The Moscow City Duma approved for submission to the State Duma a draft law "On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation in Part of Improving the Mechanism for Preventing and Combating Drug Addiction, Substance Abuse, Alcoholism." We have learned that the project has passed an examination in the State Duma. The core of the bill is testing young people for drug use without a doctor's prescription. But will it help the fight against drugs? What will the school, police, parents, medicine do with children who test positive?
This call to the editor was just after such a check at school. True, my mother asked not to give the city and last name: “Galya refused to give urine - this had to be done under the supervision of a school nurse, who, one by one, with a special glass for analysis, escorted the girls to the toilet. This is probably so that they do not pass one urine at all. Galya refused. When I began to ask why, she said that she had heard that a positive result happens and not only for those who take drugs. “Can you imagine what they will arrange if it turns out to be positive ?!” But they arranged for her without a positive result. The class teacher said just that: If you don’t pass, you will pass - you accept.
Will the saliva or urine tests that are going to be taken from schoolchildren help the fight against drugs? After the investigation of the personal tragedy, which was undertaken by our crime reporter Sergei Kanev ("New" No. 33 of 03.30.2011 "The Death of a Son"), there are big doubts about this. The expert, president of the Society of Evidence-Based Medicine Specialists, Doctor of Medical Sciences Vasily Vlasov, is of the same opinion.
Director of the Moscow Scientific and Practical Center for Narcology and Chief Narcologist of the Ministry of Health and Social Development of Russia Yevgeny Bryun has been promoting the idea of testing schoolchildren and students for drug use for 10 years and now reports with satisfaction: “legislators have responded to our numerous requests.”
They responded for an obvious reason - drug use in Russia is growing. The agency responsible for controlling the distribution of drugs puts pressure on pharmacists, veterinarians and grandmothers who have self-sowing poppies in their garden, and does not fight Afghan heroin. This is understandable: they don't shoot in pharmacies. People's initiatives - let's remember the "City Without Drugs" - frighten the authorities. If we add to this the wretched state of drug treatment in the country, it is understandable why legislators are looking for new, untrodden paths.
The fact is that addictions, traditionally called drug addiction by lawyers, are very difficult to treat. It is easy to isolate an addict for a short period of time, but as soon as he leaves the hospital, he again begins to take the passionately desired drug. To overcome addiction, rehabilitation, long-term support, measures to restore the ability to lead oneself are needed. This is a rather expensive and not very effective practice, in Russia it is extremely small. We must pay tribute to the chief narcologist - E. Brune constantly points out the need to develop a network of rehabilitation centers.
Due to the fact that it is difficult to overcome addiction, and drug addicts bring harm to themselves and others every day and every hour, all over the world, in addition to drug treatment programs, harm reduction programs are being developed.
To prevent addicts from sharing syringes and infecting each other with serious infections like hepatitis and AIDS, a natural and cheap solution is to give addicts clean syringes. It has been proven that as a result, it is possible to slow down the spread of infections among drug addicts. The fewer infections drug addicts have, the safer the lives of other people.
Another misfortune of a drug addict and society is that he is ready to commit a crime in order to get money for the drug he depends on. If drug addicts are given a safe and cheap substance that replaces them with a drug, then it is possible to reduce crime and even help drug addicts integrate into society and work. The so-called substitution therapy is quite well studied, quite safe. The World Health Organization has included these substitution medications in its list of "Essential Medicines". We have such a list called the "List of Vital and Essential Medicines", but our list does not include a single drug for substitution therapy, they are not even allowed to be imported into Russia, and a ban on medical use was introduced into the federal law. As a result, the entire domestic narcology stands with divorced hands and is forced to practice methods of treatment that were outdated in the middle of the 20th century.
Instead of effective means of prevention and treatment, squiggles like medical examinations of schoolchildren are invented.
E. Brun conducted the first experiments on checking schoolchildren and students back in 2001. Already in 2004, Moscow legislators wrote in the city law "On Youth" among the measures to support health, physical culture and sports: "The executive authorities of the city of Moscow organize an annual medical examination of underage citizens, including testing for the consumption of narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances." Like this, without the doctor's instructions and the consent of the parents. Fortunately, Moscow parents did not resignedly accept testing contrary to federal laws and dangerous for the family. But work began on amending the federal law.
And now, on March 10, on the first TV channel, they showed how Sverdlovsk schoolchildren handed over saliva for analysis. Right there, for the camera, saliva is dripped onto the strips and the result is watched. Such disinformation accompaniment will be the steeper the closer to the submission of the bill to the State Duma.
The authors of the bill refer to the instruction of the President, but the text that is available to us says: “to prepare and submit to the State Duma ... draft federal laws: ... on the introduction of medical studies of certain categories of citizens to identify the fact of consumption of narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances and their analogues” . What did you think? It is obvious that we are talking about pilots, operators of nuclear power plants, drug police and other people whom society would first of all like to see free from any addictions. But Moscow legislators went in the wrong direction, but where it is easier - to force children to be tested.
Why survey all schoolchildren and students? We are told: we will identify those who use, and then we will help them not to use. Bruhn touts as a great achievement his own tests that detect not only drug contact during the last days, but also use for several months. Such tests are all the more pointless. If a person has not used the drug during the last days, his past long-term experience does not matter. What can be done for single drug users? Identification of "probers", as E. Brune calls them, is absolutely meaningless.
But Brun, on the blue eye of a video camera, recently reported that it turns out that preventive screening (examination of healthy people) for drug use is recommended by WHO, and has been successfully used in the Scandinavian countries for a long time. Both of these are not true. There is no strong evidence for the usefulness of screening healthy people for drug use, and WHO does not recommend it. WHO recommends that people be screened for whom there is reason to believe that they abuse alcohol or use drugs that are not prescribed by a doctor.
In addition, any tests can give false positive and false negative results. We don't know anything about the quality of the tests invented by E. Brune and his colleagues. No one knows what to do with accidentally discovered signs of drug use. E. Brun offers to "understand" and "help" with the consent of the parents.
Instead of real work - swindle. Screening at school will lead to the identification of those who once tried drugs. Then you can frighten everyone with numbers and report that they have worked with those identified, and they no longer use ... The reports will not contain anything that these people would no longer use anyway.
Any medical examination must be voluntary. Compulsory examinations - only by court order, but this is extremely rare. Workers of some professions are examined to ensure the safety of the population (food workers, kindergarten workers, pilots ...), but they also give consent. At school, testing cannot be truly voluntary. If everyone passes urine, and Masha refuses, then Masha will be pressured by the teacher, the headmaster, and comrades - “come on, fill it up - no better than others!” Our narcologists and drug police are already commenting on this prospect: whoever refuses is probably the one who uses drugs!
Once the analysis is completed, its result must be recorded. Today, E. Brune proudly announces that the results of one examination at the university are hidden in his safe and he will not show them to anyone. But according to the law, the results of the examination of people cannot belong to Brun or Fedorov. They are at the disposal of the medical organization and are provided to health officials, investigators, interrogators, and so on. - the list is huge. In our militia-police since 2000, there has been an instruction for working with minors, which prescribes to register with the institution "accounting and preventive cards" of minors "using narcotic drugs or psychotropic substances without a doctor's prescription." So, as soon as the medical examination is carried out, the police will come for the results.
Who benefits from testing children? Carrying out such testing dramatically increases the flow of solvent parents with children to narcologists. The possibilities of the state and municipal network in providing drug treatment, as Yevgeny Bryun himself repeatedly said, are extremely limited, and parents will have to turn to private practitioners. The latter are ready to offer them everything - from private conversations to rehabilitation in the Himalayas. The money that deceived people will incur to narcologists, and that the state will allocate for such pseudo-drug assistance, will go, including, specifically, to E. Bruno, the holder of a number of patents for methods of treating and rehabilitating drug addicts. The more such "assistance" is provided, the greater the deduction to the patent holder. The more tests are carried out, the more deductions from sales to developers and manufacturers of tests for "drugs". Gryzlov and Petrik were probably not the first to discover the possibilities of patents for pumping the national budget into the pocket of the patent holder, but this technology of using federal laws for personal enrichment has been picked up.
Testing is also supported by the drug control service: it is more pleasant for the service to deal with defenseless children and their families than with drug lords. But the school should not become a place of organized state violence against children.
Vasily Vlasov, Doctor of Medical Sciences, President of the Society of Evidence-Based Medicine Specialists
for Novaya Gazeta