
Vladimir Vladimirovich ( doctor addresses the Prime Minister of Russia - L. R. ), dear friends!
The Ministry of Health finally went to a direct conversation with us, we had been waiting for this for a long time. This, of course, is not yet a congress of doctors of Russia, but this is a dialogue, and this is not necessary to be afraid, because our people are normal and speaks correctly.
All the good about our achievements was told by both Vladimir Vladimirovich and Tatyana Alekseevna. Indeed, so much opens, so much is introduced, so much is built. Only a blind or embittered person does not see this. I can say about the good thing as for me personally: the Institute of Pediatric Traumatology has been built over the years - the only one of a kind not only in Moscow, but also in the world. You can replicate this experience - such children's hospitals need to be built in Russia.
But my task today is not to praise what we have done, but to designate pain points.
In relation to childhood. It is necessary to strengthen real children's programs. It would be nice for us to think about free medicinal support for children under 12 years of age, which is being done all over the world. And Alexander Baranov ( director of the Scientific Center for the Health of Children of the RAMS . - L. R. ) repeatedly raised the question of the construction of rehabilitation centers, this is all the more important that we will engage in small children.
But first a little story. You, Vladimir Vladimirovich, being the president, took on our side, and not to the side of Zurabov, who said that there was no need for health care. It was with me. And you can confirm this, it was so. And there was the first swallow - the national project "Health". The money was allocated, the fact that it was partially buried in the ground is not your problem, but those who are under you. But the primary link was saved, which fell apart due to a meager salary. At the same time, the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Health forgot that narrow specialists, doctors of school-school institutions, heads of departments that the salary were not increased, and big problems arose in clinics. We all clearly understood that this project could not solve all many years of healthcare sores. But equipment, cars were purchased, it was all, and by 2007 we began to speak loudly both the presidential administration and the government about the need to raise a share of healthcare in the internal gross product from shameful 3.5% to 6. Moreover, we are not talking about 8-10-15%, as in other countries, and we are not talking about bringing costs in dollars to rubles, but only about interest.
But the crisis struck. I am convinced that if it were not for him, then no one would have caught up with our best healthcare structure in the world if we had at least 6% of GDP and would rationally use them. In difficult conditions, you tried to preserve the social sphere. She, of course, suffered, but did not return to the level of the 90s, this is good.
Now they have found the opportunity to give healthcare an additional 460 billion. This is a lot, it is necessary that they do not cut and spend correctly. The expenditure of these funds should be put not only under the control of the prosecutor's office, but also of medical public organizations.
I can tell you how they can saw. There is a program for reducing road traffic injuries. There I found a line: “Development of a first -aid kit for drivers” - and saw a figure of several million rubles. I did not believe my eyes, how could this turn out? As a result, they threw out medicines from the first -aid kit, as if we were living in Europe with walking availability of medical care, and added several bandages. Did these funds pay the developers, I don’t know, but someone put this figure? Who put it?
The allocated additional funds will increase the share of healthcare in GDP, I counted, up to 4.4% of GDP, but this is not 6-7%. In general, healthcare is half -financed in about twice as approximately. And against this background, maybe I’m mistaken, or maybe not, there is a clear position of the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Economic Development to throw a rope around us and limit budget financing.
Vladimir Vladimirovich, because then not only we will suffocate.
We introduced the concept of profitability in our healthcare - a terrible business! Close hospitals and clinics without building a assistance system for the remaining.
I moved out of the road, stopped at the village, there is a woman of about fifty. "How with medicine?" I ask. I convey the essence without all the Russian words that I heard from her: FAP ( feldsher-midwife point. - L. R. ) closed, 30 km to get to the nearest one. One doctor. You can’t get through to the ambulance. The bus has become expensive, rarely walks.
Who needs such reform? We think about money. A ruble stood ahead, and about the people with this approach to profitability began to forget.
And about doctors too. It’s good that the question is now turning. Maybe the train has already left? From whom should I ask for this?
We would be faster to report upstairs that so many beds were reduced, so many hospitals were closed. Previously, the crossing red banner was given for such agility. And now what is they given? It is easy to break the system, and restore for a long time and expensive.
We talked about difficulties with personnel. But this is an invented administrative division in the area, when there is a city health department, there is a district - on one patch - this is a double increase in the staff of managers. I think the system that was before was no less effective.
Another fashion is this: let's reduce beds in hospitals. Yes, in hospitals, treatment is more expensive. In clinics, it is cheaper. But in order to follow this fashion, everything must be done so that clinics can take patients, provide medicines and consumables, as in a hospital.
Now they started talking about personnel. It turns out that 30% of the frames in the village are missing. And we will add that in the cities too.
Five years ago, the healthcare commission of the Public Chamber loudly said about this. But why listen to her?
There are not enough resuscitators, anesthesiologists, dermatologists, neurosurgeons, radiologists for working on heavy equipment, pathologists, and a failure with narrow specialists. There are regions where more than 50% of the retiremental doctors and only 7% of young specialists.
I would like, Vladimir Vladimirovich, so that the real state program for leaving this personnel state is prepared.
In municipal hospitals, a doctor’s salary is within 8000 rubles. Unlike civil servants who, at the very least, we cannot live on a salary, we cannot and must modify ten to twelve on duty up to 15-20 thousand, so as not to die of hunger. Where to improve your qualifications there.
You have now talked about interns and residents. I don’t know when there will be an improvement, but today I am ashamed to look into my residents in the eye. They earn two thousand with a tail.
Who did it? The same people wrote.
Another question: in an orderly order they began to introduce a new remuneration system. They said that it would be better: payment is higher, the quality of service of the population will improve, etc. Deputy Minister Oleg Safonov came to me and talked about the new payment system for three hours. And in our old differentiated system with 18 discharges, a stimulating system was built. Why are you breaking? Who invented all this. Can I ask?
Today, for those who work in the compulsory medical insurance system, increase tariffs 2-3 times and completely cover the expenses of the medical institution.
Why for a child who lies in intensive care with a heavy combined injury, we get money in only one month of treatment in the amount of 110 thousand rubles? Let me send to the apartment to the one who wrote it, this child is on the breathing apparatus, with a head injury, but which can still be fighting. He can lie 50 days. Not because we want, but because it is necessary. And it costs more than 400 thousand rubles. What money will we treat it from? From the salary of doctors?
As a result of many innovations so far-maybe this is some kind of transition period? - According to the accounts of the register of compulsory medical insurance, we began to receive no more, but less, despite the fact that the coefficient seemed to increase.
And at the same time, scatter with money. Here is informatization. I come to the city. I go to the clinic. There is a computer. I ask: "Does it work?" “We have concluded the contract with Moscow programmers, they put us a program.” I come to another city, all the same: “So far it does not work. They found a company in Moscow, paid money, they put us ... "
What is it?
We can’t make a single program for so many years, transfer to all clinics? We overpay a lot of money.
And informatization gives a lot. In Orenburg, they gave me a password in the children's hospital, and I entered the system from the office. I looked at the registry, I see what turn. "Can a medical office?" - "Can". “Can you see how many patients this pediatrician accepted last day?” - "Can". - "Or maybe there is a diary, and treatment, and purpose?" - "There is, and a hospital and 8 clinics are combined into the network!" What are we inventing? Take look how much it costs, implement.
About legislation. You know my position, I have performed this more than once. But they do not want to listen to representatives of civil society. They look at us like obsessive flies. Look at the draft law on health protection. The section on medical associations, public organizations has become some kind of kutsy. Do we not need them? Or will we then create a separate law about them? Instruct the medical room to prepare this section. Our people are not a fool, and there are no enemies among us.
How many years do we ask: where is the concept of healthcare development? Where are we going? Please tell us loudly. At the congress of doctors, let's discuss this concept. And already under this concept we will build laws.
Wound up. Let's go a different path. First quietly laws. But the concept is not. And now we will build a concept under the laws.
For compulsory medical insurance or new forms of ownership of institutions: autonomous, budget, state-owned-first conduct a pilot project in one or two regions of the country. And then adopt the law.
Vladimir Vladimirovich, why are the authors of laws are hiding from us? You don't know?
I repeat, I look, all the time they interfere with Vladimir Vladimirovich to listen.
Vladimir Putin: Apparently, they are deliberately distracted.
Yes, both on one and the other. I am moving.
I ask: why do not we know the authors of laws? If there are many of them, nothing, we will read the names. The country should know its heroes in person.
Vladimir Putin: No one hides the authors there, it is easy to clarify.
A lot of harm brought us 94-ФЗ. Now he is corrected, that's right. But the Ministry of Economic Development distinguished himself again. Order No. 601 came. Have you received? "On approval of the nomenclature of goods, works, services for the needs of the customer." A new purchase scheme, which combined unlawed groups, for example, antibiotics and antifungal drugs. Now we can buy one or another per quarter. Or group No. 96: combined Vatu and X -ray equipment. We just get up! These are such laws and orders that discredit power. As if deliberately someone invents.
The frivolous attitude towards public organizations is evidenced by such a fact. We held together with trade unions the first conference on self -regulation of professional activity. 70 regions participated, the decision was sent, including to the Ministry of Health and Social Development. And just in six months, we get an answer signed by Vladimir Belov. An example of epistolary bureaucratic art is about everything, but not about the specific sentences that we had. It is published on the website of the National Medical Chamber - you can read. (And I think, Vladimir Vladimirovich, that I received this answer when the ministry found out that I was with you and left our decision.) Belov - a good specialist, financier, graduated from the Institute of Water Transport. But in Leningrad. He could not know the specifics of the questions that were raised in our solution.
I am a straight person and I cannot but say that this is a trouble, that the Ministry of Health and Social Development does not have a single normal experienced healthcare organizer. (Applause.)
I have questions for some of the Ministry of Health. So to Olga Vladimirovna Krivonos - she lowered her head. She once explained to Tatyana Alekseevna Golikova that the ambulance should come to the hospital and continue to work in the hospital with the one whom she delivered. Goodbye, ambulance for those who still be needed? When a child with a combined injury is lucky to me at the ambulance, she reports, the patient is greeted in the receptionist resuscitator, neurosurgeon, traumatologist and general surgeon. This is the approach of specialized care to the patient. And not the use of an ambulance in the hospital ...
Another trouble is the difference in the per capita norm in different regions of the country. The difference in tariffs that have not changed for several years. We have one country. Why should a person suffer if he was born in the subsidized region and there are no sufficient funds for healthcare? The ill -conceived division of the powers of healthcare into federal, regional and municipal levels. <...>
Vladimir Putin: To make it clear colleagues, I asked Leonid Mikhailovich to speak. Although he knew in advance that this performance would be polemic, sharp, professional, and in some way naive. But this naivety is from a desire to make better, and this is the most important thing.
_ (Published with minor reductions) _
Leonid Roshal: "For me, the party - patients and doctors"
We called Leonid Roshal and asked what is the most weak link in Russian healthcare now?
- The main thing is personnel.
- Is the most important thing in the personnel problem - salary?
- In working with medical personnel there are two necessary things. The first - the salary of doctors should be doubled and tripled. And the second is the state program of training and retraining of personnel with the introduction of continuous, personified, free for doctors of education. Return to the distribution of graduates of medical universities who are studying at the state expense. This must be done now, and not later, after 5-6 years, because now there is an acute lack of personnel.
The next question: the introduction of self -regulation of professional activities - the transfer of certification issues, the development of protocols, methodological recommendations, standards that are mandatory for each specialist. The creation of an independent professional examination, arbitration courts, professional liability insurance, patient protection from poor -quality treatment and medical errors. And the protection of doctors from unreasonable judicial persecution, if they did not violate ethical norms, professional approaches. These are precisely those issues that the very young National Medical Chamber began to deal with actively.
Licensing has nothing to do with us, because a doctor’s license is, in our understanding, a diploma and a certificate, which he then must confirm with his professional activity.
- Leonid Mikhailovich, why did you decide to perform so hard right now?
“I can't understand your question.” Open the decisions of the Health Commission of the Public Chamber in two volumes in four years. All this is there. All the years I am talking about the same thing. I am in the government, when I was invited, I said the same thing. I can’t change myself. I did not say anything supernova. But much more did not say.
I am not in any party. For me, the party is patients and doctors.
- What is the reaction to your speech? Rejoice?
- To dance and jump, I did not see. But calls, letters and SSEMECK are a complete phone. From all over the country. I just said what most doctors think about. So you can’t live on. It is important that the benefits be. Judging by Putin’s reaction, he heard us.