
To the television discussion Nikolai Svanidze and Sergey Kurginyan in the program "Historical process"
Everyone who is trying in a public controversy with Kurginyan to oppon him from the standpoint of morality and the truth of a historical fact, are doomed to failure. Kurginyan and his “witnesses” cannot be taken or fragmented, and they will always interpret the truth of the fact in their own way. With them, of course, it is better not to discuss at all for reasons that are clear to all honest cardigors. But if you still got into the discussion, several important points should be taken into account.
These people mainly deny any moral side of history, but see only the so -called progressive, sovereign and patriotic perspective. They consider only a strong state a positive criterion for development. The means of achieving the goal are not important to them: for them it is not power in truth, especially in morality, but the truth - in strength. Their conservatism, in many ways, totalitarian, their patriotism is nationalist, their redness of brown.
Everything else, as I said, is a couple of Shulera tricks. Firstly, the history of Russia, from the point of view of the horrors of tsarism and Stalinism, is not unique and not precedent, and, secondly, any criticism of these regimes is anti-national, anti-state, antipatriotic. In addition to this, two or three simple slope, like a professional boxer: not to pronounce the word “justify”, constantly stipulate that the murders and meanness themselves are badly, and even sympathize with the victims. But, in fact, to consider them costs, always demand the “complete” truth and appeal to the people.
What can be opposed to such a position? Nothing. How to explain the cannibal that there are such bad things for yourself? After all, this is his usual food. It remains only to hope that there are more vegetarians around. But, judging by the stable final figures-percentes after discussions with Kurginyan, there is little hope for it.
Of course, I also think that "Stalin has not died." And I am also sure that without the decolinization of public consciousness - and this is primarily his humanization, the recognition of the inalienable human rights and the rule of law - no qualitative changes in people's lives in our country will occur. Another thing is that all individual noble impulses are doomed, in my opinion, to failure. So we have already instructed that without a clear, clear and consistent state policy, in particular, nothing will change in this matter. And ambiguity will always be in the hand of Kurginyan and like him.
They love to refer to international experience, for example, the French Revolution. So the prosecutor of the French Revolution Fukier de Teveville, being the main prosecutor in trials, came up with the principle of "Amalgama". It consisted in the fact that during one trial, several people were judged simultaneously who had nothing to do with each other, and really guilty, and obviously innocent: royalists and thieves, political opponents and the finalized military - all at the same time. So judged, for example, Danton. This principle of re-sorceress is still in use-all in one heap, “transfer the shooters”, you look, some dirt will stick, maybe, and people are confused. Kurginyan often resorts to this prosecutor's reception. So during the first transfer to the RTR on the topic “Legal Protection” he was told about Thoma-Magnitsky, and he was about the heremo-Brauder.
By the way, Kurginyan never departs from the prepared scenario plan and, so that anyone speaks, will stubbornly bend his line, turning, if not “to the degree and the world”, then at least to his witnesses and audience of fans of his acting and distinguishing gift. And he is always the prosecutor in the court of history.
I understand the noble pathos of Nikolai Svanidze. But I think that one of his film from the series “Historical Chronicles” is much more useful than all this is a ristalism with Kurginyan. In addition, I am afraid that it may not get into the struggle of ideas, not into a duel for the minds of our fellow citizens, but in a passionate, in kind of end in the end of the Kurginyan. But this cannot be done in any case. Really, he is not worth it.
... By the way, about the “Magnitsky case”, which was discussed directly on the “historical process”. The Investigative Committee of Russia officially assigned the responsibility for the death of the British Investment Fund of Hermitge Capital to Sergey Magnitsky for two people - the doctor who treated him and the curator of the prison medical unit. On Friday, the laboratory assistant “Butyrki” Larisa Litvinova and the deputy chief of the insulator for therapeutic and preventive work of Dmitry Kratov was charged. The first - in causing death by negligence due to improper performance of professional duties (part 2 of article 109 of the Criminal Code, up to three years in prison). The second - into the negligence, which entailed by negligence of the death of a person (part 2 of Art. 293, up to five years in prison).
So, the "switchmen" were found. Whether there will still be the accused, let's see - the investigation continued until August 24. “Legal security” in our country is still unpredictable as its past.