
Bill Clinton, Boris Yeltsin and Leonid Kuchma after the signing of the Budapest Memorandum in December 1994
The party of Vladimir Zelensky "servant of the people" announced the need to conclude an agreement on guarantees of security of Ukraine . This proposal is clearly dedicated to the meeting of foreign ministers of Ukraine and Russia planned at March 10 at the diplomatic forum in Antalya.
If the North Atlantic Alliance is not ready to accept Ukraine into its ranks, we need a “specific agreement” that will “fundamentally differ from the Budapest memorandum and provide for specific political, economic and military steps of the guarantors of the security of Ukraine.” "Such warrants can become the United States, Türkiye, the states of the Ukrainian neighbors. For their part, Russia must also legally record that it recognizes Ukrainian statehood and guarantees that it will not threaten our state." In the statement of the "servants of the people" it is emphasized: "Our Ukraine is Donetsk, Lugansk, and Crimea."
Directly about the neutral (non -block) status of Ukraine is not said in the statement. But it is implied in the case of concluding an agreement on security guarantees. On the same day, in an interview with the American television channel, ABC Zelensky said: "Relatively NATO - I cooled on this issue for a long time, after we realized that NATO is not ready to accept Ukraine. The alliance is afraid of conflicting steps and confrontation with Russia."
Regarding Moscow, to recognize the “independence” of the DPR and LPR and the Russian affiliation of Crimea Zelensky said: “We could negotiate and find a compromise on how these“ republics ”will continue to live. But what is important for me, these are people in these territories, whether they want to be part of Ukraine and who will say in Ukraine that he wants these territories to be with us.” It is characteristic that Crimea fell out of the answer.
Zelensky considers it necessary that "the Russian dictator Putin began to speak, begin the dialogue to leave the information vacuum, without oxygen in which he is located." “He receives information, and we do not know how realistic it is, this information. It seems that he is simply closing his eyes,” Zelensky says about Putin. If the Ukrainian president really believes that, having met with Putin, he will be able to open his eyes to what is happening, then this is a dangerous illusion. Putin really lives in the parallel reality created by himself and his environment, but is not going to leave it. Moscow uses such statements by Zelensky only for a propaganda stalk .
As for the possible agreement on security guarantees for Ukraine, it is completely incomprehensible how it will be fundamentally different from the sad memory of the 1994 Budapest memorandum, which for Putin turned out to be just a ply of paper. After all, the guarantees of Ukraine, among others, will be given by Putin's Russia and Lukashenkovskaya Belarus (and Lukashenko’s signature is no more expensive than Putin’s signature). The position of Ukraine is fundamentally different from the position of neutral Switzerland, the independence and territorial integrity of which is not threatened by any of the neighboring states. Ukraine will have a powerful enemy in the person of Putin's Russia, who wants to destroy it. To prevent a new Russian attack on Ukraine, the contract must contain specific military obligations of the countries signing it, which will be put into effect in case of aggression against Ukraine. But, firstly, Russia will never sign such an agreement, and secondly, such obligations will be equivalent to the Military Union with Ukraine, which means that it will be difficult to consider a neutral country.
Not to mention the fact that in order to conclude an agreement on guarantees of the security of Ukraine, one must first achieve the withdrawal of Russian troops at least to the positions that they occupied on February 23, 2022. But Putin is not going to do this.
It is very clear the desire of the President of Zelensky and the Government of Ukraine to stop the war or to achieve at least a temporary truce in order to withdraw people from besieged cities where they are bombarded and shelling. In order for Putin to stop the offensive, and the ideas of the agreement on non -block status are advanced. But the aggressor no worse than Ukrainian politicians understands that the further survival of Ukraine, if it manages to reflect the current invasion, will entirely depend on the receipt of modern weapons from NATO countries. So, the de facto neutral status of Ukraine will still not be. Therefore, Putin is not going to negotiate with Zelensky. He uses conversations about neutral status exclusively for propaganda purposes - to undermine the fighting spirit of the defenders of Ukraine, who fought largely by NATO weapons and with the support of a number of NATO countries, including the United States, Britain and Poland. The loss of the prospects for membership in NATO will most negatively affect the moral state of the population and the army of Ukraine.
Putin will agree to recognize the independence of Ukraine only if he suffers a military defeat here. You can agree with the Ukrainian internationalist Oleg Belokolos : a meeting in Antalya makes sense only to "show all the inadequacy of the Russian Federation and its leadership." There is practically no chance that she will bring the end of the war.