
At first glance, luck accompanies Vladimir Putin. The most important outcome of the hostilities in 2016: the Syrian government troops, supported by the Russian aviation group, albeit with considerable difficulty, but still took the two millionth Aleppo, the second most important city in Syria. Taking advantage of this circumstance, Moscow called for another truce, which would supposedly lead to some kind of political settlement. Of course, on the terms of the ruling regime in Damascus.
Having got involved in the Syrian civil war in the fall of 2015, the Kremlin set as a secondary goal a way out of the international isolation in which Russia found itself as a result of the annexation of Crimea and a hybrid war in the Donbass. And, it must be admitted, this goal was largely achieved. Throughout the past year, US Secretary of State John Kerry had regular telephone conversations with his Russian counterpart Sergei Lavrov. Putin himself arranged real telephone conferences with the participation of the leaders of the leading European states. And even the owner of the White House was forced, apparently against his will, from time to time to make contact with his Russian colleague.
The war in Syria, now 15 months old and estimated to have cost Russian taxpayers between $1 billion and $3.6 billion, has also become a hot topic in domestic politics. Television broadcast daily reports of the military department about daily victories. If you believe the reports, in 2016 our air strikes destroyed an unthinkable number of terrorist command posts and thousands of militants themselves (at the same time, Russian intelligence mastered an unprecedented art - it determined the nationality of enemies from the air and each time indicated exactly how many "terrorists" were killed "arrived in Syria from Russia). Everyman watched this small victorious war from the sofa, considering what was happening on the TV screen a computer game, something like catching Pokemon. And when the heavy aircraft-carrying cruiser “Admiral Kuznetsov” arrived on the Syrian shores, quite fuming, the heart of the layman should have been filled with pride: far away, our planes take off from the ship’s deck to bomb the enemy, no worse than American ones. The fact that at the same time, not from enemy fire, but due to the failure of equipment and poor training of personnel, two fighters were lost, one could not pay attention.
As soon as it became clear that the main Syrian leader was not going to leave, the ceasefire lost all meaning - the subject of negotiations between Assad's representatives and the armed opposition disappeared.
True, along the way, one insignificant problem made itself felt (not counting the losses, of course). Despite the remarkable victories, a certain force each time returns domestic strategists to the same, it would seem, repeatedly passed level of the “game”. So, in the last days of the victorious assault on Aleppo, ISIS militants * with a sudden blow regain ancient Palmyra. And repeatedly bombed terrorists who should have lost the will to resist commit crimes all over the world: from Ankara, where the Russian ambassador was killed (see page 32 for more details), to Berlin, where a truck crushed people at a Christmas market.
In fact, the course of hostilities in Syria in 2016 is a vicious circle: from a truce to an assault, and then again from an assault to a truce. In February, Moscow, apparently assuming that the five-month-long bombing had bled the militants bled dry, announced a two-week ceasefire — there was an agreement with Washington on this score. Russia even created a special center in which our officers were supposed to persuade the leaders of the "rebellious territories" to stop hostilities. The truce did not, of course, extend to those whom Moscow called terrorists. Soon, much to the surprise of Sergei Shoigu, who reported on the next successes of the air group, Putin announced the successful completion of the operation and the withdrawal of most of the combat aircraft from the Khmeimim air base. Then it seemed that Putin understood that it was impossible to win the war he got involved in, and, having achieved his goal, he was trying to “jump off” and save face.

However, the truce was soon broken. Bashar al-Assad has clearly perked up thanks to Russian aviation (and not only aviation) support. The dictator set his own conditions regarding a truce, hinted that he would participate in the new presidential elections, when and if the matter came to them. As soon as it became clear that the main Syrian leader was not going to leave, the ceasefire lost all meaning - the subject of negotiations between Assad's representatives and the armed opposition disappeared. But the West has placed the responsibility for the disruption of the truce not on the Syrian dictator, but on Putin. And he understood: he was in Syria for a long time (later the Russian parliament secured an indefinite Russian military presence in this country).
The planes remaining at the Khmeimim base, to which strategic bombers joined, began to hit the terrorists in Palmyra. In the end, the IS * formations left the ancient city, the liberation of which became a symbol of the success of Russian weapons in Syria. And Assad's forces were able to concentrate on Aleppo. Events followed a familiar pattern: relentless bombardments that killed hundreds of civilians, and rather sluggish actions by Assad's motley army, including exhausted government troops, Iranian and Palestinian volunteers, and Lebanese Hezbollah units.
In order to stop the bloodshed, in September, Washington signed another ceasefire agreement with Moscow. The agreement included the creation of a joint Russian-American center to maintain a ceasefire and even joint (or at least coordinated) airstrikes on areas where terrorist groups are based. All this assumed the unthinkable - the exchange of intelligence information in real time, when it would not be possible to specially edit it so as to hide from each other the possibilities and sources of their intelligence. The initiative required such a degree of trust in relations between Russia and the United States, which for many years could not be achieved even within NATO: only 60 years after its creation, the Alliance was able to create joint intelligence agencies. However, the exchange of intelligence information with Russia, a state that the West, at least on the European continent, intends to contain by military force, is already something unthinkable.
As a result, this agreement was thwarted. Either Russian or Syrian aircraft continued to peck at the besieged Aleppo, destroying hospitals and peaceful neighborhoods. And, of course, causing protests in the US and Europe. There was even talk of imposing new sanctions against Russia. Thus, the hope that the Syrian operation would make it possible to get out of international isolation gradually faded away.
Having gone full circle, Russian diplomacy has returned to its previous level. In order to establish a dialogue on the Syrian settlement, Moscow had to abandon its unconditional support for Assad, who is considered in the West to be the main culprit in the deaths of hundreds of thousands of people. It was necessary to abandon Putin's main conviction that the people do not choose their rulers, but are doomed to live with the ruler who managed to seize and retain power. This did not happen. As a result, the war, with its senseless casualties, pushed the peacekeeping efforts into a corner every time.
To make matters worse, on December 9, in the final phase of the battle for Aleppo, IS* militants recaptured Palmyra. Guerrilla warfare is a quagmire that you can easily climb into, but it is very difficult to get out of it. The last 60 years have not given examples of military victories of regular armies over paramilitary formations. The problem (which does not yet have a solution) is that the regular army must control the territories liberated from the partisans. Therefore, after each victory, it is doomed to place garrisons in the occupied areas, to establish a system for their logistics support. As a result, fewer and fewer troops remain for the next combat mission. On the other hand, in order to strengthen the attacking formations, it is necessary to weaken the garrisons guarding the previously liberated territories. The field commanders of the "Islamic State" * immediately took advantage of the fact that all the forces of Assad were thrown into the assault on Aleppo, and thus, obviously, the formations defending Palmyra were weakened. As a result, at the end of the year, the ancient city was again in the hands of the militants.
Sooner or later, the Russian generals will offer Putin a quick move to finish the job with a large-scale ground operation. Moreover, such an operation was already rehearsed during the Center-2015 maneuvers: first, an airborne division lands on the captured airfield, and then a 100,000-strong army approaches
The resources of Assad's army are clearly depleted. According to press reports, after the capture of Aleppo and the second fall of Palmyra, Moscow and Tehran strongly recommend that Assad go on the defensive: there are simply no forces for a further offensive. And this means that the initiative will be on the side of the groups opposing Damascus.
Sooner or later, Russian generals will offer Putin a quick move to finish the job with a large-scale ground operation. Moreover, such an operation had already been rehearsed during the Center-2015 maneuvers: first, an airborne division landed on the captured airfield, and then an army of 100,000 troops approached. In order to provide the General Staff strategists with the necessary manpower, the State Duma urgently adopted amendments to the law "On military duty and military service." They allow concluding "short-term" contracts for participation in a specific operation abroad, which legalizes the participation of Russian mercenaries in the Syrian campaign. Even worse, the law allows conscripts to be contracted and sent to a distant land. It seems that breaking out of the quicksands of the Syrian desert will be much more difficult than climbing into them.
Another danger lies in the fact that on the eve of the presidential elections, the average Russian may get fed up with victories in Syria. And then the Kremlin will need another small victorious war. According to Bloomberg, Moscow may also get involved in the Libyan civil strife, supporting the military leader Khalifa Haftar, who controls the eastern and partly northern regions of the country. Haftar, according to Bloomberg, has recently been frequenting Moscow…
* "Islamic State" (ISIS, ISIS) is an organization banned in Russia as a terrorist organization.