The election of the head of the Orthodox Church in America, the youngest by consecration, Bishop Jonah, who became a bishop just a few days before the council, I think, seemed to the participants of the council the best way out of the crisis situation in which the church found itself. It is clear that when two metropolitans in a row are accused of financial abuse, the church needs a person who cannot be suspected of such fraud. Accordingly, all hierarchs, to one degree or another close to the previous leadership, were under great doubt. In addition, there is a clear personnel shortage in the American church: many prominent figures of the OCA were previously clergy of other faiths - Roman Catholics, Protestants, Uniates. The appearance at the head of the church of a person who was already a clergyman of another denomination could work against the image of this church. Bishop Jonah was never a clergyman of another denomination; he, however, was a Protestant in his youth, but converted to Orthodoxy during his student years. That is, here the image factor was much better.
In fact, there were two solutions: first, to invite a person from outside. In this case, the candidacy of Bishop Hilarion, a young and highly educated hierarch of the Russian Orthodox Church, who graduated from Oxford, is known as a theologian and church composer and enjoys a good reputation not only in the Russian Orthodox Church, but also in other local churches, was considered. There were precedents for such an election: after World War II, the hierarchs of the Russian Orthodox Church became the heads of the Polish and Czechoslovak churches. But precisely these precedents, showing that from a canonical point of view this is possible, were politically very contradictory and rather had a negative character. It is clear that the thought immediately arises about the mechanisms of subordination and dependence. There would have been the same suspicions here, so Vladyka Hilarion refused.
The second option is to elect a new person, as happened in 1964 in the ROCOR, when there were very serious internal contradictions, they could not elect a first hierarch and elected the youngest bishop by consecration, Philaret. So there are precedents here too.
Jonah is a person who, as I already said, is not connected with the old system of church leadership, an educated person, a person in no way oriented towards a church career - he became an archimandrite this year, and a person who has good relations with the Russian Orthodox Church - at one time even worked in the patriarchal system. As far as one can judge, he is a man of rather conservative views - it is significant that the monastery he founded is named after St. John of Shanghai and San Francisco, this is a saint of the ROCOR, in general, probably just such a first hierarch, quite young, with a good reputation, moderate conservative and never striving for money, is in this case the optimal figure.