On January 17, the next meeting of the Initiative Group, convened between rallies for fair elections on December 10 and 24, was held. The meeting was attended, in particular, by the co-chairman of “Solidarity” Boris Nemtsov, the head of the movement “For Human Rights” Lev Ponomarev, the leader of the Movement in Defense of the Khimki Forest Evgenia Chirikova, representatives of the Human Rights Center “Memorial”, the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, “A Just Russia”, and nationalists. The chairman was the representative of the public movement “White Ribbon” Igor Bakirov, but from time to time the rights to conduct the meeting were assumed by the Duma deputy from “A Just Russia” and Left Front activist Ilya Ponomarev or the coordinator of the Left Front Sergei Udaltsov.
After talking lightly about the relationship of the Initiative Group with other organizations involved in protest rallies and related activities (Udaltsov and Ilya Ponomarev spoke about negotiations with representatives of the League of Active Voters (LAKI), Nemtsov described his vision of the distribution of functions between the Organizing Committee (which has not met since December 24), League and Initiative Group), the meeting began to discuss the possibility of creating a public coalition. A proposal was made that a broad social movement should be created, and within it a certain structure that would coordinate the work of movement participants. As a result, this idea was supported by the majority, it was decided to call the movement the Civil Movement, and the coordination structure - the Civil Council.
A version of the Civil Harmony Agreement was adopted, the drafting of which, after disputes at the previous meeting, was fought over by Lev and Ilya Ponomarevs and the representative of the Russian Social Movement, Konstantin Krylov, assigned to them. As a result, the text retained a reference to the inadmissibility of discrimination based on race and nationality.
The text of the political declaration was read - proposals for the action on February 4 under the slogans “No to Putin! No to autocracy! For a fair and free Russia!” Many meeting participants made various suggestions, which were taken into account and transferred to the drafting group. After the editorial team has processed the text, it will be posted on Facebook for discussion.
An unusually long time was spent discussing the rules of the Civil Council. It was hard for the coordinator of the regulation group, Left Front activist Alexei Sakhnin. The main point of contention was the issue regarding the formation of the council. The regulatory group proposed compiling a 60-member council, half based on online voting and half drawn from representatives from several sectors. The meeting participants argued for a particularly long time about whether it was necessary to use voting on the Internet at all when forming the composition of the council and which specific sectors would be on it. The confusion was caused by a member of the regulations group, a representative of the unregistered Pirate Party, Alexander Shubin, who undertook to lead the vote regarding the composition of the council. He invited those gathered to vote on how many sectors there would be delegates on the council, without first specifying what those sectors should be. In addition, it remains unclear to many whether these sectors will include a list of people for whom they vote on the Internet or not. Shubin implied that online voting would take place in addition to the delegation of council members from sectors. In the end, the meeting voted not to vote for council members online (apparently, many were greatly impressed by the story of cheating in voting for possible speakers at the December 24 rally). There were four sectors, the majority agreed that three of them would be political (liberals, leftists, nationalists - the question was asked whether representatives of the national movements of some Russian republics would be included here, but no answer was received). It was decided to give the fourth sector to public organizations, and the option that won the vote was that there would be as many public activists in the council as there were all politicians in total. The council will include sixty people. Another reason for controversy and almost a scandal was the discussion of the principle of formation of each of the sectors. After the majority voted for the option, according to which the order within the political curiae is left to the political sectors, and the formation of the curia of representatives of social movements is determined through online voting for the social movements themselves. After this, Igor Bakirov said that the “White Ribbon” was leaving the meeting sign as a sign of protest, since the principles of formation should not be imposed on civil society. He was persuaded to stay. In the end, it was decided that public organizations would form the curia themselves, but other curiae had the right of veto. Nationalist Vladimir Tor especially advocated for this veto, bearing in mind that council members from public organizations could turn out to be politically biased. The meeting decided that the opinion of two political curiae was sufficient to impose a veto. Bakirov and representative of the Pirate Party Pavel Rassudov (from social activists), Udaltsov, Lev Ponomarev (from liberals) and Thor were appointed responsible from the curiae.
The most pressing agenda item, concerning the scenario for the February 4 action, was postponed until the end of the meeting. And in the finale, Ilya Ponomarev announced that since LACI had not yet held its meeting on the same topic, it made sense to wait and hold a joint discussion. There was some pity for the activists of “The Other Russia” who came to the meeting of the Initiative Group for the first time (remember, party leader Eduard Limonov was the only one who considered himself offended in connection with the transfer of the December 10 rally from Revolution Square to Bolotnaya and refused to participate in the further activities of numerous organizers, however, in anticipation protests on February 4 changed from anger to mercy, explaining this by the fact that many ordinary participants in the protest actions approached him with a request to join) and waited several hours only to be told that their proposal to expand the list of co-applicants of the action (completing the list with protest participants shares of previous months and years) is irrelevant. In the end, the scenario of the action was never discussed. It was decided to schedule the next meeting for January 26. Let's see if activists from The Other Russia will come there. At the same time, the relationship between the newly formed Civil Movement and the Organizing Committee of the action, which, apparently, will also meet sooner or later, remains unclear. Thus, Nemtsov believes that the organization of the action should be carried out by the Organizing Committee, and the Initiative Group, also known as the Civil Movement, should be responsible for carrying out political reform. It is unlikely that those members of the Civil Movement who are not members of the Organizing Committee (and only Alexei Navalny and Udaltsov, who was not present at the meeting, and, possibly, Ilya Ponomarev (well, Nemtsov, but he did not stay at the meeting of the Civil Movement) are included) agree with this .