
Well, Julia Leonidovna again appropriated the right to decide on his own who is worthy to live in this world, and who is better to kill or at least put in jail. In support of this right, a number of apparently indisputable, from the point of view of the author, are given examples of obvious justification of violence. Let me challenge this evidence.
First about the terms. None of the Libertarians have ever affirmed the inadmissibility of violence in general. Only aggressive violence is unacceptable. Protection from aggression is no longer aggression, and, therefore, not only acceptable, but also necessary. However, I would formulate this differently: “Protection against violence is not violence. This is the use of force, but not violence. ” In this case, violence is considered the use of force only against who himself initially does not use power. Protection from violence (or, as the majority of Libertarians say, aggressive violence) is not only the right, but also the moral debt of every citizen. Moreover, regardless of whom this violence (aggressive violence) comes: from a bully, from a maniac, from a cop or from the general prosecutor.
So, based on this simple principle, a woman who killed the rapist, defending himself from him, is undoubtedly right. And the farmer, who crushed six neighbors because they were supporters of slavery, of course, the criminal - no one attacked him. With Stauffenberg and Kaplan is more difficult. Neither Hitler nor Lenin attacked them directly. But they attacked their peoples - respectively, German and Russian, among which were their (Stauffenberg and Kaplan) close, and potentially they themselves. That is, it is a real threat and real aggression. So it is possible to qualify their actions as protection against aggression, but this requires consideration and analysis of circumstances.
Well, references to literary and mythological characters look completely ridiculous. Voldermort, Kashchei Immortal, Gorgon Medusa and other wonderful images are not real people. To raise the question of human rights in their regard is even more anecdotal than to put it in relation to sharks or crocodiles. Are you not going to protect the rights of bugs and cockroaches? Maybe they can’t be killed either?
As a result, the question of the boundaries of the use of force, from the point of view of libertarians, has a clear answer. If you or your neighbor attack you or your neighbor, defend yourself, including using force, it is not only possible, but also necessary. And this is by no means the prerogative of the state, but the duty of every citizen. For the state, or rather its law enforcement agencies, to protect citizens from violence is an obligation, and not an exclusive right at all.
“In order for evil to win, it is enough to deprive the ability of the ability to defend yourself.” One cannot disagree with this. But there is another way to deliver evil to the evil-to allow someone to decide for others that there is good and what is evil. Yes, to every person, by virtue of his consideration of God, the ability to distinguish between good and evil is given. But everyone, whoever he is. As soon as we entrust someone alone or a group of people for everyone that there is good and what is evil, you can forget about freedom-you will get despotism. Freedom is, first of all, it is precisely the right of everyone for themselves to determine priorities in life. And the price of freedom is the danger that someone can choose evil and destructive priorities. This is their right. To deprive of which no one has no one in the right. Otherwise, someone may deprive such a right. Since there is no border here and cannot be. Society can only protect itself from the destructive actions of such persons. That's the law. But the law can only limit evil, prevent him from gobbling us. No law is able to establish good law. For, limiting evil, he thereby limits freedom.
Therefore, Andres Breivik and Mohammed Mera should be in prison. And those who publicly express their support should not. Society must protect itself. Protect by force if necessary. But only from violence, and not from incorrect opinions.
Photo by RIA Novosti