In "Hedgehog" there is a real "cabinet" about the current so-called "dissident movement", its role in the political process, its future. I’ve been feeling like an object of this discussion for a long time now and I couldn’t stand it – I’m becoming a subject.
The style of discussion is quite Bolshevik: if he is a dissident, he has no place in politics. Moreover, they say, dissidents have never succeeded in anything (meaning in politics). Such people are impotent from politics, and we should be proud of this. And if someone succeeds, then he is no longer a dissident, but a talker, an opportunist, etc.
Let's define the terms. Dissident – “dissident”. This is not an absolute concept, it is secondary. Always implied - in relation to what? Obviously - to the dominant ideology, universally binding or dominant in society. Just a dissident, “in life” - this is already a diagnosis.
Dissidents in Soviet times were people who did not accept the totalitarian Soviet regime. They did not join the CPSU or left it and built their lives, neglecting the preferences of party members. Those who chose the path of public service and political activity were subjected to persecution and repression. These are Andrei Sakharov, Yuri Orlov, Vladimir Bukovsky, Sergei Kovalev and many others. We are proud of them, but none of them had experience in public administration or at least experience in managing a large production facility, a large team. Only party members were allowed to hold such positions. But there were also dissidents within the CPSU, I would call them “system dissidents.” These are Alexander Yakovlev, Boris Yeltsin, Yuri Afanasyev, Gavriil Popov, Anatoly Sobchak and others. Most of them, at least at the first stage of perestroika, believed in the possibility of transforming the totalitarian Soviet system into socialism “with a human face.”
Only the unification of these two groups of dissidents and their numerous supporters allowed the peaceful democratic revolution to take place in the early 90s. Naturally, it was mainly representatives of “systemic dissidents” who came to the levers of executive power. That is why the state government system has largely retained its “soviet” character. By the way, this was not the case in Poland. The Solidarity trade union, having been underground for more than ten years, during this time trained personnel to govern the country in conditions of political and economic competition. In the new Poland, many former dissidents actually came to power.
Now let's see what prospects the democratic movement in Russia has now. Dissidents in relation to the modern authoritarian government are both human rights activists, many of whom have an “anti-Soviet” past, and a new generation of politicians who have real management experience, gained mainly in the 90s. If dissidents came to power now, among them, undoubtedly, there would be professionally prepared people to run the state. But the number of modern non-systemic opposition and its influence on social processes in Russia is still insufficient. By the way, things were the same with dissidents in the late 80s in the USSR.
A necessary additional condition for the peaceful transformation of the regime built by Putin would be the emergence of a systemic opposition to the authoritarian regime, “systemic dissidents.” At the same time, it is obvious that such an opposition should not be built at the expense of “defectors” from the dissident camp. It is quite possible that the so-called “Medvedev” majority is now laying claim to the role of systemic opposition to Putin’s authoritarianism. At least, such statements were made. Wait and see.
As for the liberal, democratic opposition, it faces one task - to unite as much as possible within the framework of one organization. Such an organization is already being formed - this is the United Democratic Movement “Solidarity”.
Addressing the readers of EZh, I want to say the following. If you are against the revival of totalitarianism in Russia, if you share basic democratic values and human rights, then create cells of the Solidarity movement and join the movement.
The author is a member of the Federal Bureau of the Solidarity movement