About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Newsletter
About RIMA
For researchers
Collection
Kronika Project
About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Date
07/14/2008
Author
Hidden
Source
New Times
Preserved copy
Internet Archive
Translated material

Who rules the world

This question is the subject of constant discussion in countries that are still on their knees and that are just getting up from them. After watching G-8 leaders meet in Hokkaido, The New Times turns to experts

Can the G8 be called a world government?

Yegor Gaidar, director of the Institute for the Economy in Transition: The G8 has always been a soft and informal institution that does not have its own apparatus and does not make decisions, although it is certainly important. The fact that now many issues are being discussed without the participation of countries that are not members of the G8 (for example, the exchange rate of the yuan without the participation of China) is somehow strange. But it's important to strike a balance here. After all, if this informal club is made too broad, it will cease to be an effective institution. But if the club does not gradually expand, it will break away from reality.

Dmitry Rogozin, Russian plenipotentiary to NATO: They (G-8) do not consider themselves a world government. And they do not gather at all in order to pose as a world government, but to discuss the problems of countries that have global influence.

Rose Gottemoeller, director of the Carnegie Moscow Center, former Deputy Secretary of Energy for the United States: Not at all. This, of course, is a very influential group, but still they have their own affairs, their own governments and different forms of communication. I will say more: sometimes the meetings of the two leaders are more important than such multilateral summits as the G8.

Leonid Mlechin, columnist for the TVC channel: No. These are old myths. In the past, the Soviet Union thought that the Americans were the world government. The Americans thought they were ours. But there are no world governments and cannot be. Oleg Nechiporenko, Colonel of the Foreign Intelligence Service of the KGB of the USSR, retired: No, because there are too many game options. Summits are a decor, a podium, an interactive show on a global scale.

Evgeny Gavrilenkov, Chief Economist at Troika Dialog Investment Company: No. The government makes certain decisions and laws that are binding on society. The G8 format is simply a discussion of current problems by leaders of countries. This summit is more like a club, somewhat similar to the Davos forum, although a much wider range of countries is represented in Davos. The G8 is, of course, good, but there are over 200 countries in the world, and it is clear that representatives of the G-8 cannot take into account the interests of other players.

Alexander Dugin, leader of the Eurasian Union: From a functional point of view, the G8 is, of course, a kind of prototype of a world government. From a legal point of view, this is a club of major powers, arbitrarily chosen, not elected and (therefore) illegitimate, having no legal status, unlike other organizations. The fact that Russia is included in the G-8 is a sop thrown at the time to Yeltsin. There is nothing to condemn here, the rules in each club are determined by the owners. However, this is also proof that Russia is regaining its status.