
Leonid Mlechin’s film “Stepan Bandera. Declassified life”, shown on the TVC channel, was shot like thirty years ago. All Soviet propaganda stamps regarding Bandera, UPA and OUN are carefully repeated in the film. The main idea boils down to the fact that Bandera and Ukrainian nationalists fought all their lives against Russia, the Soviet Union, killed many innocent people, consciously, by virtue of ideological kinship, collaborated with Hitler Germany, approved the destruction of the Jews and directly participated in the “final decision”, and therefore the murder of Bandera by the Soviet agent in 1959 was a fair revenue.
Mlechin, even in all seriousness, claims that millions of Ukrainians who went to work in Germany for military plants allegedly at the draft of the OUN made a huge contribution to strengthening the defense capabilities of Germany and thereby extended the war and the crimes of Hitlerism. He also believes that the resistance of the UPA to the Soviet troops in Ukraine in 1944-1945 helped Hitler significantly tighten the war and thereby extend the suffering of the peoples. Meanwhile, as is well known, the OUN and UPA actively resisted the sending of youth to Germany - on this basis they most often had clashes with the Germans. And such a policy of Bandera is understandable - after all, the hijacking of the population to Germany undermined their social base. Recall that in the late 40s, the combat power of the UPA was undermined primarily by the Soviet mass deportations of the population of Western Ukraine, and not just because, as the film, people are tired of fighting.
And as for the "decisive" contribution of the UPA to drag out the German resistance, you can only smile here. Could Stalin, who had about 700 divisions, could feel the absence at the front 5 or 10 of them, engaged in the fight against Bandera? And even then these were mainly the NKVD divisions, which rarely appeared at the front.
In the film, there are generally many mistakes caused by the bias of the author. For example, he talks about the cooperation of Ukrainian nationalists with the Poles before the First World War, and that as if in memory of this cooperation in Lviv, a monument to Adam Mitskevich was erected in Lviv. Meanwhile, until 1939, Lviv was a Polish city, where the Poles were absolutely predominated by the population, so the monument to Mickevich was quite appropriate here and had no concern for the Polish-Ukrainian relations.
Mlechin is trying to convince the audience that Ukrainian nationalists have always considered Russia the main enemy. This is not entirely true. For Ukrainian residents of Galicia, the most acute problem was not relations with distant Muscovites, but with the local Polish community. It was with the Poles that the most fierce clashes took place, including armed. After all, Mlechin himself admits that the West-Ukrainian People’s Republic proclaimed after the collapse of Austria-Hungary was destroyed by Polish troops. You can recall the film "Iron Hundred", shot already in post -Soviet Ukraine. There, during the raid, hundreds of UPA to the west, the Poles look like the most disgusting of all Ukrainian enemies. Moskali-Ekavdeshniki are also shown by fair bandits, but they are clearly inferior to the Poles. The Germans there look like enemies with whom Bandera fights as necessary, but without hatred. And the most famous attempt, organized by a bandra, was committed not against the Soviet diplomat, but against the Polish Minister of the Interior. The main enemy of the OUN in the 30s was Poland, and not the Soviet Union, on the territory of which the OUNS did not take any active actions at all. And if we talk about the responsibility of Bandera for crimes against humanity, then he is by no means guilty of the extermination of the Jews, but in the mass destruction of the Poles in Volyn and the Galicia, which was carried out in 1943-1944 with the blessing of the OUN leadership.
Mlechin represents the case as if the pogroms and murders of Jews and Poles in Lviv in the summer of the 41st passed according to the call and with the approval of Bandera representative of Yaroslav Stetskko and other leaders of nationalists. However, even at the hearings in the American Congress in 1954 it was proved that the killings of Jews and Poles in Lviv were organized by the Germans after the Ukrainian battalion “Nachtigal” was withdrawn from the city, and the OUN leadership had no attitude to the “final decision”. According to documents released by the SBU of Ukraine when President Viktor Yushchenko, when the representatives of the Gestapo, who arrived in Lviv, turned to the Ukrainians so that they arranged a three -day Jewish pogrom, and the political and military authorities of Germany promised this not to interfere, the leaders of Ukrainian nationalists stated that this is a provocation aimed at compromising Ukrainians, so that there were a stake Draw the energy of the Ukrainian public from the struggle for state independence. " Also, Ukrainian historians found a certificate of the second management of the KGB of November 16, 1959, which states how to prepare "False Providers of the atrocities of the" battalion "Nachtigal."
The KGB generally fabricated a lot of documents that accused Ukrainian nationalists of all kinds of atrocities. In fact, Bandera and other leaders of the OUN negatively treated the Jews, considering them the agents and accomplices of the Bolsheviks. However, in their directive letters, they warned the members of the OUN against supporting the anti -Jewish actions of the Germans, since they distract Ukrainians from the struggle against the main enemies of the Bolsheviks. Many ordinary members of the OUN, of course, took part in the destruction of the Jews, but the Soviet partisans and fighters of the Polish army of Kraiova killed the Jews in the same way. However, no one is trying on this basis to declare a criminal organization AK or the Soviet partisan movement (from which, by the way, it was pretty to go not only to Jews, but also to civilians of other nationalities).
One Russian historian not so long ago in a dispute about the novel by Shukhevich spoke in the sense that since individual members of the UPA killed Jews and other civilians, then Shukhevich as a commander bears responsibility for this and must be recognized as a criminal. But then the criminals would have to admit almost all the Soviet marshals of Victory, if we recall what the Red Army subordinate to them in Germany and other European countries in 1944-1945 created.
Mlechin admits that after the Germans accelerate the Government Stetskko in Lviv, the Germans repressed many supporters of Bandera, and contrasts them with the leader of the other wing of the OUN Andrei Melnik, who seemed to have not been authorized by the Nazis. In fact, after the Wehrmacht of Kyiv, Melnik tried to create a Ukrainian government there, which was just as dispersed by the Germans as the Government Stetsko in Lviv. And the Germans also repressed the supporters of the miller. In addition, in 1943, the majority of Melniki passed to Bandera.
Mlechin insists that Ukrainian nationalists suffered from the Germans only because they incorrectly appreciated the intentions of their allies, and therefore do not deserve any sympathy. But after all, they were repressed for quite specific actions - hiding Ukrainian flags, attempts to create Ukrainian self -government, the release of pro -Ukrainian and anti -German leaflets, etc. Do these actions themselves deserve condemnation?
In fact, the leaders of the OUN, including the same Shukhevich, already in July of the 41st, after the liquidation of the Lviv government, perfectly realized that the Germans did not want independent Ukraine. But while the hope of the victory of Germany was preserved, they decided to continue the cooperation with the Germans, which was directed against the Bolsheviks, hoping after the war to achieve some Modus Vivevedy with the Nazis. With Stalin, they did not hope for any agreement. And when at the end of 1942 it became clear that Germany would lose the war, the OUN made a bet on the formation of the UPA, which in 1943-1944 fought with the Germans, and the Poles, and the Soviet partisans, and then with the Red Army.
Mlechin believes that the formation of the Galicia SS division and 80 thousand volunteers who wanted to serve in this division prove the ideological proximity of Ukrainian nationalists to German Nazis. But the famous American historian Alexander Dallin, in no sympathy for the OUN, not noticed, half a century ago noted that the main goal of the volunteers who entered the "Galicia" was to get weapons to later join the UPA. This number of volunteers alerted the Germans, who did not really trust in the middle of the 43rd sudden outbreak of Ukrainian love for Germany, and did not use all volunteers. The majority of Galicia entered the Division then really ended up in the ranks of the UPA.
Mlechin also demonizes the post -war activity of the UPA, claiming that they were recruited there with deceit, threats and intimidation, and also assuring the Ukrainian rebels to England and the United States. In fact, the UPA was a mass organization: without a real, not forced support for the local population, it could not fight for almost nine years. Since the 43rd year, OUN Bandera declared its orientation towards England and the United States, but the CIA and British intelligence drew attention to the OUN and the Baltic "forest brothers" only after the war. They were sought to use as sources of information, but never supplied weapons. The exhaustion of ammunition and, most importantly, the collapse of hopes for the Third World War just became important reasons for the cessation of armed resistance.
Paphos Mlechin is to degerize Bandera, to prove that he is inaudible to heroic myths and should be thrown out of Ukrainian history and replaced by other, more worthy heroes. But the trouble is that other heroes of the struggle for Ukrainian independence in the 30-50s except Bandera, Shukhevich and other leaders of the OUN, who, to one degree or another, were not there. And in this regard they are not alone. If we take almost all the leaders of the national liberation movements of that period, then they collaborated either with Hitler or with others equally unsympathetic modes.
The Arab liberation movement collaborated with Hitler and Mussolini. One of the leaders of the Indian Liberation Movement, Subhaas Chandra Bos, first collaborated with the Nazis and created an Indian legion in Germany, and then moved to Japan, where he created a larger Indian National Army, which fought against the allies. The future president of Indonesia Ahmed Sukarno actively collaborated with the Japanese, and the leader of the Burmese National Movement of Aun San created the manpower of the independence of Burma. In the same way, many leaders of anti -colonial liberation movements in Asia and Africa received assistance from Stalin - either directly or through the Comintern controlled by him. Mao Zedong and Ho Shi Min - these are only the most striking examples.
But all these and many other leaders of national liberation movements, sometimes guilty of ethnic purges and in other crimes, in their countries they honor and will honor as heroes, because the very existence of these countries as independent states is associated. Bandera is such a hero for the Western, but to a large extent for central Ukraine. And no one will throw it out of history and will demifologize it there. After all, if you remove the figures of Bandera, Shukhevich and other Ukrainian nationalists, it turns out that Putin, Medvedev and their environment are absolutely right, when they consider independent Ukraine a kind of "geopolitical misunderstanding" and strive to return it to the bosom of the empire. Undoubtedly, it is necessary to honestly indicate both errors and crimes of these leaders. But if you recognize them all by negative heroes of history, then the ideal world order should be recognized as the eternal preservation of the colonial empires, including the Russian one.
Now in Ukraine itself there is a split about Bandera, Shukhevich and others between the East and the West. And in national-cultural terms, Ukraine will be united when in the east they recognize the heroes of Bandera with Shukhevich, and in the West-Soviet commander-Ukrainians Vatutin and Malinovsky. But for this, more than one generation of Ukrainians should be replaced.