
The Military War between Russia and Belarus has not yet ended, and the gas is already looming on the horizon - this may be the Kremlin’s answer that Alexander Lukashenko ignored the CSTO summit in Moscow. Minsk threatens to introduce elements of border and customs control on the border with Russia. Commented by Boris Nemtsov, Julia Latynina, Dmitry Oreshkin.
Boris Nemtsov , member of the Bureau of Movement "Solidarity":
In principle, Lukashenko, of course, applies to Russia as a raw materials appendage and the dairy cow. Lukashenko’s regime was supported by Putin throughout his reign. Putin gave Belarus subsidies from five to ten billion dollars a year - in fact, these subsidies allowed Lukashenko to pay pensions, KGB to support, a repressive apparatus and so on. This regime, it exists at the expense of Russian money. If now in the Kremlin they realized that they no longer want to maintain the regime, then Lukashenko will have problems. Can he deal with these problems or not?
Lukashenko, albeit a finished scoundrel, but a person is very dodgy and tenacious. I do not remember that after the tantrum and wars he lost power - this has never happened over the past 15 years. So you can’t take it with your bare hands, we have too weak power to deal with Lukashenko. Lukashenko will now count on the help of the West and on the reforms. He will be forced to carry out reforms - privatization, for example, he will be forced to compensate for the shortage that will arise with the cessation of subsidies from Russia. But our regime cannot defeat Lukashenko, because he himself is the same. A raven of a crow will not turn off the eyes.
Julia Latynina , journalist:
The funniest in this whole story is that, in the framework of a certain policy of double -huminces, we declare on the same day that we will join the WTO along with Belarus and Kazakhstan, and then we begin to shout that Lukashenko was baked, does not want to be president and so on. All experts, including your submissive servant, have long said (for this you do not have to be a seer) that Mr. Lukashenko will take how much it is possible to take money for the recognition of South Ossetia and Abkhazia, and then throw it. Moreover, it is quite obvious that Lukashenko will outplay us, because among the rogue countries the greatest outcast always wins. In a situation where the country lives in a certain invented world of external enemies, Lukashenko, who says that this is all because the Russian oligarchs want to buy Belarusian sour cream, has an enchanting advantage before us. For all the inadequacy of the behavior of our political leadership, we do not reach the oligarchs who encroached on sour cream. We are not Lukashenko, not Ahmadinejad, not North Korea. In a game called "who is more scumbag" defeats more scumbag.
I do not think that it will end with something serious. After all, we already had a lot of exacerbations with Lukashenko, including accompanied by personal insults at Vladimir Vladimirovich. But for some reason, insults that would not have rolled from Khodorkovsky, nor from Bush, or from Obama, from Lukashenko each time bought safely, and again quiet and surface came.
The previous time, when Putin, still the president, flew to Minsk to sign a new union agreement, he brought with him absolutely all the highest officials - Mironov, Gryzlov and others - as well as two different options for the contract. One assumed that Belarus would simply receive the next grandmothers, and the other that Belarus and Russia form an union that could simply cancel the presidential election. Then Lukashenko did not even meet Putin at the airfield, Putin came to his residence, they sat there until the morning, and then said that they were discussing only a loan. By the way, Lukashenko received a loan then. Once again, he brilliantly used his technique: he all the time promises to marry Russia, but, of course, he never comes out, because he is a dictator who is good alone. His idea of independence is like worms in the intestines: the worm depends on the intestines, but the intestines are still.
Experience shows that we swallowed this from Lukashenko many times and slowly calmed down. Just like from Iran. We constantly get absolutely humiliating stories with Iran, who, of course, understands that we are not his ally in the strategic sense of the word, if only because Putin, of course, is beneficial for Iran’s relationship with the West to be tense. At the same time, the price of oil is high and the gas pipeline from Iran is not built.
But countries such as Russia, Iran, Venezuela, North Korea, Belarus, they are allies in the sense that they live in one crazy house. They are neighbors in the ward, and everyone is very different: someone considers himself Napoleon, someone believes that he will break him a glass and damned West, someone believes that he is a Genghis Khan. They will always unite against Russia. But when it comes to showdowns between them, the one who considers himself Napoleon, and the one who considers himself glass will never agree among themselves.
Dmitry Oreshkin , political scientist:
All these words Lukashenko and Putin about statehood, about the power, about the people are words, and the essence of the matter is in political interests. Lukashenko wanted to be the head of Russia, he was always interested only in his personal power. In those days when it seemed to him that he could extend his power to Russia, he was a supporter of the Union State. And now he understands that this is impossible, that Putin wants to extend his power to Belarus, to force her to obey his older brother, for example, to recognize South Ossetia and Abkhazia.
Putin has his own logic: he pays Lukashenko to 5 billion dollars of oil and gas subsidies, and does not receive political subordination in exchange; Accordingly, he feels a desire to bent Lukashenko, because he takes the money, but does not fulfill his promises. He is trying to prohibit the import of milk, somehow Lukashenko still step on the corn. In response, he tries to step on the corn to Putin, that is, Russia: he introduces customs restrictions, says that Belarusians will go to the dugouts, but will not obey, they will pour milk on the street, if only to sell Russia, since it does not buy, and so on. And for sure he will do so, since he completely controls the life of Belarusians.
Putin proceeds from the fact that he will light an economic vise - and Lukashenko’s regime will fall apart. And this is not a fact at all: in this regime, for example, there is a Korean People's Democratic Republic, and I will not say that he feels great, but Kim Jong Ir is feeling good.
We have a completely logical process of the appearance of enemies around Russia. This, it seems to me, is a great merit of Putin's foreign policy. We can talk about the machinations of the West for a long time, but we see de fact that in the Putin era, relations with Ukraine have reached the crisis, relations with Georgia reached the war, relations with Belarus worsen. These "attempts to dictate" (if you use the Soviet term) that Putin makes, meet a consistent hostility, uneatheity to meet from the CIS. Already, Uzbekistan slowly took and refused to go to the CSTO.
This is a failure policy, the Putin's failure policy, which proceeds from the fact that Belarus has dependence on Russia, while it has long been gone. She was only in that era when people were afraid that the enemies would strike a nuclear blow to them, and thought they needed defense. Now they do not need, Lukashenko wanted to spit on the CSTO - he knows that no Western Europe will occupy it. But at the same time, he remarkably speculates that the entire air defense is territorially located in Belarus. And Putin knows very well that the West will not attack Russia, but he is a security forces, so he uses this, and Lukashenko breds it: there is no price, he says, protection from the West, and he himself goes to the west for the next loans. He is not afraid of the West, but he is trying to intimidate us that the air belt will collapse.
This is an absolutely natural continuing process of the bunning of Putin’s real authorities, because it is focused on power tactics, expressed in aggression against the given world, first of all. And the Western world suggests that Putin cannot offer - non -interference and at the same time loans on preferential terms, while Putin is trying to put pressure on by force. It turns out a catastrophic situation in which Russia cannot offer anything positive of Belarus, nor Ukraine, nor Georgia, nor Moldova, but it can scare and offer a negative - that is, punish. There is strength to punish, but there is no strength to attract.
Putin punishes: he punished Georgia and he himself ended up in fools with unrecognized republics, tried to punish Ukraine, which is harder, of course, because it would always get out. Now trying to punish Belarus. This is a repeat of the Soviet model of the world, which will lead to a natural result - decay, split, separation. Now Russia will also hate Russia in Belarus, they will certainly - Lukashenko controls all the media, so there now such a wave of anti -Russian sentiments will go, worse than in Ukraine.