhti and activist from Hon Kong Nathan Lau, World Healthcare Organization, World Academy of Health. Greta Tunberg, Alexei Navalny, Prime Minister of New Zealand Jasinda Ardern, Office of the UN Supreme Commissioner for Refugee Affairs, US President Joe Biden and Black Lives Matter- “ Life of black ones matters ”).
If the Nobel Prize in Literature is a political slap in the face only in some cases (as in the case of Solzhenitsyn), then the Nobel Prize of the World becomes a political challenge in most cases. And today the Nobel Committee has a choice: to follow the path of a compromise or challenge to authoritarian regimes.
The path of a compromise is to give a prize of some well-known and well-deserved international organization (except, perhaps, WHO, whose employees sent to the Democratic Republic of the Congo to combat the flash of Ebola fever /2018–2020 /are accused of rape and sexual exploitation of local residents, and too many issues for the WHO).
Will the Nobel Committee decide to give a public slap in the face to the main dictators of the planet, calling the laureates of the Navalny world (slap in Putin), Tikhanovskaya (the slap of Lukashenko, well, and Putin at the same time), Ilham Tokhti or Nathan Lau (each of these people is a call of Xi Jinping)? And if he decides, then to whom? On what scales can we weigh the contribution of each of the candidates to strengthen the world, to the struggle against aggressive dictatorial regimes? If we proceed from the fact that the largest aggressor on the planet with nuclear weapons is Putin's Russia, then Alexei Navalny deserves more than others. However, we will find out about the decision of the Nobel Committee very soon ...
Now about the events of the already occurred. The organization "Soldiers' mothers of St. Petersburg", providing assistance to conscripts and military personnel, suspended its activities due to the approved FSB of the list of information, for the disclosure of which you can get into the register of foreign agents or even go to jail.
The reason was the order of the director of the FSB Bortnikov No. 379 dated 09/28/2021 on the list of information that does not constitute a state secret that can be used against the security of Russia.
In the case of a purposeful collection of information included in this list, any individual - both a citizen of Russia and another state - must independently contact the Ministry of Justice with a statement about its inclusion in the register of “foreign agents”. If he does not, he is facing a criminal prosecution.
In the list of 60 points. A little more than half concerns the Shoigu department, almost half - Rogozin's Roscosmos.
According to the department, Shoigu is now forbidden to collect in open sources and publish:
- information on the assessments and forecasts of the development of military-political, strategic (operational) situation ”;
- information on compliance with the rule of law and the moral and psychological climate in the troops;
- Information on the progress and results of consideration of reports of crimes in the army, which are investigated by the FSB and the military investigation of the Investigative Committee.
That is, Bortnikov completely closed the Shoigu department with his order not only from any criticism, but also from any public expert assessments. From now on, he from now on, not only “soldiers' mothers” and other human rights activists who are involved in the problems of hazing and other crimes in the army (including corruption), but also all military experts and military observers, as it is impossible to write about the army, avoiding “assessments and forecasts”, after the order of Bortnikov No. 379, is a criminal offense.
The second part of the Bortnikov List completely closes Roscosmos from any publicity. It is forbidden, for example, to collect and publish “information about problems, including financial and economic, restraining the development of Roscosmos Corporation in one or more areas of activity.”
Since one of the main problems of Roscosmos is the monstrous incompetence of his absurd leader, this means the taboo of any public mention of Dmitry Rogozin, except in the press releases of Roscosmos himself.
Another obvious problem of the Russian space department was the equal sign, for some reason set between the Goskosmos state corporation and simply with space and its development. Elon Musk quite convincingly proved that his private “trampolines” are much more effective than the products of the life of Rogozin and the state corporation led by him, which, in addition to “patriotism”, has recently been producing little.
This whole story with the “Bortnikov List” is permeated by the spirit of a defiantly arrogant lawlessness. Since the head of one of the bitch, the executive branch of the authorities prohibits the over the law on GOSTain, other laws on specially protected secrets, prohibits collecting and publishing obviously unexpected information from open sources.
On a completely fair question, and with what on earth Bortnikov assigns the role of the legislator to himself, there is a reasonable historical answer. He belongs to Emperor Pavel the first: "In Russia, only the one I speak with, and as long as I speak with him." In modern Russia, the source of power is not a people, as the Constitution crushed and raped not of hemp on the summer whispers about this, but Putin personally, from which power flows into his environment with dirty streams. Here, a portion of additional power on Bortnikov fell, he issued his censorship decree, directly contrary to the constitution and a good dozen laws.
As for the modern Russian regime, one of the characteristics of which was given by Emperor Pavel the First, Pavel Petrovich himself was convinced of the inaccuracy of his maxim at the time of a close acquaintance with the snuffbox (or with a scarf, which in this case does not matter) ...
PS, after the publication of the text, it became known that Dmitry Muratov and Maria Ressa (Philippines) became the Nobel Prize laureates. Of course, one can be happy for them (especially for Muratov), but what was not given to Navalny is very vain ...
Photo: Kremlin.ru under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License