
Fedor Lukyanov
The editor -in -chief of the magazine
"Russia in global policy"
At a meeting of the contact group (USA, Russia and four Western European countries) last Wednesday, its participants expressed their intention to proceed to the new round of negotiations immediately. Three intermediaries are representatives of Russia, the United States and the European Union. None of them will have the authority to develop a document on the status, which was endowed with the special envoy of the UN Marty Akhtisaari. Akhtisaari himself admitted that his mission is over.
Belgrade regarded the return to negotiations as a historical victory of Serbia and Russia. Indeed, the “blitzkrieg” to proclaim the independence of Kosovo, which was counted six months ago, did not work. The uncompromising position of Moscow discouraged the Western powers, who were sure that Russia would bargain and agree. The Kosovo problem has become a question for the Kremlin - who determines the rules of the game in the international arena. Be that as it may, the Serbs have no grounds for glee. Because, despite the delay, the result is known.
Negotiations with knowingly
- a well -known result -
![]() |
The fate of Kosovo will now seem to be decided by Belgrade and Primetin themselves, that is, directly interested parties. In fact, the process finally turned into a game of ambitions of the great powers.
Positions do not allow a compromise: Kosovarov will not suit anything but independence, Serbs agree to everything except her. The Prime Minister Kosovo Agim Chek has already announced the date of the proclamation of independence-November 28. And the Serbian parliament with the overwhelming majority of votes adopted a resolution that the region is an integral part of Serbia.
If the external intermediaries exerted coordinated pressure on both sides, there would be a theoretical hope for "coercion to the world." However, the contact group is divided. Russia is tough on the side of the Serbs, the EU and the USA - on the side of the Albanians. Therefore, both will stand to death, feeling the support of the powers that be.
Among the mediators there is no unity even relative to the main canvas and duration of negotiations. Russia believes that the Akhtisaari plan is no longer discussed. But there is no deadline and cannot be, the dialogue should continue until the result is achieved. Western participants do not see alternatives to the existing document, while the duration is determined in four months. That is, negotiations will end just by November 28.
Traditional
- The Balkan redistribution? -
The idea of the Kosovo section - to “cut off” the Serbian enclave in the north and give to Belgrade, and to proclaim the rest of the sovereign state is mentioned by some experts as a possible compromise. An even more radical option is to allow the Republic of Serbian, which now, in accordance with the Father's Agreements of 1995, is part of Bosnia and Herzegovina, reunite with the "main" Serbia.
All these speculative constructions are quite in the spirit of the Balkan tradition. The story is known about how the heads of Croatia and Serbia Frano Tujman and Slobodan Miloshevich in the midst of the Bosnian war were drawn at the napkin, the contours of territories by which two leaders could conclude a deal. In reality, the redistribution of administrative borders will lead to chaos. The proposal to separate the Mitrovitsa, where the majority of the population, the Serbs, already caused a symmetrical reaction of the Kosovo authorities: then, they say, let's discuss the accession of the Serbian Valley of Presevo, where the Albanians also live. Well, if you touch Bosnia, with such difficulty blinded from ethnic flaps, then the whole process of the Balkan settlement will most likely have to start again ... “Compensation” to the Serbs for the loss of Kosovo will mean the final and irrevocable celebration of the ethnic principle of state construction, which over again plunged the Balkans into the feud.
- Scenario for the future -
If nothing extraordinary happens, then the Kosovo script is approximately understandable. Four months of negotiations will end to no avail. Russia will insist on continuing the dialogue, the West will try to return the decision to the UN Security Council in order to obtain a legitimate sanction to recognize Kosovo. There, however, the same problem is the Veto Moscow.
In this case, the US State Department warned: with or without the consent of Russia, but Kosovo will be independent.
In other words - in the case of the failure of all diplomatic attempts, Washington will go to a unilateral recognition of the new state, as soon as the local government proclaims it. True, during the last visit to the United States of the leaders of the region, they said that it was not necessary to rush and even more so should not make sudden movements without consultations with the Americans. But here is a matter of tactics, not strategies. In order to relieve yourself as much as possible for the consequences, Washington needs to exhaust all attempts to solve the issue within the framework of the international legal field.
The unilateral proclamation of Kosovo will split the European Union. Officially, Brussels supports the self -determination of Kosovars. But it was assumed that it will occur within the framework of a strict and agreed on the supranational level of the procedure. The prospects of crushing existing states had not previously enthusiastically among many Europeans. Without a legitimate and clearly spelled out foundation, this really smells of a precedent. And for a number of European countries it is unacceptable.
Independence Kosovo:
- whose bowl on the scales -
Will pull more?
The UN mission in Kosovo is already wondering how many governments recognize independence.
In the Western world, a negative position will definitely take:
• Spain (due to Basque separatism)
• Greece and Cyprus (due to the unrecognized Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus; in addition, Athena has long been embarrassed by the presence of a sovereign country named Macedonia, which coincides with the name of the historical province of Greece)
• Slovakia and Romania (due to large Hungarian minorities)
• Belgium (because of the problems between Wallons and Flemings)
• France (because of Corsica)
Recognize independence:
• USA
• Great Britain
• Germany
• Italy
Most likely, this will be done in Scandinavia, however, the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Sweden Karl Bildt, a brilliant specialist in the Balkans, before his appointment to the official post last year, warned Kosovo's hasty recognition. Eastern and Central Europe will follow in the US fairway, although the Polish President Lech Kachinsky, a believing Christian and conservative, somehow mentioned that the integrity of Serbia should be preserved.
In the rest of the world, the independence of Kosovo is recognized:
• Türkiye and most Muslim states
Do not recognize:
• China (Taiwan)
• Russia
• Azerbaijan (Karabakh), Moldova (Transnistria), Ukraine (Crimea), Georgia (Abkhazia and South Ossetia) - all of them themselves can easily be in the position of Serbia.
On the contrary, Armenia (again Karabakh) would be at hand.
- In a bite -
A unilateral proclamation of Kosovo turns the situation into a gambling game with an unpredictable outcome. The process of rapprochement of Western Balkans with the European Union will stall for a long time. As an organization, the EU can hardly begin the planned plan of Akhtisaari “supervision” for a new state. Therefore, you will have to look for workarounds and appoint someone who, in the absence of the UN and the EU, will take responsibility for the territory. The UN Security Council will once again demonstrate its powerlessness in the face of the discord of the key powers.
But such a scenario is generally satisfied with Washington and Moscow. America will fulfill its promise - Kosovars suffering from the yoke of the dictator Milosevich will gain independence. Russia will demonstrate principles - we have done everything we could. In addition, the destruction of the legitimate “fabric” in such a delicate issue as the boundaries, unties the hands in case the Kremlin still has a desire to expand the territory.
All this promises to Europe the hearth of instability, and the world - confirmation of how much the existing rules and boundaries are.