About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Newsletter
About RIMA
For researchers
Collection
Kronika Project
About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Date
11/13/2006
Author
Андрей Рябов
Source
Novaya Gazeta
Preserved copy
Internet Archive
Translated material

MYSTIC IN WINE

POINT OF VIEW

It is a matter of routine that politicians and officials seek to justify their decisions, as well as their failures, with rational arguments. Otherwise, the public will raise the question of "their conformity." We seem to be getting right...

It is a matter of routine that politicians and officials seek to justify their decisions, as well as their failures, with rational arguments. Otherwise, the public will raise the question of "their conformity." We seem to have the exact opposite picture. The more unprofessional the decision is made, the more serious its consequences, the stronger the desire of the authorities to explain what happened not with rational reasons, but with frank fantasies.

You don't have to look far for examples. The wave of poisoning by alcohol substitutes that swept across the country forced to consider this issue at the level of government structures. The cause of the tragedy is clear. Some influential people, hoping to take over the alcohol market, squeezing independent producers out of it, miscalculated. And instead of establishing their own monopoly, they destroyed it. And with the continued high demand, the “holes” were instantly filled with crime, which began to sell, as happened at the end of the Soviet era, brake fluids under the guise of cheap alcohol.

However, instead of admitting the failure of their claims to a guiding and regulating role, government officials suddenly began to explain what had happened ... as a conspiracy of some "saboteurs" against the government and its noble intentions. They even agree that the Georgian and Moldovan winemakers are to blame for everything, so treacherously seeking to avenge the expulsion of their products from the Russian market. This myth-making nonsense is repeated by high-ranking officials and replicated with might and main by the official media. As a result, the boundaries between myth and reality are gradually blurred.

Our officials either do not realize what a dangerous mechanism for creating myths they are launching (after all, according to the same logic, if they wish, they themselves can be accused of intending to poison someone), or they do not understand that mass enthusiasm for myths will inevitably be followed by mass insight with all the ensuing consequences.

However, it would be too naive to reproach the inhabitants of the highest echelons of power with short-sightedness. Even if they needed myths, it was only to substantiate decisions that had quite specific, earthly dimensions. For example, in order to save thousands of compatriots from the threat of being poisoned by swill brewed by "pests" and "conspirators", it is necessary to return to the state monopoly of the production of alcoholic beverages. And some go even further, suggesting to nationalize even the alcohol trade.

Such proposals are fully consistent with tradition. If something in the country breaks down or disappears from the shelves, there is a ready-made explanation for this: you can’t give so much freedom to a private trader. In other words, there is not enough state. And it does not matter that the attempts of the state to take over the leadership of one or another sector of the economy ended in failure. In the current situation, when it is practically impossible to find those responsible for this or that decision in bureaucratic offices, the risk of such disorganization increases many times over.

The obsession to increase the role of the state wherever possible is all too obviously reminiscent of the slogan "More socialism!" at the end of the Soviet era, which sounded more insistent, the less goods became on the shelves. Perhaps the authors of the slogan sincerely believed that socialism, as some kind of ideal model, had not yet revealed its enormous transformative potential. It is possible that today's statesmen are convinced that our state has not yet shown its creative potential. The only trouble is that ordinary citizens are not interested in theoretical and ideological constructions, but citizens react very painfully to real failures that affect the daily interests of millions, as well as to slogans consecrating these failures.