About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Newsletter
About RIMA
For researchers
Collection
Kronika Project
About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Date
05/15/2017
Author
Hidden
Source
Grani.ru
Preserved copy
Internet Archive
Translated material

Woe from Gram

"Rosneft". Photo from the site www.dazzle.ru

The decision of the Moscow Arbitration Court in the lawsuit of Rosneft for RBC gives rise to the “permissiveness and impunity of the media”, and RBC itself and its journalists “mock” over the adopted judicial act. This is stated in the cassation appeal of the oil company, Vedomosti reports .

The court, when making a decision on the claim, violated the rule of law, the document says. This is expressed in the fact that the arbitration established that the journalists have spread inaccurate information and damaged its business reputation, but refused to prescribe compensation for damage.

The authenticity of the complaint was confirmed by the publication in RBC. Rosneft refused comments.

The fact that Rosneft appealed on a cassation manner and a decision of the arbitration in a lawsuit to protect the business reputation against the founder of RBC and four journalists of the publication became known on May 5. The cassation appeal of the oil company on the decisions of lower instances was registered in the Arbitration Court of Moscow.

On December 12, 2016, the Moscow Arbitration Court decided on the Rosneft claim . The claims were partially satisfied - the corporation insisted on recovering from RBC for the publication of the article “Sechin asked the government to protect Rosneft from BP almost 3 billion 179 million rubles. However, the court reduced the amount of payment by almost 8 thousand times, to 390 thousand rubles.

At the same time, from the authors of the article by Timofei Dzyadko, Maxim Tovkailo and Lyudmila Simedova, as well as the leading television channel Konstantin Bochkarev, it was decided to recover 4.5 thousand rubles each.

On March 1, the 9th Arbitration Court of Appeal canceled the monetary penalty from the editorial office and journalists of RBC. At the same time, the court confirmed the decision of the first instance that recognized the article defaming the business reputation of Rosneft. The publication by decision of the court should be removed from the site of the publication. In addition, the editorial office has been entrusted with a 10-day period to publish a refutation of the information set forth in the article, as well as report on the refutation of RBC on the air of the RBC television channel.

Lawyer Evgeny Reznik, representing the interests of the publication, did not exclude that after receiving the motivating part of the appeal resolution, he would appeal the decision further. “We are still guided by the opinion of linguistic experts who have not found defamatory formulations and information in materials that are common by media holding,” the lawyer explained. “However, the court decision that has entered into force will be executed in accordance with the letter of the law.”

The publication published an article about Rosneft on its website on April 11, 2016. A television program was released on the basis of this publication on the RBC television channel. The article stated that Rosneft President Igor Sechin asks the government to limit the rights of buyers of privatized shares, fearing that the BP will receive a blocking corporation’s block during the privatization of 19.5 percent of its shares. The publication was also reported with reference to unnamed federal officials that Rosneft's buyers will be obliged not to conclude a joint -stock agreement with BP.

Rosneft said that cooperation with BP is long -term, and published information is false. The press secretary of the corporation Mikhail Leontyev then stated that the whole article is a "fiction of journalists."