
An additional impetus to the discussion on the possible liberalization of the Russian economy was given by Igor Shuvalov's speech at a forum in St. Petersburg about a possible reduction in the level of state intervention in the economy. The forum itself, however, did not become a real platform for discussions. The grade level was basically a matter of choosing between good and best. Economists who were ready to seriously challenge the established system of views were not seen on the podium. So it turned out that Shuvalov's speech became the sharpest, most critical and resonant. Nevertheless, it was at the forum that some of the problems of the Russian economy emerged quite clearly.
"Invisible" economy
The head of the Ministry of Economic Development, Elvira Nabiullina, said that the volume of Russian GDP this year reached $2 trillion, and this puts the domestic economy in 7th place in the world.
And taking into account the fact that at present the growth rates are very high (8.1% - at the end of last year, 8.4% - for 5 months of this year), the minister predicted that by 2020 our country will confidently enter the top five world leaders . At the same time, the Russian economy will grow at an annual rate of 5.5–6% over the next 12 years.
Jim O'Neill, director of economic research at Goldman Sachs, however, had a slightly different outlook. He estimated the current volume of Russian GDP at $1.5 trillion. And he took our country 8th place in the world ranking. He predicted that in 2010-2015 the growth of the Russian economy will drop to 3.3% per year, and by 2020 - to 2.9%. O'Neill explained this slowdown by the fact that GDP growth requires more employed people, and Russia just has to go through the demographic hole. At the same time, in 12 years our GDP will amount to $3 trillion and the country will rise to the 6th place in the world ranking. Michael Klein, Chairman of the Board of Citigroup, also added color to the overall picture, calling the Russian economy “invisible”, since 85% of its exports are non-consumer goods.
Such assessments clearly upset Elvira Nabiullina. She explained the difference in today's GDP volumes by the fact that the Ministry of Economic Development (MED), unlike Western analysts, keeps score at purchasing power parity, which gives us a better figure. But with the growth rate predicted by O'Neill, she could not come to terms with it. “You predict for us the inertial path of development, from which we are going to leave,” she said. In turn, the chairman of the board of directors of MDM Bank Oleg Vyugin, the figure of the upcoming growth of 3.3% does not scare at all. He urged to think not about the quantity, but about the quality of growth. According to his calculations, to ensure even such a pace, the Russian economy will have to raise labor productivity by 70% - a noble task, but extremely difficult to achieve.
All money visit us

To turn off the inertial path of development, Russia will need serious investments. In this regard, the results of Ernst & Young's 2008 study of the investment climate in various countries in 2008 published at the forum are interesting. According to a survey of 834 top managers of the largest international companies, China turned out to be the most interesting country for investments. China was named an attractive region for investment by 47% of respondents. India voted for 30% of those polled. Russia is in third place with 21%, the United States and Canada earned the same amount. The countries of Western Europe got only 33% of all. Moreover, the study participants are quite optimistic about the investment prospects of our country: 61% of respondents are confident that Russia will become “more stable” in the coming years, and only 8% do not support this point of view.
Today, however, this optimism is shattered by financial reality. Finance Minister Alexei Kudrin did not fail to remind the audience that in the first quarter of 2008 $20 billion had flown out of the country, and now this figure has become even more impressive. Well, the net outflow of capital 1 From the beginning of the year, according to the Central Bank, it has already been estimated at $ 5 billion. At the same time, Kudrin, however, did not forget to praise the cautious policy of his department, which in recent years has been aimed at creating powerful reserves. Their total amount to date in Russia has exceeded $500 billion, which, according to Kudrin, made it possible to actually "not notice" a powerful outflow of funds from the country. For their part, the Ernst & Young survey participants quite clearly identified four main obstacles that deter foreign investors: corruption, lack of transparency in the legislative framework, administrative barriers and the lack of an independent judiciary. Perhaps, in order to mitigate the severity of these problems, presidential aide Arkady Dvorkovich said that, from his point of view, our country has proved that investments in its economy can be effective. According to him, Russia protects foreign investments even more than domestic ones. All that is required of Western companies entering our market, says Dvorkovich, is the transparency of plans regarding how exactly they are going to invest.
In response to this, one of the foreign participants in the discussion at the forum unfolded the latest issue of the Financial Times, on the page of which a cartoon was depicted dedicated to the well-known conflict in TNK-BP. According to the banker, one such cartoon in the world's leading press organ, which all investors must read, can outweigh all the positive speeches that come from officials.
___________
1 The difference between the total volume of capital outflows abroad and capital inflows into the country from abroad.