
This week, the next meeting of the interdepartmental working group on religious education of the Commission on Religious Associations under the Government of the Russian Federation, dedicated to the problem of state accreditation of theological schools, is scheduled to take place. The working group was created almost a year ago, after the first discussion of the problem of accreditation at a government commission - then everything ended in nothing. Representatives of the Ministry of Education and Science emphasized that the issue
has no solutionwithin the framework of existing educational legislation. Not much progressed further at subsequent meetings, of which there were no less than three - this time with the participation of the working group.
The question is really difficult. On the one hand, our Church is separated from the state, therefore government agencies do not have the right to certify the work of religious organizations, which by status are religious educational institutions, and therefore cannot allow them to issue state-issued diplomas. But, on the other hand, for several years now there have been versions of the state standard “theology”: for the “bachelor” level since 1993, “master” - since 2001, according to the traditional five-year education system with the specialty "theology" - since 2002 . The Church is ready to teach its students based on these standards. A workaround is also possible: highlight a general humanities block in the list of seminar subjects and receive state accreditation “for it.” In order not to further confuse the problem, it was decided to begin by limiting ourselves to considering the issue of the legal possibility of applying state standards in theological schools. And then, it seems, things got off the ground.
“The letter signed by the Deputy Minister of Education and Science, which we received, contains agreement with the wording that we proposed,” Andrei Sebentsov, deputy chairman of the Commission on Religious Associations under the Government of the Russian Federation, head of the working group, told the Daily Journal. “At the same time, the ministry believes that the law “On Education” does not even require changes and makes it possible to limit ourselves only to amendments to the law “On Freedom of Conscience and Religious Associations,” for which amendments regarding other things are currently being prepared. The following entry should be made there: religious educational institutions have the right to provide education according to state educational standards and, if accredited, issue a state diploma.”
This formulation gives hope that sooner or later professional religious education will receive legal status in society and seminarians, on an equal basis with everyone else, will have the right and opportunity to study on exchange in other, non-theological educational institutions or continue their education abroad. Resolving the issue with theological schools is also important for Russia from the point of view of joining the so-called Bologna process. Russia signed the Bologna Agreement adopted in 1999, which assumes that by 2010 the education system in European countries will acquire many common features. But in Europe, graduates of theological schools have rights equal to all others. Somewhere (for example, Italy) the so-called nostrification has been adopted - recognition of the equivalence of diplomas from state and church schools; somewhere this is regulated by other legislative norms. But nowhere are church professionals considered second-class citizens.
However, as it turns out, the Bologna Agreement simultaneously poses a considerable danger for religious education in Russia. To fit into the pan-European system, we need to significantly reduce the number of educational standards - according to some sources, almost tenfold. Now there are supposedly 400-500 of them in Russia, but only 40-50 will remain. Many fear that the “theology” standard, which has had many opponents, will also be cut. The head of the department of programs and standards of the Ministry of Education and Science, Nelly Rozina, confirmed to EZh that a revision of the list of standards is in the plan, but noted that “it is not yet clear what will be reduced.” Andrei Sebentsov believes that it would be wrong to abolish the theological standard. “He was born in pain, many believed that he was not needed, but, like a child, once he was born, it would be a crime to destroy him,” he shared his thoughts with the Daily Journal.
No less important, in my opinion, is something else. If the standard is really abolished, having decided that the theological school will survive without it - it has lived until now - then the entire system of theological education will suffer from this. First of all, of course, secular theological universities and faculties. The number of theological faculties in various universities (Omsk, Ural, Altai, etc.) and institutes is already approaching thirty, and the competition in some places is quite considerable: at the theological department of Tula University, for example, this year it was 8 people per place. And some secular theological universities, most of which arose much earlier than faculties and have existed for 10-15 years, have managed to acquire an established reputation. With the abolition of the standard, they will immediately lose the basis for their existence. Theology will once again be confined within the constrained ecclesiastical framework; there will not be that flow of ideas and opinions, that tension of thought that could have arisen had it developed freely, with healthy competition between church and academic science. In such a situation, it is hardly possible to talk about the restoration of the theological school in its entirety.
Yes, in pre-revolutionary Russia there was no system of secular theological education, but certain theological disciplines were taught at universities, where prominent church scientists taught, and the connection between theological and secular schools was preserved. The Soviet government not only expelled the “priests” from all state educational institutions, but also put an end to the development of theology. Living thought disappeared from the system of church education, and the skills to handle it were gradually lost. The abolition of the theological standard may again drive the theological school into the ghetto.