
60-year-old Archbishop Hilarion (Corporal) was elected head of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia (ROCOR, now part of the Moscow Patriarchate). There was no sensation - it was this bishop, who was the first deputy of his predecessor, who was called the most likely successor to the late Bishop Laurus. The entire election procedure took only a few minutes.
The new “foreign” metropolitan is the sixth first hierarch of the ROCOR. Each of his predecessors was a significant figure in the history of Russian Orthodoxy, having a significant influence on the paths followed by his church. The first of them is Metropolitan Anthony (Khrapovitsky), the founder of the ROCOR, a bright, charismatic personality, an educated theologian, whose works still cause controversy in the Orthodox community, and a conservative politician who almost became a patriarch in the turbulent year 17. Most members of the Council then supported his candidacy, but during the drawing of lots the schema monk took out a note with the name of the humble Bishop Tikhon, now canonized. Metropolitan Anthony was not distinguished by anything but humility - sharp, conflicting, difficult to compromise, he really wanted power, wanting to change the Russian Church, increase its authority, protect independence in relations with the state. The extreme right-wing views of Metropolitan Anthony, combined with his vigorous activity, doomed him to death in Bolshevik Russia - so he emigrated, but in emigration he did not retire, but created an extremely conservative, anti-communist, militant church. It matches its parishioners of that time, who replaced the tunics of white regiment officers with the jackets of Parisian taxi drivers and the overalls of workers in factories and mines in many European countries.
Bishop Anthony’s successor, Metropolitan Anastasy (Gribanovsky), was far from such a bright figure, but, being a pre-Soviet bishop, he symbolized the successive nature of the ROCOR (as political scientists say, “increased legitimacy”). Over the three decades of his leadership of the church, there were many upheavals - the war (during which the “foreigners” actively supported the Vlasov movement and units of White emigrants who fought on the side of the Germans), and the forced move from Europe to the USA, and the creation of the spiritual center of the church there in Jordanville. As well as the natural decline of the former flock and the acquisition of a new one, from among the second wave of emigration, a significant part of the Vlasov one. At the same time, Bishop Anastassy, despite all the conflicts, maintained a respectable appearance - thus, responsibility for too close rapprochement with the Nazis was assigned to the Berlin Metropolitan Seraphim (Lyade), who turned out to be a quite convenient figure for this. Not only was he German by nationality, but before leaving the USSR he belonged to the renovation movement in the church, which was used by the security officers in their own interests.
The third first hierarch, Metropolitan Filaret (Voznesensky), was a man of a completely different generation. He left Russia as a youth, and as an adult he was persecuted in Maoist China. A kind, pious man, but with little experience in administrative affairs, he transferred the real management of the church into the hands of the influential Protopresbyter George (Grabe), who later became Bishop Gregory. Under Bishop Philaret, the ROCOR became not just a conservative, but an ultra-conservative church, anathematizing ecumenism and doing everything possible to isolate the church from world Orthodoxy. This position made him an idol of those who consider ecumenism a kind of Satanism (many of them venerate the metropolitan as a saint), but led to the fact that the church faced the danger of marginalization, intensified due to a gradual new reduction in the number of the flock - old emigrants were dying, and “ The third wave of emigration was very little interested in such a church.
The fourth first hierarch, Metropolitan Vitaly (Ustinov), who headed the ROCOR in 1986, tried to solve the problems. He deprived Bishop Gregory of power and began to govern the church on his own, wavering between conservatism and ultra-conservatism. The ecumenists continued to be resolutely condemned, but they tried not to remember the conciliar anathema. The bishop, who left his homeland as a child, made his main bet on the creation in the post-Soviet space of an organizational structure alternative to the Moscow Patriarchate - not only parishes, but also entire dioceses. However, this plan failed: the resources of the “foreigners” were incomparable with the capabilities of the Russian Orthodox Church, and the clergy of the Russian Orthodox Church Abroad were often replenished by far from the best representatives of the patriarchy, either who came into conflict with their own clergy (where it is usually difficult to find right and wrong), or who were counting on a quick career when changing the “red” church to the “white” one.
The crisis of the ROCOR, coupled with the venerable age of the first hierarch, led to the fact that his colleagues persistently asked Bishop Vitaly to retire with honor. He agreed and left, but then withdrew his statement, but no one listened to him, except for a small group of supporters who formed an alternative jurisdiction, which has now undergone several splits. The fifth First Hierarch was Metropolitan Laurus (Shkurla), the first head of the ROCOR, who was born outside of Russia and received higher education in the USA. A Carpathian by origin, he was distinguished by moderate views and saw his main goal as rapprochement with the Russian Orthodox Church, even to the point of joining it on the most honorable terms possible. The elderly ruler was clearly flattered by the close attention and emphasized respectful attitude towards him during his visits to Russia, which was unfamiliar to him, including from Vladimir Putin. The head of a small church, little known in the West and losing opportunities for development, he unexpectedly found himself in front of television cameras together with the leader of a state that is part of the G8. Bishop Laurus completed his task, despite resistance from the opposition, who did not want to go to the “red” church. Less than a year after the completion of the unification process, he died.
The election of Bishop Hilarion as the sixth First Hierarch of the ROCOR, despite all the predetermination of this event, became a landmark phenomenon in the history of the “foreign” church. Firstly, Metropolitan Laurus’s closest ally will clearly continue his work. A descendant of Ukrainian emigrants who came to Canada from Poland before World War II, he never harbored any particular hostility toward the Moscow Patriarchate. He was one of the active supporters of reunification with the Russian Orthodox Church, although his non-conflict nature did not allow him to join the initiators of this process. Unlike Archbishop Mark (Arndt), the administrator of the ROCOR diocese in Europe (only 2 out of 11 bishops voted for him; the rest supported the elected first hierarch), Bishop Hilarion did not get drawn into the polemics between supporters and opponents of annexation, which often took dramatic forms. As a result, his candidacy turned out to be acceptable to the Secretary of the Synod, Bishop Gabriel (Chemodakov), who was skeptical about integration from the very beginning, and to other recent critics of the Patriarchate who remained among the clergy and flock of the “foreigners.”
Secondly, it will be easier for Bishop Hilarion, who is calm and ready for informed decisions, to deal with issues related to the fate of specific priests who once transferred from the Russian Orthodox Church to the Russian Orthodox Church Abroad. There remain several parishes on the territory of Russia that continue to submit to the “foreign” Synod - under the terms of the integration agreement, they were given a “transitional” five-year period. In addition, a number of issues still need to be resolved, for example, about the prospects for uniting the “patriarchal” and “foreign” spiritual missions in Jerusalem, about the relationship between dioceses located on the same territory (in Europe and the USA, for example), but historically included in the Russian Orthodox Church, respectively and ROCOR. And also about the possibility of returning to the ROCOR some of the clergy who left it after unification with the ROC on a wave of emotions, and now feel nostalgia for the familiar church.
Thirdly, Archbishop Hilarion personifies the continuation of the “foreign” tradition of conservatism, but without the extremes characteristic of ultra-conservatives. He received not only spiritual, but also secular education, and has a master's degree in Slavic studies and Russian literature from Syracuse University. At the same time, the bishop is a very churchly person, who attended church from early childhood, and after graduating from the seminary, he took monastic vows at the Holy Trinity Monastery in Jordanville. In his youth, his confessor was Bishop Savva (Sarachevich), a native of Serbia, a close friend of the famous “foreign” Bishop John (Maksimovich), whom the ROCOR canonized. At the upcoming Council of Bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church in June, there will be a church-wide glorification of this ascetic, who during his lifetime suffered a lot from overzealous zealots of orthodoxy.
Fourthly, the election of Bishop Hilarion is a kind of response to critics of the unification with the Russian Orthodox Church, who argued that the Patriarchate, having received the right to approve the first hierarch, would seek to establish direct control over “foreign” dioceses by promoting its own person to this post. Now this point of view has been refuted: the ROCOR remains a “foreign” church, which has the right to make independent decisions. Moreover, Moscow is quite happy with the elected candidate. Yesterday, Patriarch Alexy II and the Holy Synod approved the election of Archbishop Hilarion of Sydney as First Hierarch of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia.
The author is vice-president of the Center for Political Technologies