This is how visitors to the symposium exhibitions interacted with contemporary art. (Photo by Max Novikov )
To be honest, I, who consider myself a modern and enlightened person, do not understand expressions like “digital revolutionization”, “cyberfeminism” or “VRML projects” very well. If the same thing happens to the reader of these lines, I must upset him: he and I are hopelessly backward people. If only because we must take into account the will of the masses. And the masses (young, fashionably dressed, with smart books and magazines in their hands) filled the rather large central auditorium of the Russian State University for the Humanities for four days in a row and regularly listened to reports about “VRML projects”. The first interdisciplinary international symposium "Pro&Contra" was held, dedicated to the influence of new technologies such as all kinds of multimedia and the Internet on modern culture.
But I was reconciled with my own limitations by the solemn greetings to the participants of the symposium, published in its booklet. From the rector of the Russian State University for the Humanities ("it is difficult to overestimate the influence of media culture on all aspects of human activity") and the head of the Department of Government Information of the Government of the Russian Federation ("at a meeting with representatives of the Internet community in December 1999, V.V. Putin expressed interest in the Russian The network segment was actively developing." This is probably the “digital revolutionization” of the entire country. But seriously, the “Pro&Contra” symposium, consisting not only of vigils at the Russian State University for the Humanities, but also exhibitions in galleries, thematic film screenings at the Cinema Museum and parties in nightclubs, is the first truly serious, large-scale international event in many years, dedicated to current culture and supported at the state level.

Moscow artist Gor Chahal for the first time changed his vital orientation to a virtual one. (Photo by Max Novikov )
On the other hand, the state has no choice but to try to tame electronics and Internet workers in the face of a real threat. Online media are crowding out paper media largely due to greater flexibility and the absence of any censorship. And every self-respecting representative of alternative culture has his own website. Therefore, the apogee of “Pro&Contra” was a “round table” in the press center of the Government House of the Russian Federation entitled “State. Information. Internet” and with the participation of ministers Pochinok and Reiman, as well as comrades from the FSB. It was all about the same thing: is it possible and necessary to introduce censorship in a freedom-loving network? (By the way, a Duma hearing of the bill “On Internet Regulation” is scheduled for May 18.)
However, we are writing for the art department, not the politics department. But with the so-called network art, things are not going well. It’s not that it doesn’t exist - it exists, but it kind of exists. To an outsider, any symposium exhibition, say, “Network Art as It Is” in the M. Gelman Gallery, will seem as abstruse and boring as the lectures at the Russian State University for the Humanities. The curators - Marat Gelman himself and employees of the MediaArtLab association (which is also the organizer of the entire symposium) - made an attempt at "traditional exhibition of art living in a different virtual space." That is, they hung Internet projects from different countries not only on Gelman’s web page, but also on the walls of his gallery.
At one time, the melancholy Balts came up with the idea of “burying” other people’s sites that turned out to be unnecessary, creating virtual tombstones for them. The curators of the exhibition took advantage of their invention. The dull one-color prints from the Internet that make up the exhibition are similar to these slabs. Because the projects themselves - cheerful and colorful - live only in the natural environment. On the computer screen.
To enjoy net art, you must first connect to the network. But the pleasure is worth it. This is what the Pro&Contra symposium tried to show.

The classic of Bulgarian contemporary art, Luchezar Boyadzhiev, has long been on the Internet. (Photo by Max Novikov )