
Bishop Diomede is preparing for the Local Council. This is evidenced, on the one hand, by the ease with which he is ready to resign from the rank of bishop, on the other, by an appeal to the church court and, in general, by his expressed intention to remain within the canonical boundaries of the church, even “even as a simple monk.” Local council, i.e. The council of all layers of the church people, including the clergy and laity, and not just its hierarchical elite, has not been canceled by the current Charter on the governance of the Russian Orthodox Church de jure, although de facto, according to this document, the prospect of convening such a council has become very illusory.
Having lost hope of the support of the Council of Bishops, Bishop Diomede and his supporters are conducting a loud PR campaign for the right to be the voice of the entire church people. Time will tell how successful it is. So far, the steps being taken are quite logical. Simple ideas that are understandable to the “simple believer” are put forward. Then they demonstrate their readiness to defend them even in the event of a real threat of defrocking—the loss of, so to speak, “institutional status.” Which also seems quite logical, because In the entire history of Russian Orthodoxy, there is hardly a single bishop who not only heroically challenged the authorities, like Arseny (Matseevich), or gained popularity as a spiritual writer like Feofan (Govorov), but who led a mass spiritual movement. Among the Orthodox people, bearers of bright personal charisma—elders—who often could have a very modest or even no institutional status at all, enjoyed and enjoy much greater veneration. Yes, Rev. Sergius of Radonezh avoided ordination for a long time, remaining a simple monk, St. Seraphim of Sarov was just a deacon, and one of the leaders of the founded St. Seraphim of the 150,000-strong Orthodox people's movement of interlocutors, Peter Chigrinsky was completely a layman. It is precisely this niche of the charismatic (non-institutional) spiritual leader of the church that supporters of Rasputin’s canonization seek to occupy. It is precisely this that Lord Diomede lays claim to.
Whether he succeeds or not depends not only on skillful PR. (Which, by the way, is now difficult, since the main information resource on which he could count - radio and the Radonezh newspaper - are controlled by his opponents. Diomede's supporters have only a couple of far-right sites and blogs at their disposal.) And not only from the bishops’ readiness to consistently defend their positions. They are no longer as easily intimidated by the threat of a split as the fundamentalists were able to do in the early 90s. The quality of the program proposed by Diomid is important. And for all its popularity and accessibility, it is far from perfect. Of course, the process of secularization, which in our country, as well as throughout the world, is not slowing down, is ambiguous and fraught with serious losses for the church. The spirit of worldliness also penetrates inside the church fence, at least in the form of “glamorous Orthodoxy.” And here the concern of the “Diomidovites” is understandable. But this spirit can hardly be defeated by spells alone, to which the “program” of Diomede’s supporters, built on the denial of current church policy, largely boils down to. A new information age with its universality and multiculturalism is inevitably approaching. Central Russian villages with Caucasian populations, Afro-Russians and Central Asian residents of Russian cities have long become part of our everyday life. Under these conditions, it is possible to propose solutions that worked successfully in the agricultural or even industrial era, but it is not productive.
Here the emphasis on enlightenment, education, the revival of community life and overcoming the alienation between the hierarchy and the people, made by the last Council of Bishops, seems more justified. Moreover, for example, Metropolitan Kirill and his supporters also, apparently, do not reject the idea of a Local Council in principle. In recent years, in the speeches of Bishop Kirill and other DECR leaders, the process of preparing the Local Council of 1917-18 has been cited as a favorite example of correct intra-church discussion. Apparently, they do not hope to resolve all church issues solely in the spirit of curialism (the theory according to which the highest authority in the Church belongs to its first hierarch - “Hedgehog”).
Whose program will be accepted by the church people? Who will reach the finish line first? There are no answers to these questions yet; it is only clear that the “non-institutional” process of preparing the Local Council has already been launched.
Alexander Burov - deputy. editor-in-chief of the newspaper "Kifa", scientific. co-workers State Museum of the History of Religion (GMIR)