 In society Barrow fate
 I consider it my duty to respond to the article by Julia Latynina , because, unlike her, I was engaged in a business about the arson of the Passage shopping center, not according to information from the Internet, but with the exit to the place. In 2009, I wrote an article about this for the monthly “Top Secret”, she stood in the room, but was shot and has not been in full in the media since then. I would like to add a few considerations to the article. Unlike many witnesses and false witnesses, I do not claim that I know the truth, I have doubts, they are set out in the article, and in two years I did not get rid of them. But Julia Latynina asks questions that I tried to answer. Firstly, this is the topic of witnesses: one of them suddenly remembered the faces who saw only a couple of seconds from a distance of 50 meters and a few months before the testimony, and the second died the day after the testimony. Latynina raises the topic of a note, which contained recommendations to the accused teenagers what to say. As a note was fabricated, the operative who participated in falsification told me with documents in my hands. Latynina reproaches Chekalina for the fact that the company that he created after a scandalous dismissal from the prosecutor’s office was lodging in the premises provided by the Makhmudovs, that is, people who are accused of organizing arson. And what would it be better if they abandoned him and his family, after he lost his job, freely or involuntarily helping them to clear the name? In general, the righteous anger of the journalist always looks awkward if he intervenes in the internal showdowns of security forces. Not quite decent - if the journalist rushes to protect the winners. Nowhere - if the winner turned out to be the boss ...
On July 11, 2005, the Passage shopping center burned down in Ukhta, since then this day has become mourning for many residents of the northern city. 25 people were killed in the fire, 24 of them are women. Their relatives sought a revision of the acquittal, issued in June last year to two young people accused of a conscious arson of the store. The prosecution was also handed close to the mourning anniversary - in June 2009, despite the obvious inconsistencies of the investigation and the numerous falsification of the case that has opened in the first process. The grief of some allowed others to report on the successful completion of the case, and the remaining aloof to solve the issues of increasing the business. At the same time, both the fate of the victims and the fate of the convicts were not taken into account. Fire measures
The arson version was not the only one at first; As the public prosecutor Yuri Ovchinnikov told me, there were about one and a half dozen options. Near the place where the fire rushed, before that, welding work was carried out. In the basement of the shopping center there was a household chemistry warehouse, a fire could occur there without any external intervention, wiring could fly - the cotton that many witnesses heard, and the instant spread of fire across the building, said. In the first messages, they generally talked about the explosion, including domestic gas. Some witnesses claim that they saw a person who ran out of the “passage” who shouted: “There will be an explosion, scatter!” The arson version became the main one when the helplessness of firefighters from the unit, located about five minutes of calm walk, was revealed.
The relatives of the dead and the direct witnesses of the fire Valentina Vasilievna Zhvanikova, Irina Gennadievna Nikiforova, Olga Genrikhovna Melchenko, Svetlana Valentinovna Sukhinskaya and Glafira Dmitrievna Bazhenova tell. As they found out in the city archive, the house was old, 1935, wooden, lined with brick. Nobody issued permission from the fire department to open a retail outlet in it. Firefighters, who arrived quite quickly, were confused, no one wanted to take command, the first thing they rushed to call the authorities on mobile phones. As a result, where they called, the so-called control and observation business, which firefighters must conduct for each structure, disappeared. The ends are in the water? Water whipped from the holes hoses, its pressure was not enough to combat fire. The bosses arrived, at some point there were more people in shape with epaulets than in robes. This continued until the specialized firefighter of the oil refinery drove up.
Huge - for a small town and for white day - the number of dead is explained, in addition to confusion, all conceivable violations of the fire rules made by the owners of the building and tenants. The spare exits were closed, on plastic windows, which not only burned and did not open completely, and iron gratings were also installed. These lattices were helped by the owner of a jeep with a winch from the windows of two floors. The focus of the sunburn was also at the central entrance, next to the main staircase, fire and smoke came from there. The absolute majority of the dead, who failed to break out of the air, died of suffocation, only two were burned.
The frames of this chronicle went around the television screens. The dead were buried, the patients were treated, compensation was given, among the firefighters they found the most guilty and condemned. The version of arson began to grow into the main one, when the witnesses began to talk about two young people who behaved inconsistent with what was happening. In the video of the Stroymarket located opposite the Stroymarket store on July 11, poorly distinguishable figures were visible, which, at the time of universal excitement at the first signs of a fire, did not go to Passage, like the entire stream of citizens, and for an incomprehensible purpose entered the Stroymarket and left the store without buying anything. But the investigation did not help the video. Says the then general director of the Stroymarket network Andrei Shilykovsky:
-The video surveillance system “Inspector-Plus” was new for us, it was installed only two months before the fire, and we did not know its capabilities. On the evening of July 11, I showed records from her cameras to the head of the criminal police of the city Mikhail Krasnov, he ordered to bring a disc with a record in the morning. And in the morning it turned out that the system lay down new notes on yesterday. She removes automatically, responding to movement in the frame. When the number of filming reaches some norms recorded in the program, it turns out, writes new notes on the old ones. On July 11 there was a lot of movement, both in the evening and in the morning of 12, and so she wiped the necessary. Then we tried to remove the records together with experts, nothing happened.
The story with the video disc was the relatives of the victims of another reason to suspect the owners of Stroymarket in the fire. Although the employee of the Republican prosecutor’s office, Ovchinnikov, painted me with the location of the cameras, which it is clear that the video proposal could not be defining. “Passage” was not visible in them.
Ugly boys Since we started talking about the suspicions of the victims, we must tell the story of the accused (and already convicted, however, the sentence has not yet entered into force). And the story of the owner of the Stroymarket, more than once loudly accused of ordering a fire. The investigation of the arrested businessman Fakhrudin Makhmudov has not yet been completed. He and his relatives are suspected of forcing Anton Korostelev (at the time of the fire of eighteen -year -olds) and Alexei Pulilin (at that time almost nineteen -year -old) to make arson, for whom the investigation does not find his own motives.
 As soon as different witnesses of the fire spoke of suspicious teenagers, both youths fell under special attention. And earlier, behind them, since the age of 14, stretched a train of thefts and other small offenses. However, in the summer of 2005, despite Korostelev's dyed blond hair, the teenagers noticed in the fire, which were noticed in a fire, became suspects, were suspects, and then were even detained, but then released. And only after how many months, when Korostelev and Pulalin, once again caught the theft, began to invent mitigating circumstances, so as not to sit down for a very long time, they began to associate them with the “passage” case.
Until September 2005, when they came across again, there were no such absurd robberies behind them. There was a stupid thing in their biography, when they hacked the apartment of his neighbors, in order to wrap the friend’s apartment, they did not take anything from them, but through them they penetrated the intended goal. And this time it turned out like in a cheap detective. They hacked the next mobile store, did not open the cash desk on the spot, they decided to take it with them. They threw her over the fence - and she fell on the hood of a police car ...
They had two more accomplices on these cellular thefts. There are testimonies in the court of one of them, Bakhmatov, that during the investigation, Pulyalin advised them to say that they committed a series of thefts by order of some authorities of Said and Tolstoy, as if for coercion. Two accomplices refused, and Korostelev agreed. The investigation adopted the version of Pulilin, showed him and Korostelev dozens of portraits of various kinds of authorities, they did not recognize any “said”. Moreover, in a relatively small northern town, no one has ever heard of such a formidable and exotic figure for these places.
But in the minds of the investigation, the thought of the involvement of “ugly boys” was born to something more significant than theft and robberies. Moreover, the head of the investigative group was replaced, instead of the investigator (then the prosecutor’s office, and not the Investigative Committee) A. Baranov, who switched to refereeing work, Anatoly Vlasenko took the case under his leadership. Previously, he rose to a decent post “Vazynik”, but left the prosecutor's office to the justice of the peace. The judicial career failed, after a few months he came to ask back to the organs. At first, he was not entrusted with the previous post.
Here is how the former deputy prosecutor of Ukhta Grigory Chekalin, who led the investigation to rob stores: “The prosecutor of the Republic of Kazakhstan, at that time was Viktor Kovalevsky, who called the investigator of the Sosnogorsk city prosecutor, A.A. at that time, describes the further in the statement of the head of the presidential administration of the Russian Federation. And he provided him with a chance to take the place of the investigator in the police department (special affairs-I.G.) of the prosecutor's office of the Republic of Kazakhstan with one condition-at any cost to reveal the arson of the shopping center "Passage" or write a dismissal report. "
By April 2006, the investigation had data on the conflict of Pulilin with one of the young members of the family of entrepreneur Makhmudov, which occurred in the previous spring. At first, however, it was about the theft from the Makhmudovsky warehouse, but later the option with a fight seemed more interesting. Then she began to turn into the main version, according to which Pulyalin and Korostelev, after a conflict with the Makhmudovs, were “put on the counter”, which “tapped” half a million rubles. They didn’t have such money, they allegedly promised to forgive the debt and even pay extra, if they ... set fire to the “passage”.
And nine months after the fire, confessions were born - first Korostelev, then Pulilina.
Queen of evidence From the very beginning with these testimony there was a non -bond, even if they are accepted unconditionally. The boys describe how they were threatened, beaten, taken to the forest of the Mahmudes and his people, forcing them to go to the arson of a competitor. And the investigation team, recording these testimonies, does not start a criminal case that could be instituted under several articles. There is a composition: illegal capture, extortion. If you believe in the pistol poke in the back of the head - also illegal possession and threat of life with a weapon. The investigation team leaves all these testimonies in the main case, but does not write a report on the establishment of a new business.
I asked the head of the Investigative Department of the Investigative Committee under the Prosecutor's Office of the Republic of Komi Nikolai Basmanov whether this is correct. Nikolai Alekseevich replied that, of course, it was wrong that now all these actions are investigated in the framework of a new case against the “customers” of arson, and then the prosecutor’s office did not allocate them. However, the piquancy is that during the investigation in the first case, Nikolai Basmanov was the deputy prosecutor of the republic who oversaw ... supervision of the investigation!
Pulyalin and Korostelev, during interrogations in the spring of 2006, began to declare that together with Said and Tolstoy they were sent to the crime by one of their brothers Makhmudovs, Magomed, and among those who threatened the boys, there was the head of the family, Fakhrudin Makhmudov. Meanwhile, the moment, as Magomed Makhmudov and Pulyalin and Korostelev, Magomeda and Korostelev began to testify, their lawyers managed to appeal to the public and tell at a press conference, together with the deputy of the City Council, which testimonies of the boys are knocked out by the investigation. Immediately after that, the guys were imprisoned and they began to admit.
But after the Makhmudov brothers proved that they could not take Pulilin to the forest and later, already in July, to provide them with combustible materials and pay for the “work”, since those days were in their native Dagestan (they even presented airline tickets with the mark of the special contribution and photos of their vehicles at control points), in October 2006, the case against them was closed. Moreover, Magomed Makhmudov, as the most actively subjected to investigative pressure, managed to receive compensation for non -pecuniary damage in court. True, only 35 thousand.
Pulyalin and Korostelev did not get off so easily. Although in their original case the prosecutor’s office, given the cooperation with the investigation, agreed with the court and three of the four robbers received conditional terms, one Korostelov, who had an outstanding criminal record, got into the colony. But the investigation on Passage begins to interrogate witnesses in the second circle, pushing them to the idea that they saw these teenagers on the day of the fire. Some, a year later, looking at the boys that have changed in IVS, they are still recognized. The persons of the suspects are checked with portraits, who, according to the testimony of witnesses, were made by artists from the local art school. True, then it turned out that portraits made in violation of the rules were also corrected.
On the table by the prosecutor Ovchinnikov, I saw them, quite generalized work. Personally, I could not determine the degree of similarity, a member of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Komi Kotlyakov, who participated in the last process, did not allow me a date with the accused. However, in the summer of 2006, on the initiative of A. Vlasenko (he wanted to authoritatively support the version) they were taken to Moscow for a psycho-physiological examination, as the passage of the “lies detector” is called. They have been tested by competitors, state and independent. Specialists who usually argue with each other on professional issues gave the same assessment: the guys lie, slander, confuse in details.
The defendants all the time gave contradictory testimony, then abandoning the former, then confirming them-after all, the tragic date went further. Several times they announced the pressure of the investigation. It seems that it is necessary to give all these details, albeit without going into eloquent details, so that the mechanism of current Russian justice becomes clear. With whom everyone can encounter. I asked Ovchinnikov how the statements of the investigation were refuted. Yuri Alekseevich replied that the police and investigators said that they did not put pressure on the suspects ...
It is said: falsification! So, by the end of 2006, the investigation was forced to abandon the version of the Order of the Mahmudovs of Passage. What to do? It was decided through the next confessions of Pulilin and Korostelev to find new evidence. So there was a note by Pulilin, written in the address of certain criminal authorities, in which he directly calls the customer. The note (according to investigators) was mysterious in one of the Moscow police department, there it was discovered by a vigilant policeman, he realized, climbing on the Internet, which “passage” was in question, and handed over a note to the officers who arrived from the Komi. The note formed the basis of a new investigation and appeared as evidence in the last year's process.
The former operative officer, in 2005, the police captain says, now Major Mikhail Evseev :
- In December 2006, I was called by the Deputy Head of the Criminal Investigation Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Republic of R.R. Turdyev and asked if I have friends in Moscow, capable of helping in operational development and to make sure that a certain note is discovered in Moscow. I said that there is such a person. Turdyev and I went to Moscow with the note, there my friend "lied" there, and we took it back. I thought it was just part of the operational game and did not expect that the note would appear as evidence in the process.
In a conversation with me, Evseev confirmed the story by traveling documents, from which, in addition to other things, it is clear that he and Turdyev were on a business trip from December 17 to 21, and in the process Colonel Turdyev claimed that he did not remember how he got to the capital, but remembers that he was not there earlier than the 19th. The note was really written by Pulilin on the hint of a criminal planted in his camera, its addressees are fictitious. Its discovery in Moscow was to support a staggering investigation.
This was not the only falsification; others were revealed at the 2008 process. The most loud was voiced by a member of the investigative group, then deputy prosecutor of Ukhta Grigory Chekalin. According to him, which he confirmed and a year later at a personal meeting, immediately after the fire, the witnesses witnessed that he could not remember the teenager who left the “passage” at the time of the sunbathing. And the document in which he describes the suspect was later forged.
Even if you do not take into account the handwriting examination, which the witness testified was subjected to, a clear inconsistency was visible: the hosts, the operative of the police, came across Pulilin and Korostelov during the investigation on the theft, but did not declare then that he saw them during the fire. In addition, I checked it on the spot, from where, in his own words, the hosts stood, it is impossible to see the facial features of the person going from the entrance to the burned store. And the owners also claims that he saw the suspect for a few seconds when he turned around. I saw from a distance of about 50 meters! The prosecutor Ovchinnikov explained to me that the hostel has very good vision ...
In the same place, next to the desert, where the passage was used to be, I also found a place where the witness saw two teenagers immediately before the fire and where the investigator, a couple of days after the tragedy, found lids from bottles, in which there was a combustible mixture. There and now there are full of covers and bottles - this is the extractive point of local booze. Regarding these covers, I asked Ovchinnikov (investigator Vlasenko refused to talk with me) if they found any traces of them. They didn’t find it, although if they were from bottles with unidentified (?) Fuel and if real arsonists immediately unscrewed them before the fire, then at the current level of detective technologies it was possible to find prints - for example, a genetic examination. There were also no traces of burned clothing at the place that the accused indicated, who, according to them, were indicated by all that they went “to business”. The traces remained only in written, and not in the material form.
It turns out that all evidence of the accusations is based on words, in addition to different types of indications, there is nothing financially reliable, even the plastic bottles found at the site of fire somehow very strangely survived in a thousand-degree fire. At the same time, during the investigation in the testimony, they were transformed from one and a half liter to five -liter.
The testimonies of another important witness, the data seems to be immediately after the fire, now you will not be relying. He died immediately after he gave them! On July 14, 2005, according to the papers, in the evening a certain Moldavian migrant worker Donets described the suspects in the police room, in the morning of the 15th he was taken to a psychiatric hospital with an attack of white fever, after a couple of days he died. The whole long history of the relationship of the drunken violator of the migration law with the police suggests that he could write everything that they would require from him. Even after death ...
All these and other violations allowed the court in 2008 under the chairmanship of V.R. In addition to the acquittal, Kuntorovsky also make a private definition of the investigation. It firmly says: "A preliminary investigation in this criminal case was carried out with violations of the criminal procedure law, biased and extremely carelessly." And then - more than a dozen pages of confirmation.
But the private definition, as well as the sentence from June 2008, is now invalid. After the cassation filed by the prosecutor’s office, which was satisfied with the Supreme Court of Russia, as we know, the Supreme Court of the Komi Republic in June this year issued a new sentence, the conviction. On which, by the way, in turn, the cassation was filed by lawyers of convicts.
Whose organs?
In the cassation that the Supreme Court of Russia satisfied, a conflict is prescribed, which could be hidden from those present in the First Court. Almost a prosecution admitted that she prevented her from working the way she wanted, a parallel investigation, which during the trial through its channels conducted the FSB department in the Komi Republic. Its employees double -checked witnesses and found inconsistencies, they also ensured the safety of the main exposure - the current deputy prosecutor of Ukhta Grigory Chekalin (in the photo) To whom the FSB officials were proposed, according to him, to speak in court with the testimony of falsifications. At their request, he wrote a note about these violations and presented evidence, including audio recordings.
As the retirees of the FSB explained in an unofficial conversation, their colleagues did not make anything illegal. And I did not wait for an official response from the FSB, although I wrote a statement with a request to explain to me and the newspaper, as the conflict of the FSB and the prosecutor's office should understand. But Yuri Ovchinnikov, representing the prosecutor's office on both processes, explained what the difference was the difference from the first and the first: no one interfered, all law enforcement agencies worked in the same team.
And the court accepted the evidence that his predecessor rejected, including the story with the production of “on the counter” of Pulilin and Korostelev. But it was this story that was previously rejected by the investigation, as a result of which the other court decided to pay moral compensation to one of the Makhmudovs! When repeated consideration of the case, the Komi Supreme Court considered the statement of Chekalin with a lie. Now, if the sentence enters into legal force, Grigory Chekalin will become the accused, as the head of the investigative department Nikolai Basmanov told me.
According to Nikolai Basmanov, the arson of Passage was caused by competition. But why then do this with a set of witnesses, in the midst of the day? Nobody would have prevented at night and no one would have seen anything. The victims believe that Mahmudov simply wanted to intimidate the city, he had little economic power, he wanted to, with the help of fear, to capture political. But then why did one of his associates tear off the bars from the windows with the help of his jeep and saved dozens of people?
No, logical motives are not visible in the version that was recognized in Ukhta, because the Mahmudes did not stand, crossing his hands, next to the burning building and did not say: “Look, I did it, now I'm the most important!”. On the contrary, he presented Alibi, trying to prove his non -involvement. But, despite this, the day after the conviction, Pulilin and Korostelev Fakhrudin and Asret Makhmudovs were arrested. I do not take on the role of a judge, I just think with readers. Maybe now convicts are really to blame. Only the investigation and the court did not convince me.
But there is a clear motive for another version, which was developing the first detained suspects - employees of the Sotovik salon in the Passage shopping center. Three hours before the fire, they came to the head office of Sotovik in Syktyvkar with a check, suspected that they were traded in counterfeit. The owner said that the documents are in the Ukhta store. One of the managers of this store, a certain S., according to his testimony, is not quite a sane person, in addition, a pyromanus with experience, repeatedly set fire to relatives. Of course, in this situation, it was not necessary to call him: “Fuck the store!”, It was enough to hint: “Notice the traces!”. And it was precisely the managers of the Sotovik from the very beginning that they suspected and detained.
By the way, Andrei Shilykovsky, who watched a video surveillance recording in the “building materials”, told me that the figure on her, her plastic and gait, remembered him later. When he saw on the street of this very S. now convicted for mockery of animals.
Relatives of the dead are inclined to explain the confrontation between the two departments of Makhmudov’s money, who, if the sentence enters into force, will be called by the court the customer of arson. The local “oligarch”, which controls most of the construction industry of the republic, really has good connections. But his opponents have a connection. It was Fakhrudin Makhmudov, speaking on television before the verdict, who told how they were trying to blackmail him with involvement in the fire, demanding to give a share of the business. This was also written in the statements of Grigory Chekalin, aimed at the highest instances.
In particular, he explains the activity of the FSB in the first process by the fact that the head of the Komi Republic V.A. Torlopov was then interested in the defeat of the prosecutor's office, since he was not satisfied with the activity of the new prosecutor of the Republic A.I. Shuklin. By the way, Shuklin did not sign the indictment in the case of the “passage”, it was signed by his deputy, in violation of the usual movement of papers, a day after admission to the republic’s prosecutor's office. In the day we studied dozens of volumes! But still, Shuklin turned out to be extreme and was dismissed.
And before the second process, according to Chekalin, Torlopov was firmly interested in issuing a conviction in the case under the control of the President of Russia and the Prosecutor General’s Office, and therefore the FSB went to the side. In December 2009, by the way, the term of powers of the head of the republic expires, in which this year there was another fire with a lot of victims. So the elite of the republic was vital to find the perpetrators. Well, besides, to squeeze the Mahmudovs.
By the way, the businessman and State Duma deputy R. Goldstein, who, according to Chekalin, addressed Makhmudov with a proposal to share the business, proudly declared the media about his satisfaction with the conviction. Like Torlopov, he made it clear that he took part in this outcome of the case ...
Moscow-Syktyvkar-Ukhta
Original text Joseph Galperin All rights to materials located on the EJ.ru website are protected in accordance with the legislation of the Russian Federation, including copyright and related rights. With any use of the site and satellite projects, hyperlink (Hyperlink) on EJ.ru is required. |