The dispute over who owns the rights to the world-famous macaque selfies - her or the owner of the camera - has flared up with renewed vigor.

In June 2011, the Celebes macaque, a crested baboon named Naruto from the Tangkoko-Batuangus-Dua Saudara Nature Reserve near Bitung on the island of Sulawesi (Indonesia), became famous throughout the world and made famous photographer David Slater.
The monkey took several pictures with Slater's camera while pressing the shutter button. Some of them turned out to be unusable, but several were successful. The photographer licensed them and subsequently published them, captioning them as “monkey selfies.”
Thus, Slater launched a long-term and ongoing debate on copyright issues. And, if initially the question boiled down to whether the photographer could be considered the author of the famous photographs, then the dispute later turned around the thesis of whether the baboon Naruto could have the rights to his self-portrait.
In 2014, photographs of Naruto appeared on Wikimedia Commons. The Wikimedia Foundation, which owns the project, has repeatedly refused to remove them at Slater's request, arguing that the photographer cannot have any rights to the images. According to the foundation, macaque selfies are in the public domain, like a piece of non-human art.
Slater, in contrast, argued that he was rightfully credited as the author of the photo because he had the artistic intention - he deliberately left the camera so the monkeys could play with it and thus "designed the photo", meaning that the macaques could click release button.
The photographer noted that he only managed to earn about two thousand pounds (150 thousand rubles) in the first year of publication of the photographs, and after they appeared on Wikipedia, no one else was interested in them. So, according to Slater, for this episode alone he lost approximately 10 thousand pounds of income (770 thousand rubles).
If I were given one pound for every use of these photographs, I would probably already have 40 million pounds in my pocket.
David Slater, photographer
At the end of 2014, the US Copyright Office put an end to the dispute by officially declaring that works created by animals cannot be subject to copyright.
The US Copyright Office will register an original work of authorship, provided that the work was created by a person.
The Bureau will not register works created by nature, animals or plants.
from the US Copyright Office
In the list of possible options for such works, the bureau just mentioned photographs taken by a monkey, paintings drawn by elephants, as well as wooden driftwood that changed its shape and became smooth in the ocean.
In its commentary, the Bureau, just in case, made it clear that, by analogy, it will not consider applications for registration of works created by supernatural forces, although it may register the work “if the author in the application indicates that he was inspired by the divine spirit.”
In September 2015, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) sued Slater on behalf of Naruto the macaque, citing the baboon as the rightful owner of the copyright in the photographs.
Primatologist Antje Engelhardt acted as a next friend in this case, a special person usually appointed to represent children or people with developmental disabilities who would not be able to sue without outside help.
PETA demanded that all fees for the use of Naruto photographs be directed to the benefit of the monkey and its relatives in the reserve, and also expressed its readiness to administer the receipt of funds. The environmentalists' claim was supported by the fact that the species of monkey that made Naruto famous is in danger of extinction.
During the trial, which was already very unusual for American legal practice, another circumstance became clear, which caused a new stream of jokes from observers. Turns out PETA was sued by the wrong monkey. Slater described Naruto as a female macaque, while environmentalists identified the plaintiff as a male crested baboon.
In January 2016, District Judge William Orrick, hearing the case, concluded that Naruto had no standing to sue and dismissed the case on that basis. The question of whether a monkey can have copyright on a photograph it creates remains unanswered.
Dissatisfied with the handling of the case, PETA appealed the court's decision. The organization's lawyer, Jeff Kerr, said he still believes Naruto should receive a copyright "if possible under U.S. law."
By granting image rights to this monkey, the court could - for the first time in history - declare the animal to be the owner of the property, rather than the property itself.
Jeff Kerr, lawyer
On July 12, 2017, the San Francisco Court of Appeal began considering the merits of the complaint. Slater, embroiled in years of legal battles, admitted that he was broke: this time he could not even afford a plane ticket to attend the hearing. The photographer, who still made money as a freelancer, noted that he was unable to replace broken equipment and still had not paid the lawyer who defended him in 2015.
I'm thinking about walking dogs. I don't even have money to pay taxes.
David Slater, photographer
The court hearing (video recording is available on the court’s website) lasted two and a half hours. During this time, the parties discussed issues that caused many ironic remarks from journalists and network users.
The meeting discussed whether PETA has a close enough relationship with Naruto to represent him in court, what value a written copyright notice issued to the macaque community would have for the baboon, and what actual harm the monkey would actually suffer if it were not recognized as the subject of copyright. .
One of the judges noted that Naruto has virtually no way to receive or keep money. Also, the monkey cannot suffer reputational losses. There is no evidence of how copyright recognition would help Naruto in any way - he has no bank account and no tax benefits.
Another judge suggested considering how the copyright, if it were recognized in Naruto, could pass to the author's heirs.
Are there such concepts as law and lawlessness in the Naruto world? Are Naruto's descendants "children" as defined by law?
Carlos Bea, judge
Commenting on the results of the meeting, Slater said that he was perplexed by the American judicial system. The only consolation, he said, was that this story helped save the crested baboons from extinction. One single photograph was enough to cause a powerful public outcry and draw attention to the problem.