
A few days ago, at a closed government meeting, a bill was approved that provided for a radical change in the relationship of the Russian Academy of Sciences (RAN) with the state. According to the draft (formulated as amendments to the current law “On Science”), the Academy is deprived of all autonomy. Its president will be “approved” (that is, actually appointed) by the head of state, and its charter - by the government. More importantly, the Academy is losing its financial independence, remaining only the manager of budget funds allocated and distributed by the state. Although the bill has not yet even been submitted to the Duma, the changes it introduces are spoken of as a fait accompli.
Commenting on this news, RAS Vice-President Gennady Mesyats said that the sudden change in status came as a shock to the Academy: “Nobody warned us, it happened suddenly, many still cannot come to their senses.” Probably, Gennady Andreevich only meant that the Presidium of the Russian Academy of Sciences, having achieved the removal of this issue from the agenda of the government meeting on May 26, did not expect that the next attack of the adversaries would be so quick and decisive, and therefore completely missed the blow. In general, the current battle over the reform of the Russian Academy of Sciences has been going on for about two years, and talk about the fact that something needs to be done with this structure has been going on for the entire 15 years of its existence.
The point is not even that the coordination of fundamental scientific research on behalf of the state is carried out by a structure that is considered a self-governing public organization de jure and is de facto not accountable to anyone but itself. The trouble is that the RAS performs these duties extremely poorly. When they say that “officials are trying to take control of science away from scientists,” this is nothing more than cheap demagoguery: it is clear that in reality the system of institutes is controlled not by venerable academicians and corresponding members (who gather once a year for the general meeting of the Academy), but by the apparatus of the Russian Academy of Sciences. That is, the same officials, and not the best variety: for the most part, these are people who for some reason did not have a successful scientific career, and they went along the administrative line, self-taught, learning the wisdom of management.
The results are logical: even against the bleak background of Russian federal bodies, the RAS apparatus stands out for its stupidity, inefficiency and lack of professionalism. The share of administrative costs in the overall structure of expenses of RAS institutions reaches almost 10% - four times higher than even the usual Russian norms. A special analytical note prepared by the Ministry of Education and Science based on inspections by the Accounts Chamber and other control bodies states that the inefficiency of academic management “eats up” up to 80% of the income that could flow into the state budget from the Russian Academy of Sciences. The compilers of the note call the Russian Academy of Sciences “a politicized distribution corporation isolated from the problems of society that cares not about research, but about a comfortable existence.”
Of course, the Ministry of Education and Science cannot be called an impartial party: it is it (more precisely, the Federal Agency for Science and Innovation that is part of it) that acts as the standard bearer of the campaign against academic autonomy and the main beneficiary if it is successful. But it is no secret that the main task of the RAS apparatus and the “scientific policy” pursued by it has long been to maintain control over the property of the Academy and the financial flows entering its institutions. We are talking not only about budget money, but also about grants (primarily foreign) allocated to specific scientists and research groups. Moreover, one gets the impression that the subject of the struggle is not the total amount of funds raised or even the share of them withdrawn by the Academy’s structures, but rather control over their distribution. Suffice it to recall how, in a number of conflict cases, RAS officials preferred to lose the grant altogether rather than give it to someone to whom they could actually allocate it. Or how in the first half of the 90s the Presidium of the Russian Academy of Sciences stubbornly and successfully resisted the transformation of academic institutes into federal research centers - which would have meant a “separate line in the budget,” i.e., more generous and timely funding, but bypassing the Academy. As for property management, its quality depends mainly on the management of institutions. The RAS apparatus here looks clearly superfluous: the documents it issues openly interfere with successful business executives, do not help the weak in any way, and are completely powerless against dishonest people.
While the state was unable to fulfill its own obligations (and did not expect anything real from fundamental science), it could only endure all this according to the principle “they pretend that they work, and we pretend that we pay them.” But the excess of finance immediately gave rise to corresponding ambitions - to return Russia to the status of a great scientific power. And the very first glance at the existing system of management of fundamental science in the country showed: without its radical reform, no financial injections will yield the slightest result.
In principle, the “society with unlimited irresponsibility” into which the Russian Academy of Sciences has become can be reformed in two ways. The first is to take away state powers in the field of science from the Academy, removing research institutions from its jurisdiction, but maintaining its independence and self-government. Thus, the RAS would turn into a professional organization of the scientific elite - similar to the British Royal Society or the US National Academy. The reputation of the Russian Academy brand in the world is still very high (perhaps even higher than it really deserves), and there is no need to worry about its future.
Another way is exactly the opposite: to bring the formal status of the Academy in line with the functions it actually performs, to turn its apparatus into a regular department (the academicians themselves in this option would become something like a public council under the ministry - extremely broad and authoritative, but without any authority) and put under standard hardware control.
The state, as usual, tried to bypass the pillar on the right and left at the same time. The RAS reform plan, developed within the Ministry of Education and Science, back in June included elements of both paths: on the one hand, the withdrawal of institutions, and on the other, an appointed president. (The Presidium of the Russian Academy of Sciences, which promised to reform the Academy at the first signs of impending vivisection, for two years came up with nothing but a 20% reduction in staff, in the best Soviet traditions, stupidly and evenly distributed not only across all institutes, but also across all laboratories and services of each of them.) However, as far as is known, the current bill retains the powers of a government department for the Academy, only tightening government control over it. In other words, the eclecticism of the proposed reform was noticed and realized - and the choice was made in favor of nationalization. And this is not the choice of the Ministry of Education and Science. It would be precisely the separation of the Academy from the state that would meet his selfish interests—guess who would get the alienated resources and powers in this case!
But tactically the moment for the attack was chosen extremely well. Elections for the President of the Russian Academy of Sciences are scheduled for December 18, and the age limit for Yuri Osipov, who currently holds this post, prohibits him from running for a new term. If the amendments come into force before this date, the elections will be canceled, and the powers of the current president and presidium will be extended for a transition period. This allows the authors of the reform (whose onslaught the Academy has already repulsed twice) to hope that this time the resistance from the top of the RAS will not be so fierce.
On the other hand, there is something symbolic in the fact that the next “reform” begins with a complete stop to even routine and formal changes.