To polemic between N. Krivoshein and A. PorobinekWhat did Voltaire mean, claiming that religion has existed since the first hypocrite met the first fool? That religion is a type of ancient power that allows one to manipulate others. And, of course, the author of “Candida” would not be so harsh if those who manipulate would not have been manipulated almost always in favor of the power of those who are in power. It was the game of the church on the side of class privileges and estate differences against the idea of equal civil rights that the philosopher irritation caused irritation.
Assuring that all power from God, the Church without hesitation takes the side of the strong, that is, the state in its confrontation with society and almost never loses, calling for society to humility and humility. In the history of Orthodoxy, there were only a few points when the church tried to play not on the side of obscurantists, but stood up for the weak. However, after Peter I crushed the spine of Orthodoxy on the sovereign threshold, turning it - since then a disabled person to the Ministry of Propaganda, the Church, only after the October Revolution, tried to start in the instinct of self -preservation, but very quickly turned, according to the poet, the Russian Orthodox Orthodox order of Lenin twice. Church. That is, a variety of the department of the ideology of the Central Committee of the CPSU.
And, however, it was the Soviet period for Russian Orthodoxy that was a star hour. The authorities only during the war remembered the Russian Orthodox Church, breaking up in a foul-fooled “brothers and sisters”, but in peacetime she rightly saw in religious utopia only a competitor for the utopia of the communist. This divorce with the authorities was a sip of air for the Russian Orthodox Church, which she, alas, did not use, holding on to the archaic tradition of obedience and, like fire, fearing competitors and reforms.
What is happening today in Russia, and the symptom of which was the process against the curators of “forbidden art”? It is ridiculous to talk about the prime of Orthodoxy, rather - about the Orthodox obscurantist. Even if you do not list the priests who have or have positions in the NKVD-KGB-FSB, do not remember the tobacco-alcoholic business, which is associated with the current patriarch, not to pay attention to the defiantly lordly and non-Christian lifestyle with luxurious clocks on the wrists of the hierarchs, the Russian Orthodox Church still plays on the side of the dark forces. The clericalization of official Orthodoxy, eager for worldly power and has long become a younger partner of the Putin-Medvedev regime in the process of depriving citizens (flock), is frank in the name of increasing the rights of the same power. All these calls for imperial patriotism, all this anti -Western rhetoric, producing intolerance and dissent, promoting confessional and national superiority, attempts to break into school and in the army, that is, to steer in favor of the Church of Putin, Medvedev, Luzhkov, etc. In that version of Orthodoxy, which is being imposed today, first of all, there is very little society. It is Christian tolerance, but there is a lot of great power and Byzantine cunning.
Can contemporary art not respond to this? Only if it is blindly. Black caviar in a silver salary is the same as the Breget watch for 50 thousand dollars on the hand of the highest Orthodox hierarch, without the embarrassment of the taldy about the priority of spiritual values over material. Before us is a distinct criticism of the arrogant and self-confident clericalism, who never raises his voice in defense of the weak, will never say: Mr. President or Mr. Prime Minister, to wet his own citizens in the toilet, only because they want freedom, that they do not agree with how you have divided the good and belonging to society-this is not Christian! It is impossible to destroy the minority, it is disgusted by the commandments to boast of force, it is impossible to maintain xenophobia and corrupt society - your power is not from God, but from the devil! No, we will never hear this, because the Russian Orthodox Church is always on the side of strength and wealth, on the side of traditional darkness, as it represents - to a great extent - a gathering of cowardly conformists who can get arranged in the life of the crafty power lies, and those few exceptions that, of course, have a place to be, only emphasize the rule. And, therefore, there is no criticism that would be redundant in relation to the modern Russian church.
Artists and curators themselves are a special article. I am understanding with those who say that he does not like this art. Contemporary art cannot be liked, this image is not of beauty, but by the schemes of thought. Not beautiful Elena, laughing the blue eyelids and crossing her long legs, poses a modern artist, and the boundaries between art and non-art, permissible and possible, utopian and opposing utopia. No rest, a smile through the teeth in the event of understanding and two or three half an intake chin. This is a banal truth: the level of freedom in society corresponds to the level of understanding of contemporary art. Serious museums of contemporary art appear only if civil society already exists and has power. This, of course, is an educational program, but there is also a cultural sanity, that is, an understanding of what a cultural hierarchy is and who in a diverse and diverse Russian culture today has world recognition.
That is, the fact that Russia can sell only oil, gas and other minerals know everything. But the fact that it was the artists who were exhibited by Erofeev and Samodurov who are the only ones who were recognized as the world community as cultural value that for some reason is not advertised. To say, I don’t see Kabakov or Bulatov there, I don’t like, I don’t like it, I don’t understand-the same as at the beginning of the century before last to say the same about Pushkin, in the middle of the past-about Mandelstam, and at the end of it about Brodsky. You don’t love, you don’t understand - go to the Internet, make a surname on the search bar, find out what a cultural person should know: these guys are a little than, except for oil and gas, the country can be proud of. Because they are the only ones connect us with history, the rest of the world and the future, there are no other bridges yet.
Photo by RIA Novosti