On Monday, September 3, the police conducted a search and seizure of documents in the Moscow branch of Smolensky Bank OJSC. On its website, the bank posted an official message: “The visit of employees of the Ministry of Internal Affairs to the branch of the bank on September 3, 2012 is connected with the activities of one of the unscrupulous clients and has nothing to do with the work of Smolensky Bank OJSC. Meanwhile, the police reported that the investigative measures are still related to the work of the bank, and the most direct:
“According to preliminary data, in 2009 and 2010, some citizens, posing as bank employees, misled customers and illegally took possession of their apartments,” Andrey Galiakberov, head of the press service of the Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs for Moscow, told Novaya Gazeta. “Under the guise of a loan agreement secured by an apartment, citizens were given a contract for the sale of real estate to sign.
Over the years, about a hundred people have become victims of fraudsters. All of them, when applying for a loan at the bank's office, communicated with a respectable man aged 55-60, who introduced himself as Sergei Salia. Now the bank does not recognize Saliya as its employee. But, as numerous victims confirm, he behaved like a boss in the office, bank employees treated him respectfully, and Salia quickly resolved all issues related to loan approval. Salia's Lexus was parked in the bank's parking lot, even on the day it was searched.
Salia offered borrowers to issue a loan under the program "Mutual Trust" - at 24-28% per annum. As security for the loan, an apartment was issued, moreover, under a contract of sale. At the same time, the value of the pledged property was seriously underestimated - up to 20-30% of the real one, just for the amount of the loan. As a guarantee of the return of the apartment, people were offered to draw up a contract for the repurchase of the apartment, but without a date. “This is a mere formality necessary to facilitate the transaction,” Salia said. “As soon as you pay off the loan, we will put a date in the contract, and the apartment will be yours again.”
Loans were issued quickly, literally in one day.
Future borrowers were brought a huge package of documents, but there was no way to scrupulously familiarize themselves with them: some papers were taken away for correction, others were brought, then taken away again, constantly distracted by extraneous conversations. People signed the contract literally in the last minutes of the bank's work - so as not to repeat the whole procedure tomorrow.
The transaction was certified by the notary Elizaveta Smorgunova, who works in the same building where the bank is located.
Later, borrowers found out that the interest rate on their loans turned out to be several times higher than that originally discussed. Attempts to terminate this agreement led to the fact that they were evicted from apartments that had already been re-registered as Salia. Bank "Smolensky" also demanded through the court to pay off the loan with accrued penalties. In light of this circumstance, few of the people who lost money believe that the top management of the bank was not involved in Saliy's affairs.
However, the idea also had other big patrons.
“Scammers have a good roof,” says lawyer Andrey Rudnev, who represents the interests of the victims. - All our appeals to law enforcement agencies came to one person - Artem Nesmachny, the GSU investigator for Moscow. And Nesmachny invariably made decisions to refuse to initiate a criminal case.
Meanwhile, the mother of Artem Nesmachny, as it turned out later, bought an apartment that used to belong to one of the victims of the scam.
Only once a criminal case on the fact of fraud in a bank was nevertheless initiated - at the request of Tatyana Shkanaeva, who also lost her apartment. The investigation was carried out by the investigative unit at the Department of Internal Affairs for the South Administrative District of Moscow, but soon the case was requested by the Main Investigative Directorate - and again turned out to be with Nesmachny. As a result of his investigation, Shkanaeva turned from a victim into a criminal. The case went to court, and the woman, who was in her ninth month of pregnancy, was sentenced to three years probation under Article 159 - “Fraud”. It follows from the verdict that when selling her apartment to Sergei Salia, the woman forged the signature of her own daughter. So Shkanaeva found herself without an apartment, with a huge debt to the bank, and even with a criminal record.
As other injured borrowers say, they were warned that if they did not calm down and stop complaining, the next sentences would no longer be suspended, but with real terms.
Attempts to protest the actions of Nesmachny from his immediate leadership were futile. Effective, according to deceived borrowers, was only an appeal to the State Duma.
“We turned to Viktor Cherkesov, First Deputy Chairman of the State Duma Committee on Security and Anti-Corruption,” says Andrey Rudnev, a lawyer for deceived borrowers. - Cherkesov wrote a deputy's request and took the matter under his personal control.
On May 12, the 6th department of the SC GSU of the Main Directorate of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia for Moscow opened a criminal case on the grounds of a crime under Part 4 of Art. 159 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (fraud committed by an organized group on an especially large scale).
In June, investigators from the head office of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the capital found out the circumstances of the acquisition of that same apartment by Nesmachny's mother. He was fired from the police. The Internal Security Service of the Main Directorate of the Ministry of Internal Affairs for Moscow is conducting an inspection on him. However, it is not yet known about the initiation of a criminal case.
Branch manager of Smolensky Bank Pavel SHITOV:
“The economic situation in 2008-2009, as you remember, was not stable – there was a crisis. It was during this difficult time that the loan brokers with whom the Bank worked developed a new product that allows them to issue loans to borrowers for the purchase of their real estate with the possibility of living in the sold housing and repurchasing it after repaying the loan. In other words, the client could take out a consumer loan in the amount of 60-80% of the cost of his home when selling it to a broker. As soon as the borrower paid off the loan, he got the opportunity to buy his home back.
In order to shorten the paperwork processing time, such a loan was issued not against the security of real estate, but against the security of the Bank's promissory note, which was presented by the borrower when repurchasing his home. In our country, the very procedure for foreclosing the pledged property is very lengthy, and issuing a bill of exchange greatly simplifies the matter, especially since the law allows it.
The developed scheme was also convenient for the borrower, because a loan for a fairly large amount was issued quickly enough, which was also a certain risk for the Bank.
Fortunately, there were not so many such loans - several hundred. Several of these borrowers failed to repay. It was they who provoked an information attack on Smolensky Bank. At the same time, the case of the initiator of this attack within the framework of civil law has already been lost and a corresponding court decision has been issued.”
From all of the above, only one conclusion follows: the activities of Smolensky Bank OJSC were, are and remain absolutely legal, and recent events are not directly related to the activities of the Bank, which in its work is always guided by the relevant laws. JSC "Smolensky Bank" is almost more than law enforcement officers interested in the success of the investigation in this case, and the speedy identification of the perpetrators, who will receive a fair punishment.