About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Newsletter
About RIMA
For researchers
Collection
Kronika Project
About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Date
02/24/2000
Author
Hidden
Source
Novaya Gazeta
Preserved copy
Internet Archive
Translated material

REDITION OF DREAMS

Why the oligarchs will not defend democracy, but only property Image of the Enemy For ten years, liberal intellectuals have been scaring the public and each other with the return of the communists. In fact, most of our cultural figures or...

Why the oligarchs will not defend democracy, but only property

The image of the enemy

For ten years, liberal intellectuals have been scaring the public and each other with the return of the Communists. In fact, most of our cultural figures or masters of domestic journalism under the communists lived quite tolerably. Yes, they were prevented from working, but in fact there was no totalitarianism for a long time. Under totalitarianism, restructuring does not happen. It's just that the foremen of perestroika, who later became the singers of neoliberal reforms, needed the image of an enemy. The Communists were perfect for this role - fortunately, no one has forgotten about the Stalinist repressions.

The image of the enemy turned out to be so terrible that the intellectuals themselves believed in it and were afraid. For the sake of fighting the terrible threat of “totalitarian revenge” on the current government, anything could be forgiven. The very people who today shout "democracy in danger" in 1993 hailed the violation of the Constitution and the shooting at the parliament. The same voices that now warn us against the introduction of censorship, only recently called for the prohibition of "red" publications.

Yes, the real danger never comes from where it is expected. But this is only part of the problem. The main trouble is that the offensive of authoritarianism in post-Soviet Russia was prepared and supported by people who still call themselves democrats. Now they complain about the forced unanimity of the press. Wasn't the "democratic" press just as unanimous in the early 1990s, when not a single critical word about the "reformers" and Yeltsin could be said without immediately being labeled an "enemy of democracy"? Television absolutely totalitarian inspired us with propaganda clichés, intimidated us with the “red-brown threat”.

Yes, of course, in 1991-1993 there was also a communist press, but it only reached the communists. For this, the leaders of the Supreme Council needed their own body to make it clear to society that there are political forces in Russia that are not communist, do not advocate a return to the past, but nevertheless do not agree with the current policy. Now it can already be stated that almost all the warnings that were made in 1992-1993 by economists close to the Supreme Soviet turned out to be correct. The development of the country followed the path of oligarchic and peripheral capitalism, led to deindustrialization and exacerbation of social contradictions. This was no less obvious in 1993 than it is now. If critics of the reforms had been able to reach out to public opinion then, much would be different today. People's deputies of 1992-1993 were not given such an opportunity, they were stuck with the image of the enemy.

And as you know, if the enemy does not surrender, he is destroyed.

In 1993, for the first time, the authorities crossed over the law and through blood. She did it to the applause of the liberal public. Who proved to us that the Constitution can be violated for the sake of political expediency, who spoke in the press justifying the execution of the crowd at Ostankino, who went joyfully to look at the burning White House?

After the shooting of parliament, the liberal intelligentsia enthusiastically supported the authoritarian Constitution of 1993, which in all respects was a huge step backwards compared to the legislation of 1991-1992. Not only did Yeltsin's Basic Law render the government and the president essentially unaccountable, it placed the Constitutional Court under their control, thereby ending the independence of the judiciary.

Parliament turned into a decoration, where the cardboard opposition could sit as long as it wanted.

The first war in Chechnya was a logical continuation of the shooting at the White House. Indeed, why shouldn't Dudayev's palace in Grozny be bombed if it was possible to shoot at the House of Soviets in Moscow? Why is it impossible to kill civilians in Chechnya, if it is permissible to do the same in one's own capital? Why are Chechen fighters better than the "red" fighters, who were so feared in 1993?

Our human rights activists themselves urged the authorities to disregard the laws and crack down on dissidents. And it never occurred to anyone that the "Reds", being in the minority, have the same human rights as all other people. Dissenters have the right to their opinion even when we do not like it, and the right to freedom of thought, as Rosa Luxemburg noted in her polemic with Lenin, is precisely the right to dissent. Even if nostalgic communists are not supporters of democracy, they still remain citizens and should be protected by law. The liberal intelligentsia, having got rid of Soviet censorship, did not want to hear the voices of those who suffered from the new post-Soviet system. As a result, she took responsibility for all the outrages that took place.

In 1996, another propaganda hysteria began. In 1993, something could be explained by the novelty of the situation, a lack of understanding of the problems that had arisen. Three years later, no one had any moral alibi. And the Zyuganovs could intimidate the people only with malicious intent. The leaders of the restored Communist Party themselves were perfectly inscribed in the Yeltsin system, attached to the same feeding troughs. In 1996, they were afraid that the communists would not return - they were afraid of the unpredictability that is always associated with democracy. They were afraid to let the people make their own choice. Of course, it was necessary to vote, but it was not we who had to decide, but completely different people and in another place. That is why the 1996 elections were actually held as having no alternative - against the backdrop of transparent hints that if the masses vote incorrectly, a civil war will begin in the country (don't vote, and the Kremlin team will not give up power anyway).

Why were the 1996 elections better than the 2000 elections? In a certain sense, they were worse - because of the mass complicity of the authorities on the part of the liberal intelligentsia. As one editor-in-chief put it in 1996, "We have locked our consciences in a vault during the election." Yes, they locked it, but they lost the key.

Today they, perhaps, would like to find the treasured key, but it's not so easy...

Self-criticism

People make mistakes, they have the right to change their views. The problem is not that someone supported Yeltsin in 1993 or 1996. Not even in the fact that by doing so they supported the system of personal power, which inevitably leads to dictatorship. The problem is different: no one or almost no one repented. None of those who today call for a rebuff to the maturing dictatorship have the moral courage to admit their share of the blame, to say that they themselves prepared it. In this sense, the communists turned out to be more honest than the “democrats”. The Communists at least had the 20th Congress. Yes, this self-criticism was inconsistent, half-hearted, but it nevertheless took place. She, incidentally, was quite risky - both politically and morally. If, after Stalin, millions of people continued to believe in communism (not only as an idea, but also as a political movement), it was not least because moral self-purification was promised. After the communist parties, fearful of their own political audacity, backed off, moral capital was quickly lost.

The liberal intelligentsia today has not even risen to the moral level of the Khrushchev Politburo - and there, it must be said, there were far from angels. Andrei Babitsky, after the shooting of the White House, sent Yeltsin back the medal awarded to him for participating in the first defense of the White House in August 1991. He was absolutely not obliged to do this - after all, in 1991 he did not do anything that he, as a citizen or journalist, should have been ashamed of. And yet he had to somehow indicate his break with power, his rejection of authoritarianism, his readiness to go against the current. And he did it at a time when the liberal public was still singing the president's praises with might and main. Yes, today none of those who are indignant at the massacre of Babitsky dared to refuse the awards and titles appropriated by the authorities.

Yes, there is no doubt that those who today belatedly protest against the stifling of the free press, racist propaganda, the military adventure in Chechnya and the falsification of elections are morally and civilly much better than their other colleagues, monotonously praising and. O. president and crowds rushing to nominate Putin's candidacy for the post of legitimate chief boss. Yes, belated disagreement is better than timely servility. Yet ethical questions remain. And the point now is not to poke a finger at someone and remember the past. It's just that without a sober assessment of the past, without firm moral principles, the movement for democratic freedoms will not be politically effective. For those who do not have tanks and police batons, all strength lies in the firmness of the moral position. If this is not the case, there is nothing to oppose to the club.

There will be no return to the past

Behind the lamentations about totalitarian revenge lies not only fear of impending danger or a desire to hide one's own guilt. Behind them lies an elementary misunderstanding of the current socio-political situation. After all, it was not from the "Reds" that the authoritarian threat came, not from the supporters of the Soviet system, but from patented "reformers" to whom the American administration itself appropriated such a title.

Authoritarianism does not appear in a vacuum. It is generated by a certain social system, protects certain interests. The old Soviet economic system is long gone. Everything has long been privatized by the oligarchs. And they need a dictatorship not for the sake of social justice, but for the protection of property.

Already when Chubais promoted the ideas of "landslide" privatization, it was clear that such an approach was incompatible with democracy. In a society where property is concentrated in the hands of an insignificant minority, there can be no full-fledged civil equality; where the press is owned by big money and television is owned by a handful of magnates, there will be neither freedom of speech nor freedom of the press.

Yeltsin did not accidentally appoint Putin as his successor. In a period when it was necessary to divide property and ensure the export of capital abroad, democracy was still suitable. Moreover, it was needed as a way to legitimize power, to make it attractive (both in the face of its citizens and in the face of the West). Now property is largely divided up, real estate in Europe has been bought up, and the ruling elite needs a strict order to protect themselves from millions of have-nots. And at the same time, from each other, because in the conditions of predatory management, privatized property, no matter how much it may be, is still not enough for all the oligarchs.

The oligarchy needs a dictatorship. That is why the struggle for democracy is meaningless if at the same time it is not an anti-oligarchic struggle. But this is a conclusion that liberal leaders are also mortally afraid of. After all, this way you can get into the same camp with the "reds". Dictatorship in Russia does not come from the "left", as we were scared, but from the right. And therefore, whether someone likes it or not, the opposition will objectively “left”.

The old Soviet layouts are fading into the past, they are being replaced by new ones, surprisingly similar to what we once read about in Latin American novels. All this is reminiscent of the well-known fairy tale about the genie, who fulfills any desire at such a price that it would be better not to ask for anything at all. Those who helped let the genie out of the bottle are now painfully thinking about how to drive it back. The intellectuals asked for a Russian Pinochet. Now they will most likely get it. I do not like? Should have thought ahead!

Putin promised us that he would not allow a return to the past. And he is absolutely right. Another thing is that the future that the current government is preparing for us may turn out to be worse than any past.