Boor tax
Recently, a certain working meeting of representatives of non -governmental organizations took place in Moscow. I will allow myself to quote Oleg Orlov, Chairman of the Council of the Human Rights Center "Memorial". It was about the relationship between Russia and the Strasbourg Court: as for monetary compensation, they are paid in a careful way, day a day. But, in fact, there is a payment of lawlessness tax .
I explain. The European Court is not the highest instance in relation to the judicial system of the state member of the Convention. Therefore, he cannot cancel the decision made by the state authority or the national court, does not give instructions to the legislator, does not exercise abstract control of national legislation or judicial practice, does not have the right to give orders to take measures that have legal consequences. The court considers only specific complaints in order to establish whether violations of the Convention’s requirements were really committed. However, the court has the right to award the “fair satisfaction of the claim” in the form of financial compensation for material damage and non -pecuniary damage, as well as reimbursing the won to the side of all costs and expenses.
Thus, if the ECHR recognizes violations of the rights of a particular person by the Russian Federation (in our case), then we are not talking about the immediate abolition of what the Russian Federation has already drunk, but about the legitimation of the citizen’s resentment against the state. They recognized the insult? Thank you. The money, as Orlov said, is paid without delay. And all. Attempts to find out whether officials who committed a violation of human rights were held accountable. Moreover, in January last year, the first pilot resolution on Russia on the problem of non -fulfillment or delays in the execution of the decision of domestic vessels appeared.
Then I quote: “... the respondent state must create, within six months from the moment this resolution will become final in accordance with Article 44, §2, the effective domestic means of legal protection or a set of funds that would ensure a rapid and adequate restoration of violated rights, including damage, in case of non-fulfillment or delays in the execution of national court decisions in accordance with the principles of the Convention, in accordance fixed in court decisions ... "
I target, where are you? The Russian state, whose snow on winter you can’t interrogate, honestly pays compensation. But as for the straightened justice, the conversation is special. We are actually paying compensation, taxpayers. And we ourselves, in the conditions of the created vertical, can not be restored in any way. And others are simply not going to do this.
In September, the Moscow City Court Recognized illegal The refusal of the metropolitan authorities in the coordination of the "Day of Anger" on March 20. Prior to this, the same Moscow City Court recognized the extension of the investigation in the criminal case against employees of the Hermitage Capital Foundation, in which lawyer Sergei Magnitsky later died in the investigative isolation. The Taffy Award was awarded to Manana Aslamazyan (which the Russians learned about purely by accident). What is common between all these events and where does the ECHR?
The general lies in the fact that the post -fact of everyone knows everything about laws and legality. The recognition of the illegality of the prohibition of the March event in September can no longer change anything. And you will not revive the recognition of the illegality of the extension of the investigation of the deceased Magnitsky. But formally, the letter is followed. And no Strasbourg will stand. And in fact, the WHO is there now.
As for Manana Aslamazyan, the award award is not only an objective recognition of her merits, but also to the understanding that her work was political, and not a “dispute of business entities”. And the secrets around the fact of her receipt of this award absolutely confirm my immortal thought. The protocol of leaning against decent people is observed, but in fact everything is still.
I am probably naive, but it seems to me that such a precedent should mean a change in the situation in the global plan - they premise the disgraced, which means that the wind changed. But, alas, we still have how long to wait for Mary Poppins. True, we all pretend that she has already returned. And ... we pay for this illusion. With money, deceived hopes, legal nihilism of compatriots from ensign to generals inclusive, I’m not talking about ministers and commander in chief ... In general, cool heads of our homeland are fooling us, Russian citizens, and Europe. On a solid dachshund, for our money. To do, as you think it is necessary, then recognize your own wrongness, slightly shake the moss and ... continue to act in the above key.
Photos of RIA Novosti